News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by robomartin on Monday June 11, 2012 @02:07AM (#4093405)
This is the part that really confuses me. You only have to run a business --any business-- for a few quarters to understand the negative impact that taxation and over-regulation can have on the decisions you make, the risks you take, your ability to compete and how quickly you can grow.

You really don't need a study from Harvard to get data on this. If you don't get it because of a lack of business experience, go talk to your local high-school-educated baker, mechanic or gas-station owner for a quick round-down.

The evidence is overwhelming. Yet, we keep dicking around and supporting policies, politicians and people who somehow think they can violate the laws of physics and make things better by shafting everyone with more taxes.

When are we going to learn and act? When it is too late?

I owned a manufacturing business for nearly a decade. We designed and assembled electronics, embedded systems, FPGA's, lots of code. Hell, we even had a full-blown CNC shop with the latest equipment. As an engineer it was fun to go to the office. As a business person, it was painful.

Example: One day this guy from the County of Los Angeles Business Property Tax department shows up in our industrial area going from door to door. The guy comes into our office and informs us that he was there to confirm how much we owned in business property taxes. I told him that we leased the 10,000 square foot building. We didn't own it. He then says: "Do you own desks, computers, tools, machinery, fax machines, chairs...?". Sure. "Well, you have to pay the County of L.A. taxes on these and other items". The only thing that I could say to him was "You have to be fucking joking! I have to pay you taxes on my desks and chairs, forever? Why?"

Think I am making this up? Here:

http://lacountypropertytax.com/portal/contactus/ppa.aspx

Being in manufacturing during the last several years has been a very painful experience. The supply chain is royally fucked. A lot of what you have to source you just can't get in the US any more. More an more suppliers are closing their doors every day. It's painful, difficult and you are getting killed by product coming from China.

I won't go into the details that led to my decision to abandon hardware/electronics manufacturing. I, ultimately, decided that it was a far better idea to transform into a software-only enterprise and move away from making real physical goods.

Because what we made involved everything from electronics, FPGA's, embedded, web and workstation software it really wasn't too difficult to shed the hardware portion of things and stick to software. I pains me because I love making things, but we, in the US, have somehow managed to FUBAR our system to such an extent that people like me have to say "fuck it" and move on.

If you continue voting for policies that promote higher taxation and regulation, more government involvement and government programs you are going to get exactly the country you are voting for: A third world mess with rats jumping ship faster than humans. Mark my words. Think about it.

What cracks me up is that you guys are arguing percentages and technicalities. Coming from my side of the table reading this would be funny if it wasn't so tragic. Go make something. Then come back and re-read your comments to see what they sound like.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by einhverfr on Monday June 11, 2012 @03:25AM (#4093545)
I think though that overregulation is a bigger issue than taxation. The fact is that income taxes only tax against profits, though excise taxes can be a bigger deal (think gallonage taxes on liquor produced) because those increase your overall cost.

There are two problems with overregulation though. The first is that it is a up-front cost that keeps on coming up day in and day out. It's not like an income tax that hits your profits. It's more like an excise tax on goods produced. Overregulation is a drag on the economy. It is a drag that makes it harder to break even. It is a drag that makes it harder to do anything. It's a bigger issue than income tax rates.

But it's even worse than excise tax rates. Regulatory compliance is something that takes resources. The more resources you have the easier it is. Consequently over-regulation protects big players by raising huge barriers to entry.

And at least in a country like China, if the system is unworkable a whispers in ears and envelopes of cash probably go a long ways towards making the system workable..... Over here we have a slightly different approach. We pay a professional class of people large rates, and, as in places like China, they then represent our cause to various officials. It's a question as to whether you hire an "agent" or whether you hire a "lawyer." Apparently one counts as corruption and arguably bribery while the other does not.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by codehotter on Monday June 11, 2012 @02:37AM (#4093449)
I do not know enough to disagree with you on your main point, but I do have a few nits.

You really don't need a study from Harvard to get data on this. If you don't get it because of a lack of business experience, go talk to your local high-school-educated baker, mechanic or gas-station owner for a quick round-down.

Talking to your local high-school-educated baker is not science. We confidently believe a great deal of things that are untrue, and getting it confirmed with science is valuable. In hindsight, it's usually easy to be unsurprised by a scientific result.

Can you imagine possible circumstances that would lead you to confidently believe taxation and regulation to be the cause of many businesses' failure even if it were untrue?

The evidence is overwhelming. Yet, we keep dicking around and supporting policies, politicians and people who somehow think they can violate the laws of physics and make things better by shafting everyone with more taxes.

I would love to believe this, since that would be a good argument to have less taxes. However, as your only evidence, you offer an example of absurd property taxation on desks and chairs.

Such taxes cost a business in legal, accounting, and administration fees, in addition to the tax itself, and it costs tax money to operate the government bureau to oversee all of this. All this looks to be a blatant example of government inefficiency.

However, every country in the world, at least every democracy, suffers from such problems. At one point or another, the politicians have to trade political capital to push for the policies really important to them, their funders and their voter base, and less than ideal compromises do get made.

