Re:Show HN: I coded my own JSON translation tool to easily l...
by numpad0 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @03:17PM
(#40919812)
That tip btw isn't limited to LLMs. Blindfolded human translators given single word to translate tend not to do great jobs.
Re:Show HN: I coded my own JSON translation tool to easily l...
by hju22_-3 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @05:52PM
(#40921625)
For example, Breath of the Wild has a quest-line featuring two NPCs sending love letters via a river, and you can help then get together or something. Only issue is that it's hella creepy in the English translation, while it's much less in the original Japanese one. I don't remember the specifics, but the problem there was the translators were not given context for what they were translating.
Re:Show HN: I coded my own JSON translation tool to easily l...
by numpad0 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @07:48PM
(#40922498)
It doesn't take that much specific examples or Japanese text as an example. "Walk" could be referring to speed, a physical walkway, undesired mechanical behaviors, some sort of activism, so on. "Connect with $VAR" translates differently depending on what the $VAR is; a human, a group of humans, a computer, a webservice. The intention of a word or few words divorced from associated stimuli is simply in-determinate.
In GP's defense, I suppose there are values in butchered translation as a low-budget checkbox checker. LLM do generate a lot of great lipsums.
Pro tip: If you are using an LLM to do translations for you, give it CONTEXT so that the translations are not garbage. Don’t just say “translate x into german”. Explain in sentence or two what it’s translating and who the audience is. Many words are translated differently depending on the context of the conversation.