News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by MBCook on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:01PM (#40947904)
This sounds very stupidly dangerous. I’m amazed this is legal, and that people would do it in the first place.

I get wanting to win at all costs but this is nuts.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by its_ethan on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:05PM (#40947937)
I don't know what it is about cycling that seems to concentrate some of the most insane physiological manipulation (not sure if that's the right phrase tbh).

Other sports like baseball/tennis/etc seem to have some issues with like general steroids. But the level that cyclists go to always seems to exceed them by orders of magnitude.

I don't know how true it is, but I've heard that some cyclists had/have to set alarms throughout the night so they wake up to do jumping jacks to get their heart rates back up above the "artificial" 15bpm that their training + cocktail of drugs has caused.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by brandall10 on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:34PM (#40948191)
The other sports you listed provide much more strain on the muscoskeletal system and the cardio impact is bursty. But with cycling you have this amazingly efficient machine relieving that type of stress so it becomes more of an exercise of how efficiently the body can process oxygen and pump blood under constant duress.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by LargeWu on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:13PM (#40948009)
I think because there's less "skill" required, in the sense of hand-eye coordination, than ball sports. The predominant factor seems to be how hard and how long you can push yourself. Once you reach the human body's natural physical limits, chemical advantage seems like the only way to break through those.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by mertd on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:28PM (#40948144)
As a cyclist (albeit never raced), I want to get offended by this but I feel is largely correct. There is a lot of real time strategizing happening in road races however the marginal gains of simply having more Watts per kg for more hours trumps everything else.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:42PM (#40948255)
Bicycles are the most efficient form of transport... at moderate speeds. At elite level speeds you are so far down the exponental well of wind resistance that you need meticulous attention to aero savings and sustained power output. All of the possible aero gains permitted under the rules are already accounted for. That leaves power output as the only avenue for gaining a competitive advantage. No other sport has the same combination of antagonizing factors at play.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by its_ethan on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:24PM (#40948114)
This is an interesting thought, it makes sense intuitively.. I could see it being adjacent to why steroids are prevalent amongst body builders. After you've hit your "genetic wall" for size/strength, chemical advantage could seem like the only way to keep progressing.

It's interesting to see it play out in an "official" sport, rather than just individual workout/ "aesthetic" tournaments. Maybe they should add some more skill elements to major cycling races.. perhaps a slalom through the orange cones of a construction site every few miles? lol

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:42PM (#40948250)
Only someone who’s never cycled quickly could say there’s less skill involved. Try riding down the side of a mountain at 50mph and follow up your post.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by vorador on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:29PM (#40948159)
This is very wrong. These guys go downhill on small country roads very fast – sometimes over 100 kmh. You need deep riding skills to handle these speeds without getting injured.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by dtech on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:37PM (#40948218)
He didn't say no skill, he said less in comparison with other professional sports.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:43PM (#40948256)
Try riding down the side of a mountain at 50-70mph and tell me there’s less skill in that
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by its_ethan on Friday July 12, 2024 @03:19PM (#40948562)
For what it's worth, I don't think people are trying to say it's a zero skill sport. It's not an indictment of you or the sport.

I see the "argument" as: in sports like soccer or basketball, skills like dribbling or shooting accuracy don't have a skill "cap" and are generally uncorrelated to physiology. This is compared to the skill of descending a mountain at speed, which is dictated by how fast you can actually make yourself go, which is a matter of physiology.

It's not that strategy and skill don't exist in cycling, it's that raw power output (Watts per Kg) is ultimately the deciding factor once cyclists get to the skill cap of piloting their bike down a mountain.

So basically, could I cycle down a hill at 50-70mph? Absolutely not. But among the people who can, then the competitive advantage becomes how fast you can make yourself go down that hill.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by vorador on Friday July 12, 2024 @03:22PM (#40948587)
The competitive advantage is not physiological. Following your reasoning, that'd mean an F1 driver's competitive advantage is how fast they can push the pedals to get to 300kmph.

The real advantage is how fast you can navigate dangerous mountain roads which are narrow and have many hairpin turns.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by its_ethan on Friday July 12, 2024 @03:43PM (#40948734)
I don't know that that's the analogy you'd want to use. It is correct that an F1 driver's competitive advantage is how fast they can get to 300 kmph (or just accelerate in general, since there's skill/strategy involved as to when/where to accelerate). If we're following that reasoning... the engine is that competitive advantage, and we know that to be a significant factor because there are millions of dollars of engineering effort to optimize the cars they race. The reaction time of how fast you can push the pedal is an incredibly small part of that equation.

