Re:Second Factor SMS: Worse Than Its Reputation
by Terretta on Thursday July 11, 2024 @05:55PM
(#40940958)
Stop threatening me. And what does Hollywood have to do with me logging in?
Re:Second Factor SMS: Worse Than Its Reputation
by brandon272 on Thursday July 11, 2024 @11:03PM
(#40942448)
It is very much software-world-thinking to believe that dismissive Kafkaesque responses that just shut down the conversation without addressing the fundamental issues around usability and customer satisfaction will ameliorate the situation.
For a lot of service based businesses they see their customers face to face and it is imperative that the customers have a seamless experience. Imagine having a business where customers who can't sign into some online system you have are bringing in old Android phones and wanting help from your staff members on how to get 2FA set up on those devices and it is easy to understand why many such businesses settle on SMS based 2FA.
Re:Second Factor SMS: Worse Than Its Reputation
by akira2501 on Thursday July 11, 2024 @11:08PM
(#40942464)
"We face this. It's about 5% of users. Our margins are large enough we don't worry about this segment. They need our service more than we need them."
- Any Large Bank Anywhere
Re:Second Factor SMS: Worse Than Its Reputation
by brandon272 on Thursday July 11, 2024 @11:37PM
(#40942563)
Most large banks already largely offer non-SMS 2FA through their companion mobile apps. This is about pretty much every other service you have that does not have a dedicated mobile app and doesn't want to teach their users how to manage your 2FA codes.
Re:Second Factor SMS: Worse Than Its Reputation
by xp84 on Monday July 15, 2024 @01:14AM
(#40965435)
The problem with the above statement is that merely “offering” a better option doesn’t solve the issue. The mere presence of SMS as one option gives the same risk as if it were SMS- only. An attacker can choose the sms option (after slipping $100 or even just a fake ID to the teen at the phone store to sim-swap you) even if you never would use it. It needs to be at minimum able to be permanently disabled on demand.
Re:Second Factor SMS: Worse Than Its Reputation
by brandon272 on Thursday July 18, 2024 @12:12PM
(#40997095)
Offering it as an option does not necessarily mean allowing both sms and non sms options simultaneously.
"Unfortunately, many of our other customers, and customers of other financial institutions were not correctly protected by the code alone.. and were still getting scammed or confused.. and losing _all_ their money."
> Customer: "[...] I'm finding this very frustrating, I need to get into my account."
"That is understandable, but we take the security of your account and your personal information very seriously, and this requires us to make changes to maintain that security in the face of new threats and actors as they evolve."