As a result, most behavioural interviews are ineffective and absolutely riddled with bias.
Good HR people are worth their weight in platinum. I used to work with one whose thumbs down became an automatic "no" from the team because we discovered that she was so good at reading people that everyone she didn't like inevitably threw off massive red flags in the rest of the interviews.
No one is building a panel around pleasing anyone. If you have a member of your team who is particularly skilled in any area, it would be foolish to not take advantage of it.
Do you think its better not to do them?
My assumption is that everyone does this, and the interview is largely a test to determine if you even know what a "good" answer would sound like. The assignment is to describe how you think an emotionally intelligent and mature person would act, and if you don't even know what that looks like then there's no way they're hiring you.
If you say "I repeatedly managed to singlehandedly save the day despite being surrounded by idiots" then you've done them a huge favor of letting them know you're a pain in the ass to work with. I would assume that most people know better than to admit to an interviewer that this is how they think, but I don't conduct these interviews so I'm not sure.
I interviewed at Netflix. The market is tough right now and they pay really well. I really wanted to pass.
I did great on their tech rounds. Their "culture round" is notoriously hard, people throw out advice like "read the culture memo". I did. Now I have no idea what I did "wrong" in the culture/behavioral interview with the first hiring manager, they passed, they gave me no feedback, but they still booked me for an interview with another team. I also failed with that hiring manager.
Is it because my "EQ" is bad?
> As far as I can tell, the “behavioral interview” is essentially the same as a Scientology intake session except, you know, for capitalism instead.
> A secondary goal of the “behavioral interview” is personality homogenization where companies want to enforce not hiring anybody “too different” from their current mean personality engram.
It really, REALLY does seem this way at many places.
You see, to do the behavioral interview properly the interviewer must have a psychological degree and a special training relating to these interviews. The hiring interview is a special situation for an interviewee, they act not like they do in a normal working circumstances. For example they tend to overthink questions, searching for the best answer that will be marked by the interviewer as a good answer. They incentivized to lie, because it is easy to find these questions in advance and to invent the best answers out, and no one ever will find out that it was a lie. So, the interviewer asked some questions and got some learned answers, how can they now interpret these answers and say something about the personality traits of the interviewee?
> I’d encourage OP to put some thought into this part for their own sake. You don’t need to make everyone feel better but if you show up with the attitude that you’re never wrong, then nobody will want to work with you. I know I don’t.
You advice is probably misplaced. The article is not a part of a job interview. So their EQ didn't show any failures, they wanted to rant and they had chosen the right place to do it. If he ranted at the interview, I'd agree that he needs to work on their EQ or self-control or something.
The comments here is full of diagnoses for the author, but I'm really reluctant to form any opinions about the author mind. It is just one article, that was probably written in a single take. What you see may be not the persistent personal traits, but situational and temporary state of mind. The article has a theme and the author provides examples to his points, and do you think he should provide examples against his points? Again: if they were writing a scientific paper, I would expect them to go through all the evidence, and to do it much more rigorous, but it is just the fucking blog post. Yes a long one, but still the blog post.
And on this basis I'd encourage the most commenters in the thread to work on their EQ. More specifically to read about Fundamental Attribution Error. People are largely driven by the situation they are in, but observers interpret behavior mainly in terms of enduring personal traits.
If you asked this question to me I'd think you are an idiot.
This is hilarious and I’m sad I’ve seen versions of this more than once.
Overall I enjoyed most of this article but disagree about the objection to behavioral interviews. I think they’re an important part of the modern hiring process but I will agree that the approach is sometimes done wrong by companies and individual interviewers.
its a test of EQ, if a simple question about past conflicts makes you this defensive then its exactly the type of thing it was meant to screen for. I’d encourage OP to put some thought into this part for their own sake. You don’t need to make everyone feel better but if you show up with the attitude that you’re never wrong, then nobody will want to work with you. I know I don’t.