Most of the people who lecture at these events are programmers, not folks who have a masters in teaching along with their state certification.
But back to your point. My degree is from a university in Boston and helped me get my teaching license. Almost everything we covered was theoretical and, with a few important exceptions, utterly useless.
Looks like the author of the article was either incapable or unwilling or unprepared to perform one of the basic teaching functions - ensuring that jerks do not disrupt the process for the rest of the group. It may stem from inexperience - well, that's what experience is for. One doesn't need masters or certificates to learn such things though, it's perfectly available to any common person.
Can't speak for US, but in UK a large part of PGCE courses is devoted to reflecting and acting on experience gained in a supervised teaching placement.
Sometimes you need to dig a bit deeper to process the experience, my favourite out of date theory is Schon's single and double loop learning.
http://www.infed.org/thinkers/et-schon.htm
For coders: single loop learning is when you change the way you name variables or re-write your code to make the logic clearer. Double loop learning is the stuff Michael Lopp writes about.
And its great that people within the business are prepared to help others out.
Perhaps there is a need for a 'facilitator's FAQ' that could provide quick strategies for situations like this?
Anyone any idea where to host such a publication?
PS: why was 'Dave' allowed to join the workshop half way through?
The author was not calling for single-sex education, he was calling for us to find & support ways of giving new people "a more comfortable entrance into our general community".
This is not to imply that there aren't good reasons for women-only education, but this isn't one of them.
Would a group or women react differently if the conference jerk was female? I'd guess the answer is "No", but then I've never experienced that situation.
I have experienced the male version of this, and unlike the author of the article I never see this kind of show-off behavior as a "call to arms", unless that means fighting the urge to wing something heavy at someone's head.
Perhaps there's a selection bias here, but when I see this happen the people around me tend to concur that "helpful jerk" is being an unhelpful douche.
It seems that when enough guys get together there often ends up being some amount of dick-size measuring; is there something similar when groups of women gather?
There's a natural experiment in England where there are quite a lot of single sex schools. There are a bunch of confounding factors that are hard to kludge out - social-economic backgrounds, etc.
Some cultures and religions prefer the sexes to be separated. This may not be a good reason to many people.
The only division I would be interested in is segregating the fast learners(whatever be the reason - is sharp, already knows stuff, studies outside class) from regular learners, so that fast learners don't get bored or try to derail the class, and slow learners don't feel left out.
PS - I am not implying that you are supporting gender-segregated education. I am making a general point.
I don't see anyone suggesting such a thing, but instead, that the majority of each gender may have certain behavior and learning styles in common.
And even if this happens to be true, then why stop at gender-segregation?
Why go any further? Just because one type of segregation may work, doesn't mean that all types of segregation would work.
Unless you can prove that certain behavior is common among majority of females, and that certain common behavior is more significant than bazillion traits which are not shared, and then that certain behavior is significant to learning, and is more important than traits which aren't shared - the segregation is meaningless.
> Why go any further? Just because one type of segregation may work, doesn't mean that all types of segregation would work.
The chances that a group of students is going to be consistent, coherent, and will respond to the teaching style in the same way is essentially zero(group size > 1). If gender segregation show a noticeable, significant improvement; by all means have it. But don't make claims in advance.
I am demanding hard conclusions, failing which I am demanding you don't make any if you aren't sure(gender difference became apparent to me that day, gender segregation works etc).
> It's the difference between correlation and causation, and correlation is not "meaningless."
I didn't claim correlation is meaningless - I just claimed you are claiming correlation, and for fuck's sake, causation, when there isn't any.
Correlation is when 2 random variables aren't probabilisticaly independent. If you can cite me correlation between gender and behavioral traits when it comes to learning, and that study isn't some crackpot theory based on how I taught a ruby workshop, I am more than willing to be corrected.
This is where you're dishonest: You say you're looking for hard connections, yet any evidence is subject to a value judgement on your part. Tails I lose.
I am looking for correlation, as in the sense correlation is defined, or causation. I don't think correlation or causation is open to value judgement.
I was just trying to describe a point of view, not one I myself hold.
I think that division by sex is often used as a proxy for division based on learning styles. Not fast vs slow per se, but in how people respond to teaching styles and student interaction.
Which brings me back to my initial point. Is there data that suggests males and females respond significantly differently to teaching styles, and all member of a group(male or female) are consistent?
I am pretty sure you will be left with a class of 1 in the end.
You say that like it's a bad thing. In the ideal case, we would have completely personalized education for every student. Most of what prevents it is lack of resources (and then of course you would need teachers smart enough to make it work).I was going to point out the same thing. A women playing dumb to get help from a man, is not uncommon at all.
Just thought I'd share my tales of sexual harassment in the workplace, seemed relevant ;)
And she may have felt, accurately, that she didn't understand the material as well as the OP thought. You can produce a lot of code in a tutorial without knowing enough to produce that architecture yourself.
Personally I think the people who have the clearest view of what they don't know are the ones prepared to learn the fastest. There's a huge difference between "programming is hard!" nonsense that stops people from starting in the first place and "I'm not getting this" consolidations that help a _started_ person figure out what they need to learn.
Anecdotally, a lot of PhDs have impostor syndrome.
What they need probably is a mix of more attention, a kick up the bum, and being encouraged to go and help other people who are less progressed (because that will actually build their confidence.)
The most extreme examples did not last long. Less extreme cases were treated by starting off any request for help with a review of the process and available resources that led the colleague to ask for help from a co-worker. This was done to develop the ability to perform research and empower them to make decisions on their own as long as they had a good basis for it.
Obviously a short training seminar is different, and the expectation is not for the participant to have found the answer on their own, but I believe a short review of their thought process is in order so the instructor can catch any systemic faults in the student's development. That is, don't just tell them what to type, but figure out if they are missing a core competency and perhaps recommend an independent course of study to supplement the seminar.
And people wonder why women don't like male dominated tech events
Maybe men do similar things when they are confused, or maybe not. I don't know enough about education to comment, but attempting to would be off topic anyways.
The fact that you frame it in such a stereotypical way speaks volumes about the attitudes at work here.
And a simple "let's save the rest of these questions for after class" to the jerk is often effective.
>Dave was really excited by the class, and, like me and the other volunteers, had a lot of experience with Python.
Sounds like Dave was in the wrong class and should have been told so.
>I wondered afterwards why this extremely competent woman in her 20s would react this way after clearly mastering the material.
That's a learned technique for getting assistance. It worked on you, didn't it?