News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel is selling defective 13-14th Gen CPUs by forrestthewoods on Friday July 12, 2024 @12:12PM (#40946880)
> If it’s as they say, switching to AMD shouldn’t lead to 100x fewer crashes, it should lead to no crashes.

No?

There’s always multiple sources of crashes. Switching from Intel may eliminate 100% of one crash source, but not 100% of all crashes.

One of my favorite stories is that ArenaNet once got Guild Wars servers so stable that any crash could be reliably attributed to hardware failure. Usually memory IIRC.

Re:Intel is selling defective 13-14th Gen CPUs by ComputerGuru on Friday July 12, 2024 @12:16PM (#40946945)
That’s kind of my point. They’re clearly running a buggy codebase to begin with that I wouldn’t trust a crash to mean hardware failure.
Re:Intel is selling defective 13-14th Gen CPUs by eqvinox on Friday July 12, 2024 @12:53PM (#40947270)
Crashes caused by hardware failures look very different from crashes caused by a buggy codebase. 80% of code bugs will have very unisonous crash reports. The other 20% of code bugs — memory corruption and race conditions, notably — have more random crash reports, but are still identifiable as such. Random hardware failures generally cause crash reports that look like someone put your bits in a mixer and made a smoothie.

(NB: random hardware failures like we're talking about here. CPU design/logic erratas can and do look like code bugs; but that's not what's being discussed here.)