It assumes home prices will rise equal to inflation which hasn’t been true in recent years
It doesn’t allow you to add monthly utilities for renting but assumes 100$/month for buying. I personally have never rented a place where all utilities were covered
It assumes quite high property taxes compared to what I pay
It assumes market returns of 4.5% which is true in a long term sense but not really in the short term
It assumes rents will increase 3% per year, configurable but not true in recent years
It factors in closing costs so I guess it’s assuming you will sell at the end of the period? This is a somewhat strange assumption to me. At the end of the period I could borrow against the value of the house without selling it for instance.
I think it’s a really good tool though I wish it had just a few more options to tweak, and that the defaults got updated to reflect current rates perhaps
It also assumes the SP500 only returns 5% a year while in practice historically it is closer to 10.
I've used it. It's not good.
If you asked someone to make a calculator that makes renting as attractive as possible - it would look similar to the NYT calculator.
It's not surprising this calculator comes from a city where the majority of people rent, and is read mainly by "elites" who live in areas where more people rent...
At the time, I lived in LA in this exact calculator convinced me that housing was a horrible investment in 2013.
Had I bought then instead of had my money in the S&P my net-worth would almost be triple what it is now.
Luckily, I'm doing fine either way, and did buy and lock in a 2.7% interest rate, after learning this calculator has some serious flaws and building a much more realistic spreadsheet to model it...