We’ve seen the same with banks refusing to do business with people because of their political or social affiliations.
These seem ridiculous. Of course a business should have the ability to choose who they affiliate with, but if all businesses disassociate simultaneously, what recourse does an individual or organization have?
At the same time, who would want to hold accounts for organizations universally considered “bad”? When the label of “bad” changes at social media speed, who is safe?
As strange as it is I think we lost something when dueling and other violent extrajudicial justice stopped really being a thing. I don't want it back certainly but there is something to be said for the mediating effect that if you piss off enough people they might drag you out of your house and beat you half or fully to death. Or say literally burn down your house or business.
There's a very real asymmetry where when someone materially hurts you or your community and you don't have one of the means that society has deemed acceptable to "hit back" with you're just stuck having to put up with it.
> literally burn down your house or business
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/16th_Street_Baptist_Church_bom...
This right here I think is the absolutely fundamental tension. There are no good answers here because two people's abilities to speak are at odds. And while 1A provides an answer that spells out whose rights win out it's not clear whether this outcome is actually good.
We have public accommodation laws that very much violate a business's right to (non-) association because of burdensome effects discrimination has when no one will do business with you. And I think you can make a very strong case that the same laws could be necessary in a world where if a few large businesses refuse to do business with you it's functionally impossible to speak in any way that matters.
A 1A that upholds the speech of individual real humans above the speech of corporate entities when the two are in conflict I don't think would be a bad one.
> Social media is not that. It’s nothing like a common carrier.
The whole argument in the latter half of this article hinges on this and well… it's kind of arbitrary. Social media could be called a common carrier just as strongly as an airline could be said to curate a flying experience. Do I think the comments section of a blog post is a common carrier, no not really. But Facebook or Twitter have more in common with an ISP than a newspaper.