If you're on a bike, that competitive edge "engine" is the cyclist own physiology. Yes, how fast you can navigate the roads is part of it, but is it not the acceleration/max speed out of the hairpin turn that represents the lion's share of overall time? Rather than the fractions of seconds gained/lost in the timing of accelerations at the turn? I guess it depends on the length/ frequency of turns in the course.

Just out of curiosity, would you be defending the skill required to do cross country as vigorously as you are for cycling?

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Friday July 12, 2024 @04:42PM (#40949227)
> I don't think people are trying to say it's a zero skill sport.

I didn’t say you were, you were saying that there’s less skill involved, which is outright untrue.

> in sports like soccer or basketball, skills like dribbling or shooting accuracy don't have a skill "cap" and are generally uncorrelated to physiology.

Skill is highly correlated to physiology at the higher levels. Plenty of people practice as much as Messi, yet haven’t a fraction of his footballing ability.

> It's not that strategy and skill don't exist in cycling, it's that raw power output (Watts per Kg) is ultimately the deciding factor once cyclists get to the skill cap of piloting their bike down a mountain.

You’ve not watched the famous Pidcock descent then.

> the competitive advantage becomes how fast you can make yourself go down that hill.

Very little pedalling is involved at 60mph, it’s 100% skill.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by LargeWu on Saturday July 13, 2024 @04:29PM (#40956634)
> Skill is highly correlated to physiology at the higher levels. Plenty of people practice as much as Messi, yet haven’t a fraction of his footballing ability.

This is counter to your thesis. Messi's dominance doesn't come because he has elite physical characteristics. He's dominant because his level of skill with the ball at his foot is an outlier even among elites. It's not because he's pushing the physical limits of the human body.

There might be some variance in skill for elite riders, but I would guess the density curve of skill in that cohort is a very narrow bell curve, ie. low variance with relatively few outliers. This is what I mean when I say pure skill is not the major factor in success in cycling. Most riders are going to be pretty closely matched skill-wise, and the winners are going to be those that can generate the most power for a sustained amount of time.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by its_ethan on Saturday July 13, 2024 @09:44PM (#40958260)
I’ve given up on this thread because people seem to be getting very defensive and interpreting malice when there is none, but your comment here is similar to what I was trying to say. Cycling has a tighter bell curve of skill than other sports, just like all/most endurance sports.

It’s not a knock, I still enjoy those sports a lot, often more than wider skill bell curve sports.. oh well

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Monday July 15, 2024 @03:18AM (#40965871)
> he said less in comparison with other professional sports.

No, we’re taking umbrage with the fact that people are saying cycling requires less skill, when this simply isn’t true. It requires different skills, that’s all.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by LargeWu on Monday July 15, 2024 @09:38AM (#40967792)
No, you're still not getting it.

It's not that it requires less skill, relative to an average person. It's that skill is not the differentiating factor among elites.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Monday July 15, 2024 @12:55PM (#40969523)
I’ve answered this here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40965857

There’s plenty of amateur footballers more skilful than professionals, yet can’t make it because they lack the physical attributes (speed/strength/stamina). I’ve watched high skill teams shredded by a team that just shoved them off the ball and outran them. Barcelona’s style under Pep wasn’t mostly skill, it included a HUGE amount of physical fitness to maintain a press to win the ball back.

A massive part of Rooney’s rapid decline was his shit lifestyle reducing his fitness and speed as he grew older.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by ElGreco on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:35AM (#40983136)
I'm a keen cyclist (doing and watching); the elite differentiator is aerobic capacity (anaerobic for sprinters) not skill. Going fast up a hill wins GC and require no skill. Going fast down is more skilful but less important.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Monday July 15, 2024 @03:16AM (#40965857)
> This is counter to your thesis.

No, it’s because his skill is deeply tied to his body’s physiology. I wager you’d find physical traits that you simply must be born with. His height, balance, reaction times. Physiology.

> Most riders are going to be pretty closely matched skill-wise

This is true for all sports.

> winners are going to be those that can generate the most power for a sustained amount of time.

Strategy comes into it a lot, just like most sports.

Also, there’s plenty of talented footballers that will never go pro because they lack the ability to run fast or maintain that intensity for 90 minutes (fitness).

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by anotherboffin on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:19PM (#40948063)
I had heard that in the context of absurdly high hematocrit, where they would get their heart rate up to move the (very viscous) blood around their body. No source, but doesn’t sound impossible when everyone was on EPO.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by ben7799 on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:39PM (#40948224)
That was the early EPO era.. there were some riders that died in their sleep their blood was so thick from massive amounts of EPO. Their red blood cell counts were excessively high.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by matsemann on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:18PM (#40948058)
The wake up and walk around the hotel was mainly an EPO thing, where your blood got so thick you otherwise could die.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by Swizec on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:10PM (#40947976)
> I don't know how true it is, but I've heard that some cyclists had/have to set alarms throughout the night so they wake up to do jumping jacks to get their heart rates back up above the "artificial" 15bpm that their training + cocktail of drugs has caused.

