The studies you refer to are demonstrating that active/unguided is superior to passive/direct.
But the full picture is that active/direct > active/unguided > passive/direct. (I didn't include passive/unguided here because I'm not sure it's possible to create such a combination.)
Other studies -- that only manipulate one variable at a time -- support this big picture.
Its possible, we call the end result LLM. It isn't very effective though as we can see from the result and how much learning it took.
To me though the more interesting result isn’t really about pedagogy, it’s that people’s (undergrad physics students, in the case of the specific study I’m thinking of) subjective impressions of the effectiveness of instruction are unreliable.
Yes, common finding in studies that explore subjective vs objective measurements of learning under conditions involving "desirable difficulties":