Re:The Forth Methodology of Charles Moore
by astrobe_ on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:23PM
(#40948104)
> To simply spit out some code and without further thought accept the first barely working version of it
That's not exactly what TFA describes, though.
> there are situations, in which the engineer, provided they even get the right idea, can make their code reusable with little to no additional time needed, simply, because they know they they are doing and have experience with the matter
Maybe. Problem is, how do you know when you or someone else has enough experience to make those calls? I guess the only way is to try and try again. But if you go that route, you should really keep the score, that is, note down when you made a call and check later if you were right or wrong. It's easy to trick oneself though because the future is virtually infinite, so a decision to make e.g. something more reusable at "this little extra cost" can be indefinitely neither right nor wrong.
That's not exactly what TFA describes, though.
> there are situations, in which the engineer, provided they even get the right idea, can make their code reusable with little to no additional time needed, simply, because they know they they are doing and have experience with the matter
Maybe. Problem is, how do you know when you or someone else has enough experience to make those calls? I guess the only way is to try and try again. But if you go that route, you should really keep the score, that is, note down when you made a call and check later if you were right or wrong. It's easy to trick oneself though because the future is virtually infinite, so a decision to make e.g. something more reusable at "this little extra cost" can be indefinitely neither right nor wrong.