Re:Fed: Americans' wealth dropped 40 percent
by tomp on Monday June 11, 2012 @04:57PM
(#4096930)
they haven't really lost anything - they still own the same house, and no money, just as before(at the height at the bubble)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Fed: Americans' wealth dropped 40 percent
by SwellJoe on Monday June 11, 2012 @05:08PM
(#4097016)
A house that was purchased with $250k of debt, that is now only worth $150k, has cost the buyer $100k, for nothing. That is $100k of lost wealth to the buyer. The buyer purchased $250k worth of house, using future earnings, and now only owns $150k worth of house (but still owes $250k of future earnings). That is a devastating economic blow to a middle class family, and to dismiss it as "they haven't really lost anything" is simplistic and cruel.
They haven't lost anything, in the sense that savings appreciating slower than inflation is not losing anything, although few would suggest that this is not "losing" something.
What has been lost is choice and opportunity for an easily identified class people (homeowners in areas that could not sustain the demand for homes) on a relatively large scale. I, on the other hand, a renter who has most of his wealth in securities am not so much impacted: I only lost some liquidity in the few years it took for the stock market to bounce back.