Re:A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explan...
by codeflo on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @05:42PM
(#40870265)
> If you scan a body of water, and simulate it perfectly, the resulting simulation will not be wet.
It will be wet to the simulated being that's swimming in it.
> Consciousness may be a result of carbon being a substrate in the interactions.
Are you conscious? If so, how did you find out that you're made from actual carbon atoms and not simulated ones?
Re:A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explan...
by BobbyJo on Wednesday July 03, 2024 @05:52PM
(#40870341)
> It will be wet to the simulated being that's swimming in it.
Which has an entirely different qualia to us, the beings who consciousness we are trying to unravel.
> Are you conscious?
That's the big question.
> If so, how did you find out that you're made from actual carbon atoms and not simulated ones?
If I assume I'm conscious, whatever my atoms are, they are the atoms of concern with regard to said consciousness.
If you scan a body of water, and simulate it perfectly, the resulting simulation will not be wet. You can't separate a material process from the material completely. Consciousness may be a result of carbon being a substrate in the interactions. It might be because the brain is wet when those processes happen. There is plenty of room between believing a perfect computational simulation is not conscious and believing in immaterial souls.