I believe that taxation is inherently inefficient and I would like to see as little of it as possible. And I also believe that some functions of government are useful to society at large. A balance must be struck. This balance will include inefficiencies that come with running a political society.

Given that a balance must be struck, it is possible that the optimal level of taxation would be higher than now. I do not know how to judge it - I have no basis for that. I would like to see the evidence that shows where that balance must lie. I find it otherwise unsurprising to see business owners arguing for lower corporate tax.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by Domenic_S on Monday June 11, 2012 @03:58AM (#4093616)
> Talking to your local high-school-educated baker is not science. We confidently believe a great deal of things that are untrue, and getting it confirmed with science is valuable. In hindsight, it's usually easy to be unsurprised by a scientific result.

He's not talking about science per se, but the insane level of rules and regulations you've got to put up with as a business owner -- especially in California. In other words, my interpretation of the GP's remark is that you can get at least an order of magnitude measurement of the pain-in-the-ass/cost factor, which is likely several orders of magnitude higher than what you think it is if you haven't owned a business that has enough revenue to put you on the radar.

The bias on HN is probably more towards software (where we can all 1099 each other) and not so much towards manufacturing (which is a major compliance pain). When you're dealing with manufacturing, things are different. You're dealing the EDD, FTB, INS and IRS (from an employee compliance standpoint), then you're also dealing with OSHA and the EPA and all their arcane rules and enforcers that hit you with $15k fines if you use dishsoap incorrectly. Then, on top of all of that you're paying a 35% tax rate.

Honestly, I'm surprised manufacturing has lasted as long as it has in the US.

> Given that a balance must be struck, it is possible that the optimal level of taxation would be higher than now. I do not know how to judge it - I have no basis for that. I would like to see the evidence that shows where that balance must lie.

Well, you could read the article :) We have a control group (the US) and the test groups (Germany, China) are far outperforming us.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by _delirium on Monday June 11, 2012 @06:01AM (#4093880)
Germany is interesting as a control, because its overall tax rates are much higher than in the U.S.--- 41% of GDP for Germany, versus only 27% of GDP (at all levels of government) for the USA. But its corporate tax rate is lower, because it gets most of its tax revenue from personal income taxes and VAT.

If we wanted the American tax system to become like Germany's, the steps would look roughly like: 1. significantly lower corporate tax rates; 2. nearly double personal income tax rates; 3. institute a federal VAT.

But you don't end up with the German economic model if you do only #1...

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by dan00 on Monday June 11, 2012 @06:40AM (#4093944)
"1. significantly lower corporate tax rates"

This harmed the cities in Germany a lot and increased their debt.

It's kind of a contradiction if Germany should be the economic guide, but it's cities can't pay for their public baths anymore.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by ubernostrum on Monday June 11, 2012 @04:59AM (#4093750)
Well, this is the thing about science -- if you want to, you can go observe the real world, and see how things actually are :)

Which may not produce results you like; lack of taxation/regulation does not, empirically, correlate with strong economies, strong businesses and high standards of living. In fact, rather the opposite; it is precisely those places which have the least regulation/taxation that tend to be the "third world messes" you warn against.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by adventureful on Monday June 11, 2012 @05:13AM (#4093790)
If you're talking the complete lack of taxes, then sure, but there have been very few actual examples of that.

One of which was the USA, which almost completely lacked taxes for the fastest period of its growth, most of the 19th century. Look up the average tax haul in relation to GDP for the US during the 19th century. The US relied heavily on tariffs instead of personal or corporate income taxes or sales taxes.

Low taxes combined with strong property rights & a strong judicial have proven to produce spectacular economic booms.

The US from 1800 to 1970, modern Singapore, and modern Hong Kong for example.

Estonia's substantial economic growth after liberalization post USSR, and ditto Ireland's big economic boom after slashing its corporate taxes (doubled their per capita income in a mere 15 years, passing Britain).

Sweden has seen a significant boom after massively cutting taxes in the last few decades.

New Zealand ditto. New Zealand boomed with their tax cutting programs:

"New Zealand went through a major program of tax reform in the 1980s. The top marginal rate of income tax was reduced from 66% to 33% (increased to 39% in April 2000, 38% in April 2009 and 33% on 1 October 2010) and corporate income tax rate from 48% to 33% (reduced to 30% in 2008 and to 28% on 1 October 2010)."

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by _delirium on Monday June 11, 2012 @05:40AM (#4093834)
> Sweden has seen a significant boom after massively cutting taxes in the last few decades.

Sweden also saw a huge boom while massively raising their taxes post-WW2! And its cuts were, overall, from the highest taxes in the world, to the... 2nd-highest taxes in the world, now just barely losing out to Denmark by 1% of GDP. The correlations seem pretty complex.

In Europe, I don't see any real causal connection between tax rates and strength of the economy. If anything, there appears to be a bit of a causal connection in the opposite direction: weaker, less-developed countries have lower tax rates in order to try to lure businesses from better-developed countries. By percentage of GDP, these are the five highest-tax EU countries: Denmark, Sweden, Belgium, France, Norway. The five lowest-tax are: Lithuania, Romania, Switzerland, Latvia, Ireland.