Even as a casual runner (top 20% in a marathon, def not competitive), I have had to silence low heart rate alarms on my apple watch because my heart rate regularly drops below 40bpm at night. When I’m in peak condition for a race, I’ve seen it drop as low as 30.

Professional cyclists have the highest VO2max of any athlete. Even without drugs I would be completely unsurprised if their heart rate gets to 20bpm in deep sleep.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by its_ethan on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:18PM (#40948059)
Definitely some amount of it is natural, I'm even less competitive with running than you, but seeing my resting heart rate go down as you ramp up distances is a satisfying thing when you realize the hard work is paying off in a "tangible" way :)

I did a little more googling after the above comment, and it seems like another factor that (in theory) plays into the issue for the anecdote is that their blood can get thicker from doping. So it's a recipe of very low heart rate + extra viscous blood to pump that = danger.

Regardless, it's some pretty interesting/freaky stuff!

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by axlee on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:39PM (#40948225)
Them and cross country skiers (for VO2Max domination)
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by drdaeman on Friday July 12, 2024 @03:04PM (#40948442)
> I'm amazed this is legal

If someone is well-informed (the key point here - but I assume professional athletes are well aware of what they're doing) and still wants to do something weird and/or dangerous to their body, without harming others in the process - who is to deny them their bodily autonomy, and on what basis?

> and that people would do it in the first place

Two words: professional sports. Those folks willingly (I hope, or that'd be insane) risk their health for money, fame, and advances of medical science. Although the entertainment industry really tries the weirdest thing that I really don't understand - trying their best to shift the focus away from the science advancement as much as possible, even though this is the only actually valuable thing in professional sports.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by MBCook on Friday July 12, 2024 @04:35PM (#40949160)
I meant legal in the allowed by the sport’s governing body sense, not the will the cops show up at my door sense.

If this is what athletes do to get to the top of the sport, then it soon becomes a pseudo requirement. If the sport regulators don’t clamp down on it then they’re basically forcing people to do something insanely risky if they want to compete.

Plenty of professional sports have banned things for simply being too dangerous even if they do give an edge.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by plorkyeran on Friday July 12, 2024 @07:13PM (#40950318)
It is almost certainly just something that hasn't been banned yet. There's a very long list of similar things which the UCI has banned, but they generally don't ban things which people might hypothetically do but haven't actually started doing yet, so each time someone comes up with a new idea there's a window of time to do it while it's still legal.
Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by MBCook on Friday July 12, 2024 @10:14PM (#40951234)
I expect you’re right. It has to get on the radar to be banned.

To make matters worse unlike PEDs this may be very hard to catch.

It just floors me that someone who knew about the similarity between high altitude and partial CO poisoning not only decided to try it but got others to go along.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:40PM (#40948237)
I doubt it’s dangerous at all:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40948229

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by MBCook on Friday July 12, 2024 @04:37PM (#40949182)
Injecting spider venom isn’t dangerous as long as you get the dosage right.

If doing this makes it possible to perform better, people are going to push the edge of the amount that’s “safe“. Right up to the limit. Tip toeing over the limit.

People will get seriously hurt/die if they do it wrong.

It’s CO. there’s a reason the government is always telling people to make sure they have carbon monoxide detectors. It’s not because they might get too good at sports.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by scott_w on Friday July 12, 2024 @04:49PM (#40949296)
> Injecting spider venom isn’t dangerous as long as you get the dosage right.

Venom actively damages your cells, CO just restricts oxygen access.

> If doing this makes it possible to perform better, people are going to push the edge of the amount that’s “safe“. Right up to the limit. Tip toeing over the limit.

Not necessarily. It’s not like EPO where more is better, the benefits likely cap out long before you reach a dangerous level of CO, so going to “the limit” isn’t something that’s likely to happen.

> It’s CO. there’s a reason the government is always telling people to make sure they have carbon monoxide detectors.

Yes because your boiler might leak an uncontrolled amount of CO and, because it’s odorless, you don’t know if you’re breathing too much before you pass out and, subsequently, die. That’s a different situation than being in a controlled environment where you can set the dosage quite easily.

Re:Tour de France riders are inhaling carbon monoxide in 'su... by RIMR on Friday July 12, 2024 @02:10PM (#40947977)
I just watched Tour de Pharmacy, which I thought was parody, but now I'm not so sure.