News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mangrove trees are on the move, taking the tropics with them by refulgentis on Saturday July 20, 2024 @02:02PM (#41018343)
> I would not be surprised to see Mangroves at that latitude.

You should be! Per TFA: "60 miles north of its previously recorded range—by far the northernmost mangrove in the U.S"

IMHO each observation of a new out-of-range specimen will be unsurprising without remembering the poetic lessons of infinitesimals, ex. Ship of Theseus, if not the prosaics of infinitesimals themselves.

> It's probably more surprising that these areas aren't already subtropical.

Given my surprise at this comment, I think I may be missing the significance in the switch from unsurprising there's a new record for US mangrove latitude to surprising it wasn't already subtropical. Is a mangrove a sufficient condition for being subtropical? Is it a necessary condition? My understanding is Florida is firmly subtropical on all the tentpoles: hot summers, mild winters, and rarity of frosts (famously, enabling its orange farming).

> Climate change seems to reduce whatever factor caused the cooling there.

Occam's Razor would say this adds an unneeded factor of a previously-unknown-to-humanity outlier cooled state, to further an irrational argument that it isn't surprising.

There are no comments on this comment yet.