Israel takes prisoners not hostages and has due process albeit flawed. Everyone arrested is arrested due to something they did. Not taken out of their home or a party. Not raped and murdered. These are not civilians, they are typically criminals.
Minors taken by Israel are 16+ unless they did something serious. E.g. two teen girls stabbed a person who they thought was an elderly Jew. Was actually an old Palestinian guy. Obviously Hamas asked to release that murderer. Israel is asking for the release of innocent people while Hamas is asking for the release of mass murderers.
Maybe they learned these bad habits from the superpower : https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-07-07/ty-article-ma....
>Israel takes prisoners not hostages and has due process albeit flawed. Everyone arrested is arrested due to something they did.
Are the people abducted from West Bank committed crimes in Israel? Or were they committed against an occupying power in West Bank? Israel, could you know just leave the West Bank? So if someone attack them in Tel Aviv, can be tried in there. What you say?
>These are not civilians, they are typically criminals.
There is large difference between a criminal and a combatant. Please do not conflate the two.
>Minors taken by Israel are 16+
Age of Majority is 18, isn't it? There could be provision for extraordinary cases, but maybe the martial law has provision for doing what they want.
>Hamas is asking for the release of mass murderers.
Yeah, give them Bibi. Fully qualified.
Again a false equivalency.
You're picking a rare occurrence to justify a rule vs. a conscious policy. Recent reporting on this proved very few were actually hit by this instruction. In retrospect that directive made a lot of sense. Hundreds were kidnapped and tortured many of them probably died anyway. They were used brutally as leverage, deadly force should have been used to stop that.
Compare this to putting kids in harms way on purpose. To using hospitals and schools as arms caches and using kids to take cover behind. The fact that you're making such a comparison is embarrassing.
> Are the people abducted from West Bank committed crimes in Israel?
Not abducted. Arrested. Often turned in by the Palestinian authorities themselves.
> Or were they committed against an occupying power in West Bank?
Here you're trying to mix two things: Palestinian authority and Hamas. This is the goal of Hamas. Hamas was the main saboteur that stopped the Oslo accord from progressing to the entire west bank. Had it not been for their sabotage and mass murder in the 90s there might have been a Palestinian state by now.
Up until recently Israel arrested anyone committing a crime. That includes settlers committing crimes against Palestinians who also went to prison. This shifted with the current horrible government.
> Israel, could you know just leave the West Bank? So if someone attack them in Tel Aviv, can be tried in there. What you say?
First off, Israel was attacked a lot in Tel Aviv. We can't give a trial to rockets or the remains of a suicide bomber who blew up a bus. I'm not even sure what fantasy world you live in
Here's the thing. Israel tried to leave the west bank. It made two offers for a Palestinian state both of which were rejected. Even East Jerusalem was included with 94% of the West Bank territories. The offers were rejected by both Palestinian authority leaders. They required compromise which the Palestinians aren't capable of as a people and lack leadership that can get them there.
Furthermore, Israel tried "just leaving" Gaza which is easier since it didn't have as many settlements. Israeli nationals were removed by force and Israel left. What happened was an election where the people picked Hamas. Hamas killed the PLO people (moderate Palestinians) set up a reign of terror, taught schoolchildren that running over Jews with cars will send them to heaven (seriously, there's videos)... They used billions they got from Israel to dig tunnels, build rockets, buy weapons and prepare for October 7th.
I'm not saying that Israel didn't do bad things. It very much did, but it gave the Palestinians many opportunities for moderation and compromise. It got rejection and rockets.
> There is large difference between a criminal and a combatant. Please do not conflate the two.
True. They are criminals. Murderers.
A combatant has a reasonable end goal to free their people or bring justice, he has a chain of command with justification and responsibility. Their goal is the genocide of the Israeli people. River to the sea means literally kill all the Jews. They do that by targeting civilians not army targets, not officials. Women, children, people at a f*ing rave...
Not everyone arrested is like that. E.g. the head of the Shifa hospital was arrested and recently released (apparently by mistake), he naturally went around presenting himself as completely innocent and Israel as evil for imprisoning him.
