News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are people too flawed, ignorant, and tribal for open soci... by Animats on Saturday July 20, 2024 @05:20PM (#41020040)
> People of other countries aren't morally better, yet they are at a lesser risk of losing democracy than the US now is. Why is this? It's because the politicians there have to cooperate to form coalition governments.

Look at the mess in Israel at the moment. That's a coalition government in failure mode. Italy has coalition governments, but in recent years they seem to have coalesced into two main factions.

Re:Are people too flawed, ignorant, and tribal for open soci... by OutOfHere on Saturday July 20, 2024 @05:37PM (#41020182)
> Look at the mess in Israel at the moment. That's a coalition government in failure mode. Italy has coalition governments, but in recent years they seem to have coalesced into two main factions.

Coalition governments are intended to fail fast, then for new replacements to be wiser, to not repeat the old mistakes. Coalitions may make the government slightly more inefficient, but as soon as there is a hint of extremism, the coalition is bound to fail. It protects against real extremes. Factions can emerge, but they can't get carried away with instituting too many crazy ideas.

Re:Are people too flawed, ignorant, and tribal for open soci... by nerdix on Saturday July 20, 2024 @08:14PM (#41021347)
How do you explain the rise of Hitler with this theory?

The Weimar government was a semi-presidential system with multiple parties that required coalitions for the legislature to function.

The Nazi party won a plurality but never a majority of the vote in any election during the Weimar years. They formed a coalition with the right wing German National People's Party through which Hitler was able to rise to the position of Chancellor.

Of course, we know that the Nazis quickly seized power shortly after that and banned all political parties including, including the German National People's Party, were banned with a few months.

The German National People's Party was a radical anti-democratic party as well. Between the two parties, they received around 44% of the vote in 1932. If that many people in your country either openly or tacitly support the dissolution of democracy then your republic's days are numbered. The particular flavor of democracy that your government uses doesn't matter.

That's the situation the US is currently facing.

Re:Are people too flawed, ignorant, and tribal for open soci... by OutOfHere on Saturday July 20, 2024 @09:37PM (#41021704)
In theory, the coalition government could have not passed the Reichstag Fire Decree (followed by the Enabling Act), but they did get swayed and pass it. If such a mistake gets repeated, then yes, a coalition won't help. As such, a coalition is not foolproof.

Fortunately, to my knowledge, the US Constitution doesn't have a critical weakness like Article 48 of the Weimar Constitution which granted unusual emergency powers to the President.

In summary, it comes down to how many loopholes you can identify and patch before they get exploited. A proof solver might help.