At the same time, Apple is under no obligation to make it easy for us to trample on their licensing deals for technologies that form part of Apple's unique selling proposition in a consumer's mind. AirPlay is so well implemented, consumers find it magical. To keep that mystique, Apple has a right to review and license AirPlay to those vendors that it finds aligned with its long term goals. If you want Apple to be forced to do something different, you're not a "hacker", you're on the side of big government and "Big Brother" demanding to oversee and meddle in a company's right to sell the product it wants that works in the way that it wants.
Finally, I personally want to encourage the hell out of a computing environment that makes everyday people find computing approachable and fun. Just as you don't want a power outlet that needs constant tweaking before you can plug something in, normals don't want a computer or smartphone that requires maintenance just to be able to have fun and get things done.
Apple's forced the mainstream computing industry to stop designing for ourselves, and start thinking about everyone else. This is why computing has finally gone viral.
Did you use that first Mac? It was never about "open" or "hackable", it was about appliance computing that gets the computer out of the user's way.
Nothing has changed since Apple's 1984 when Apple adopted the slogan, "The computer for the rest of us."
Nobody is forcing you to buy Apple's products either. The solution is perfectly laissez-faire: Stop buying them. There are plenty of hacker-friendly alternatives to Apple products which, while not quite as pretty, are still fun to use - and often enable "magical" features like the ability to use an international SIM or free WiFi tethering.
My mother should never experience the benefits a computer can bring to her life because the only device she could understand how to use would be something like an iPad—and since the iPad is made by a company that isn't 100% open, it shouldn't exist at all. Everyone should use Ubuntu, and if you can't use it, it's because you're too stupid and thus don't deserve to have a computing device in your life. Open source principals are more important than anything else, and they must be applied in a binary fashion, scaled across all approaches to computing in the world.
----
A pet peeve of mine is "hackers" ignoring design, and showing zero empathy towards humans [1]. Perhaps we need more designers in the world and not more hackers who stick tight to principals, often completely blinded by these binary maxims they drum up to the real end goal: enabling our species to advance.
[1] http://krisgosser.com/journal/2011/08/empathy-is-most-import...
You, presumably, are a hacker. While hackers represent a small part of the population, they represent a very important part of the market - the part that builds the wider ecosystem. We have a disproportionate effect on the evolution of technology. Use devices that advance an agenda that should be important to you - the ability to make devices do what you want, not what its manufacturer wants them to do.
Besides, you make the non-Apple world sound more bleak than it is. While Android is not quite as polished as iOS, it's perfectly usable by nontechies.
Which would be pretty nice irony too.
And hackerism is not the computing environment Apple wants to encourage. Besides the obvious benefit of more control = better stronghold of their market, Apple is also philosophically in favor of closed, well defined systems and minimal end user confusion, not pro open-ended, experimentation lands, "we give you the building blocks, you make it whatever you want".
And, as much as I like the notion of open systems and hacking, there should be room for the other side too, systems that are designed top-to-bottom and sold "as is".
I believe that history has proved that while it is possible to get quality UIs from open ended/open source style development projects, you get them with LESS consistency that you get them from an Apple-like process, and you also get more competing stuff/chaos/design by committee, unless you coordinate the whole process, from the kernel, to the end user apps.
Open source projects are mostly islands, so you don't get to have that long term vision / whole stack co-ordination.
To put it another way, an OS called OS X exists as ONE thing where one person had ultimate responsibility for what's included and in what shape to ship it. An OS called Linux does not: it only exists as disparate things collected and distributed together (a distro). The Gnome desktop environment, for example, is not produced for a specific OS: it's produced for whoever wants to use it, from various flavors of Linux, to FreeBSD, its apps even run on OS X.
>It's time for someone to re-edit Apple's 1984 commercial and swap the logos.
Why, did Apple ever changed course? The Mac was about a "computer for the rest of us" (ie simple users), and it remains the same now. Neither Mac, nor the 1984 ad was about tinkering. It was about empowering people with simple technology (a simple spreadsheet, a simple text editor, etc), not about empowering hackers to build things.
Actually, now, with the Unix underpinnings, the Mac is also a computer that lures tons of hackers (prevalent in any programming convention and most alpha hackers use a Mac, --even Linus, although he runs Linux on it), but the main market for Apple was an is the common user.
Perhaps you missed this?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=No1MxAnHuJM http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_Different
"Here’s to the crazy ones. The misfits. The rebels. The troublemakers. The round pegs in the square holes. The ones who see things differently. They’re not fond of rules. And they have no respect for the status quo. You can quote them, disagree with them, glorify or vilify them. About the only thing you can’t do is ignore them. Because they change things. They push the human race forward. While some may see them as the crazy ones, we see genius. Because the people who are crazy enough to think they can change the world, are the ones who do. - Apple Inc."
Whereas Apple's focus of making simple computers/software for common people to use was a constant in their corporate story.
This wasn't just a single marketing campaign. It was THE marketing campaign. They even played the Steve Jobs narrated version at the Celebrating Steve event. After reading the Steve Jobs biography, I'm pretty sure that he and the others at Apple truly believe that this campaign represents Apples values.
Yeah, only it was only played once, decades ago, and nothing similar ever appeared in Apple ads since then.
The Think Different campaign was created in 1997 and ended in 2002, and I'm having a hard time believing they played that ad _once_.
iOS would be just as integrated and nice if Apple released it as Open Source. But it would give people more choice, Apple would make make less money from it, and they would then be at a disadvantage compared to other companies that did control their entire ecosystem.
The problem is that closed, proprietary systems tend to create monopolies, and while the initial products may be great, monopolies are seldom good for customers.
The other mistake people make is thinking that closed or open is an either-or proposition. Apples nice iOS ecosystem wouldn't be destroyed overnight if they had a settings option marked "allow unsigned third party apps". Would that compromise their long term / whole stack vision? No.
It's time for someone to re-edit Apple's 1984 commercial and swap the logos.