News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by Aurornis on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @08:23PM (#40991515)
> Conversely, my company, which interviewed me by having me write ‘for’ loops in all 12 or so languages listed on my CV during the technical interview, is a pretty decent place to work.

This is funny. I’ve interviewed so many candidates who think keyword stuffing their resume has no consequences, but then you get them in the interview and discover they couldn’t actually tell you much about the languages or frameworks they listed other than very high level descriptions.

When I do resume reviews for people I try to push back on some of the keyword stuffing, but there’s a lot of resistance. There’s a popular idea that resumes are just for tricking the ATS and nothing more, but then these people get in front of someone who actually wants to discuss their resume and it gets ugly fast.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by erik_seaberg on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @10:38PM (#40992021)
I will never forget the candidate around 2010 who came in claiming PostScript. Well, our interviewer started asking about stacks and clipping paths, and it quickly emerged that the candidate knew how to click Print > To File.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by xarope on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @11:25PM (#40992228)
I've done this before:

Me: you've listed Java as "Expert", perhaps you could discuss about <favorite footgun in project>

Interviewee: sweats for a bit, finally admits only used Java factory factory and copied lots of code

Me: ok great, let's move on, you've listed Rust as "Intermediate", lets...

Interviewee interrupts, admits they know how to spell Rust and watched a couple of videos of crabs

Re:Panic at the Job Market by KptMarchewa on Thursday July 18, 2024 @08:46AM (#40995072)
I've had a candidate that had Apache Spark on the resume, turns out he was sitting in a room with other people who were writing Spark jobs.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by kmoser on Thursday July 18, 2024 @02:03PM (#40998196)
I had a guy tell me he had experience with Apache's mod_rewrite module and, when asked what its purpose was, he said verbatim "It gives you, like, more commands and stuff."

Other questions were met with equally disastrous responses.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by bornfreddy on Friday July 19, 2024 @09:20AM (#41006267)
Wow, do you use Spark in production? I can't claim to have much experience with it, I just played around with it a loooong time ago, but I was impressed. I thought it went out of use along with Hadoop and HBase, glad to hear this is not the case. Are you hiring? :-D
Re:Panic at the Job Market by KptMarchewa on Friday July 19, 2024 @09:33AM (#41006394)
Out of use? Databricks is like 40 billion dollar company providing basically "managed Spark" platform.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by dennis_jeeves2 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @10:36PM (#40992012)
> I’ve interviewed so many candidates who think keyword stuffing

They do that because HR looks for it.

>frameworks they listed other than very high level descriptions.

Would you remember the details of the framework you worked on 10 years back? Especially give that in the 10 years you went through another 15 frameworks?

Re:Panic at the Job Market by vkou on Thursday July 18, 2024 @12:31AM (#40992533)
> They do that because HR looks for it.

You've described a beautiful symbiosis.

Half the people in the interviewing process see keyword stuffing as pointless bullshit, and only care if you can reverse a linked list in a language of your choice.

Half of them only care about keyword stuffing, and will send your resume in the shredder if you don't do it.

And the third half see anyone trying to avoid the nitpicks of the second half as a person to expose as a fraud.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by sensanaty on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:07AM (#40993515)
The problem is that HR is the first line of entry, and if you're not keyword stuffing every possible technology under the sun, they'll pass you on, because they don't know that being a python expert is fine for a Ruby job. So you have to put both down, lest the HR screen say "well they didn't specify Ruby, they don't make it through!"
Re:Panic at the Job Market by worble on Thursday July 18, 2024 @07:36AM (#40994638)
Yeah, I've actually had this happen before. I keyword stuffed my CV, then when I got to the interview stage, the actual tech lead quizzed me on it. I just replied honestly that while I had passing knowledge, I didn't actually know these things in detail and I did it just to get the interview. I think they appreciated the honesty, or at least could just relate to it. We tested the stuff I actually knew and got the job in the end.

It probably helped that I was just bullshitting the fringe cloud stuff, the actual languages/framework everyday related skills were all true.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by sensanaty on Thursday July 18, 2024 @09:43AM (#40995517)
My own HR people tell me it happens lol

I don't get to see the fat stack of resumes they get, only the stuff HR has already approved and passed on to me to further review. I asked them about their process, and they basically prioritize anyone who has the exact keywords on the job listing, and they more or less straight up ignore anyone who doesn't.

We had a lot of frontenders that HR filtered out because they only had React on their resume, but not Vue or Svelte (both of which are much simpler than React, so even a complete Vue/Svelte novice would do fine if they were good at React). Similarly when we were looking to fill a Ruby (NOT Ruby on Rails) dev, they filtered out people that didn't have specifically Ruby and instead had `Ruby on Rails`.

You can't even blame them, half of the stuff in the job listings sounds like complete mumbo-jumbo to anyone not directly involved with the stuff. After they told me about the Rails thing I sat down with the HR team and gave them a high-level overview on this stuff, but it still happens from time to time, especially when the job requirements/description changes every once in a while. Plus, the edge cases here (is someone good at Python OK to let through for the Ruby job? What if they have an Elixir background? Or just JS one? etc.) are basically infinite, and you can't educate them on every single possible variety of technologies out there.

The only real system would be to have the devs evaluate every resume that comes in, but that comes with its own set of problems, too.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by johnnyanmac on Thursday July 18, 2024 @06:50PM (#41000479)
I'm actually somewhat anti-AI given my domain, but this sounds like the exact kind of issue a LLM can be trained in a few weeks to do for the hiring manager. Not that braindead ATS keyword matching that's happening as of late. Actually language processing.

It was pretty much made to sift through bulks of data and idenitfy similar concepts, so it's kind of funny in this AI gold rush that I haven't heard of a proper example. The application and impact is obvious, and it's not like HR's only job is resume grokking so minimal displacement.