There's recordings of him sharing humanitarian aid given to the hospital (fuel etc.) with Hamas. Letting them operate freely within the Hospital. He kept hostages there and at least one hostage was executed there. If we're talking about doctors a month ago Israel conducted a raid in Gaza where 4 hostages were freed. The people keeping them were a doctor and his son who was a reporter. The son wrote articles about the suffering in Gaza (while they were literally holding civilian hostages from a party) he was a photographer for Al Jazeera (they deny that).
These people were held in the middle of a packed town and people either didn't know or closed a blind eye.
> >Hamas is asking for the release of mass murderers. > > Yeah, give them Bibi. Fully qualified.
I wish to see Bibi in prison. He's a horrible person, a horrible leader and a criminal. He's also on trial and his partners are even worse. However, the mass murder claim is "probably" wrong. Or at least he wouldn't be more guilty than George Bush, Churchill, etc. (albeit a terrible leader).
You're implying that when we fight mass murderers who hide behind children the fight should be 100% clean and completely free of civilian casualties?
The USA lost its middle east wars because terrorists understand its low tolerance to cruelty. All they had to do was dial up the cruelty to 11 and the US public didn't have a stomach for that. Americans abandoned the poor people of Afghanistan to the cruel rule of Taliban because they were unable to do what's necessary to end them.
Hamas is taking the same strategy, but unlike the USA we can't run anywhere. We tried living on our side of the fence and ignoring the problem. October 7th proved that this will never be possible. Even if we will have an agreement now, Hamas will break it like it did the last time. The next time will be FAR more deadly.
This is where your post veered from invective into pure and simple racism, unfortunately.
Right now all their leaders and wishful leaders are current/former terrorists. To climb to the top you have to prove yourself as a mass murderer. That doesn't yield good leadership skills.
But that's only a part of it. The main problem is their Hamula (extended family) structure. Their social order is to a large part dictated by major families that place their allegiance with individual militia. This is problematic, a leader needs to instill fear in the families and yet gain enough support by promising favors for each. The result is deep, rooted, inescapable corruption that tanked the Palestinian authority. Hamas has also robbed billions from the people of Gaza.
This sort of environment doesn't allow for compromise. The people who get to the top will be literally murdered by these families if they compromise. Anyone who shows statesmanship and willingness to work is quickly kicked out of the way by this cast system.
Don't get me wrong, individual Palestinians do want a proper democracy. But they can't really have it because the power of these forces is too big.
It's also hard to find the "good guys" because both sides did some pretty awful things. Which again muddies the waters.
But the thing is that you chose to sweep the deck and call everything I said a lie with no nuance or thought. This brings me back to a different debate I had with someone I think here... I mentioned that Israel has gay rights and one of the most advanced human rights laws, civil rights, religious freedom etc. It's essentially a super liberal country in most regards (our labor laws will make California blush).
On the flip side I mentioned gays get executed in Gaza and wife beating isn't a crime under Hamas law. Honor killings are normal occurrences (if you don't know what it is you should seriously read up about it). I was accused of "pink washing".
Pink washing is when a corporation tries to hide bad behavior with a sham gay gesture. Israel has been pro-gay for decades, pro women and human rights. That's not something tucked on.
But the accusation reminded me of you. It accused me of stating a bad verifiable fact about Hamas while saying something verifiably good about Israel. How dare I state such inconvenient facts to assault your sensitive preconceived notions of whose "good" and whose "bad" in this narrative. I've clearly gone too far.
All joking aside. Why do you think those are lies?
Why do you choose to not believe a flawed democracy over a terrorist organization that murdered people for decades?
A terrorist organization backed by an Iran, Russia block... A terrorist organization that is killing its own people. If any of these facts seem wrong to you, I suggest furthering your research on that. I think you were deeply mislead. Israel is very flawed and did indeed mistreat the Palestinians a lot (especially in the West bank) but you need nuance. Palestinians vary Hamas is evil, the Palestinian authority is "complicated". Israel is also nuanced, it has the worst government in its history right now, but that's an anomaly. It did have more liberal governments over the years.
Unfortunately, Hamas and lack of nuance from the west help strengthen the bad players within Israel and move it further to the right.