News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sin in Doing Good Deeds by sokoloff on Thursday December 25, 2008 @06:51PM (#409842)
Did you read the article at all?

Take the case of the breast cancer charity which, from the article, was pulling in $71mm from charity walks using his services. They stopped using his services and continued the walks and are taking in $11mm now.

You might argue that several other variables might have also changed, but a 6.5x factor is hard to ignore.

Re:The Sin in Doing Good Deeds by quoderat on Thursday December 25, 2008 @10:23PM (#409924)
I read the article. I wouldn't call one anecdote data, though it's about 1/10,000 of a good start.
Re:The Sin in Doing Good Deeds by albertni on Thursday December 25, 2008 @10:33PM (#409928)
That's a little harsh. It was a pretty significant anecdote - a 6.5x decrease with the only clear change being Pallotta's company-charity being forcibly stopped from continued involvement. Is there room for other plausible reasons to have caused the drop? Definitely. And of course if, hypothetically, Pallotta's company-charity was involved with sufficiently many causes, you would even expect there to be at least one anecdote with such a substantial drop. But to call it "1/10,000 of a good start" is much more unreasonable and illogical than thinking the anecdote might be of worth.
Re:The Sin in Doing Good Deeds by DabAsteroid on Friday December 26, 2008 @01:55AM (#410029)
a 6.5x decrease

That would be negative 5.5 times, or 5.5 times below zero.

Re:The Sin in Doing Good Deeds by trominos on Friday December 26, 2008 @12:11AM (#409976)
You might not call it that, but one anecdote is indeed data. A very small amount, to be sure -- but it's all we've got.

Tiny amounts of data can almost never prove a particular theory correct (in sociology, at least), but you're quite simply wrong if you think we can't get anything out of them. This particular data -- datum, I guess -- certainly can't show that charity CEOs in general earn their keep, but it so blatantly contradicts your theory that I think it's safe for us to assume that you're incorrect.

Is it possible that "there are many qualified people in charity work who make barely-subsistence wages who would likely do an as-good or better job with far less pay" and that the story's CEO's departure caused an 85% loss in the charity's income? Yes, of course. But it's unlikely. At the very least it seems like there needs to be some kind of barrier to hiring those people -- maybe it's impossible to determine which of these minimum-wage earners is actually a highly competent manager.