Re:Beyond bufferbloat: End-to-end congestion control cannot ...
by Hikikomori on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @03:40AM
(#40924546)
Its oversubscribed as many users share the same link at some point and that link is not big enough to allow all users to use all their bandwidth at the same time. ISPs will oversubscribe and add more capacity when needed to avoid congestion, around 70-95% utilization depending on link size. American ISPs seems to not care as much though.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Beyond bufferbloat: End-to-end congestion control cannot ...
by sambazi on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @05:34AM
(#40925187)
> ts oversubscribed as many users share the same link at some point and that link is not big enough to allow all users to use all their bandwidth at the same time.
that's a definition of oversubscription.
> around 70-95% utilization depending on link size.
2/3's with dumb queues, <100% with the computational tradeoff of sqm
Re:Beyond bufferbloat: End-to-end congestion control cannot ...
by scottlamb on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @03:22PM
(#40930448)
It's really not interesting to say that a major ISP doesn't have capacity for all of their customers to use their advertised bandwidth at once. That extreme just doesn't happen, and so the cost/benefit of preparing for it just isn't there. Some oversubscription is normal.
However, for their upstream links to actually be maxed out (thus "experiencing congestion" as Hikikomori put it) with any regularity is more remarkable—suggests they screwed up their capacity planning or just don't care. I kind of expect that from Comcast but not ISPs in general.
For those links to be of varying capacity (like the 5G/Wifi networks the article mentions) would be truly surprising to me.