For complex tasks like connecting AXI, SoC, memory, and custom IP components together, things like bussed wires and ports, as well as GUI configurators, make the process of getting something up and running on a real FPGA board much easier and quicker than if I had to do it all manually (of course, after I can dump the Tcl trace and move all that automation into reproducible source scripts).
I believe the biggest advantage of the Vivado block editor is the "Run Block Automation" flow that can quickly handle a lot of the wire connections and instantiation of required IPs when integrating an SoC block with modules. I think it would be interesting to explore if this idea could be successfully translated to other styles of visual programming. For example, I could place and connect a few core components and let the tooling handle the rest for me.
Also, a free idea (or I don't know if it's out there yet): an open-source HDL/FPGA editor or editor extension with something like the Vivado block editor that works with all the open source EDA tools with all the same bells and whistles, including an IP library, programmable IP GUI configurators, bussed ports and connections, and block automation. You could even integrate different HDL front-ends as there are many more now than in the past. I know Icestudio is a thing, but that seems designed for educational use, which is also cool to see! I think a VSCode webview-based extension could be one easier way to prototype this.
"Free idea: do all this work that it takes hundreds of people to do. Free! It's even free! And easy!"
Lol you must be one of those "the idea is worth more than the implementation types.
Data can instead be modeled as inputs which transform as they flow through a system, and possibly modify the system.
Right. Trying to map lines of code to blocks 1 to 1 is a bad use of time. Humans seem to deal with text really well. The problem becomes when we have many systems talking to one another, skimming through text becomes far less effective. Being able to connect 'modules' or 'nodes' together visually(whatever those modules are) and rewire them seems to be a better idea.
For a different take that's not circuit-based, see how shader nodes are implemented in Blender. That's not (as far as I know a) a Turing complete language, but it gives one idea how you can connect 'nodes' together to perform complex calculations: https://renderguide.com/blender-shader-nodes-tutorial/
A more 'general purpose' example is the blueprint system from Unreal Engine. Again we have 'nodes' that you connect together, but you don't create those visually, you connect them to achieve the behavior you want: https://dev.epicgames.com/documentation/en-us/unreal-engine/...
> I don't think there's many analogous situations in typical programming applications that call for timing diagrams
Not 'timing' per se (although those exist), but situations where you want to see changes over time across several systems are incredibly common, but existing tooling is pretty poor for that.
I've also always had an admiration for the Falstad circuit simulation tool[0], as the only SPICE-like simulator that visually depicts magnitude of voltages and currents during simulation (and not just on graphs). I reach for it once in a while when I need to do something a bit bigger than I can trivially fit in my head, but not so complex that I feel compelled to fight a more powerful but significantly shittier to work with IDE to extract an answer.
Schematics work really well for capturing information that's independent of time, like physical connections or common simple functions (summers, comparators, etc). Diagrams with time included sacrifice a dimension to show sequential progress, which is fine for things that have very little changing state attached or where query/response is highly predictable. Sometimes, animation helps restore the lost dimension for systems with time-evolution. But beyond trivial things that fit on an A4 sheet, I'd rather represent time-evolution of system state with timing diagrams. I don't think there's many analogous situations in typical programming applications that call for timing diagrams, but they are absolutely foundational for digital logic applications and low-level hardware drivers.
[0]: https://www.falstad.com/circuit/