And Germany, which has probably the strongest business sector in Europe, is towards the top; at 41% of GDP taxation, closer to Denmark's 49% than Lithuania's 21% (or the USA's 27%). Its high-tax but pro-market "social market economy" seems to be pretty successful overall.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by gaius on Monday June 11, 2012 @08:21AM (#4094217)
At the risk of invoking Godwin's, any analysis of post-WW2 Sweden has to account for them being one of the few European countries that emerged from that conflict with its industrial base intact, which it managed by hedging its bets on who the victor would be.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweden_during_World_War_II

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by daliusd on Monday June 11, 2012 @07:07AM (#4094016)
I'm from Lithuania. The problem with percentage of GDP using for all the European countries is not very good measure. Some taxes are indeed small in Lithuania (e.g. profit tax is 15% in Lithuania and 5% for small companies) but some taxes are really big (e.g. I'm giving away 42% of my salary to government). Small salaries and shadow economy in Eastern Europe might explain why percentage of GDP looks so well but we shouldn't be used as example of small taxation (because we are not).

We are smart, we are really good working, but be ready to pay a lot of taxes if you want to establish company here. While you don't need to pay bribes at least if you are doing everything legally :)

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by ubernostrum on Monday June 11, 2012 @07:00AM (#4093994)
And yet you're failing at a key scientific principle, which is looking for alternative hypotheses to explain what you're seeing :)

Many of the commonly-cited examples tend to pick situations which are amenable to lots of explanations. To take your example of the early US: was it low taxes and light regulation? Was it the presence of massive amounts of land and natural resources essentially free for the taking (once the natives had been suitably subdued)? Was it the jump from agrarian to industrial economy? How much of a role was played by the lack of regulation on things like owning other people and forcing them to work for you?

Similarly, it's difficult to work only from short-term examples; Ireland had a great boom, yes, but they also got a real-estate bubble and a banking crisis -- both of which are pretty clearly related in some way to the tax/regulation situation -- and that's not so great for the long-term.

It's also important to consider the historical context. Rapid industrialization has almost always resulted in massive growth, for example, but at unimaginable human cost. Whether we look at starvation and accidental and deliberate deaths as a result of a five-year plan or the Great Leap Forward, or starvation and accidental and deliberate deaths during the Western industrial revolution, we find that this growth is not always a uniformly good thing. Yet, when approaching from a framework that values only numbers like GDP, we don't see those costs.

If you want a scientific approach, you have to be considering all of these things, and more :)

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by rprasad on Monday June 11, 2012 @06:15PM (#4097344)
The US was not an economic power until after the Civil War, or in other words, roughly only the last two decades of the 1800s, which coincided with major technological advances such as the development of the steamship and the cotton gin. The first two decades of the 1900s coincided with a major bust cycle which did not end until after the passage of the first income tax. The US had marginal tax rates as high as 90% during the post-WWII boom. During the boom of the 1990s, tax rates were higher than they were during the Reagan or Bush II eras.

Sweden, at roughly 9.5 million people, is smaller than most major US cities, let alone metropolitan areas. It simply does not have the sort of expenses that a large nation must deal with. Further, as others have noted, Sweden's industrial base was not damaged in WWII, allowing it to avoid the type of spending that most other European nations had to deal with.

Ireland's boom resulted in an even larger bust. The key driver of the boom was reduced regulations which led to rampant overspeculation by financial institutions (i.e., essentially the same thing that happened with the U.S. mortgage market).

Estonia's economic boom is the result of the discovery and exploitation of massive oil shale reserves. Unlike most oil-producing nations, Estonia is not requiring extractors to compensate, clean up, or otherwise mitigate the environmental damage.

Singapore has increased taxes several times since 2003, with minimal effects to its growing GDP. Hong Kong has also increased taxes regularly, to pay for vastly expanded government services.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by bleu on Monday June 11, 2012 @03:24AM (#4093540)
I also have very similar experience and opinion, I was in design, manufacture, distribution for about 10 years, biggest pain in the arse you can imagine, even though moderately successful I too chucked it all in and am glade I did. I'm also now into software only. Software is hard too. Very hard, competition is tough, but it's so powerful, if your in a good niche you can really change the playing field.
Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by einhverfr on Monday June 11, 2012 @10:43AM (#4094829)
Another argument against what you are saying here is that when you look at the Eastern vs Western Roman empires, the Eastern Empire had more progressive tax policies, and was more effective at imposing and collecting taxes on the wealthy than the Western Empire was. As a result the tax base in the Western Empire was very narrow, and this contributed to its collapse (at the time the Goths overran, the Western Empire was collecting less in taxes than the Eastern Empire was spending on defence).

The relationship between taxes and prosperity is a complex one, but if we go by that example, it seems that an active policy of reducing concentration of wealth is the best way to ensure common defence and joint prosperity.

Re:You Can't Engineer Around Taxes by jf271 on Monday June 11, 2012 @07:09AM (#4094026)
That is a tax that never made sense to me. I know they do it because it is easy to quantify equipment but once you start taxing the means of production all you get is less production and less means of production to tax.