News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by mikek on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:49PM (#4085613)
> [re a slide-to-unlock patent] Apple’s .. argument is that “a tap is a zero-length swipe.” That’s silly. It’s like saying that a point is a zero-length line.

But a point is a zero-length line.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by colanderman on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:55PM (#4085646)
Your statement would imply that a point has a direction, which it does not. Also, a line does not have a length; both you and Posner meant line segment. So a correct statement would be:

A zero-length line segment is a point.

Edit: not even this is true if your definition of a line segment explicitly states that the endpoints must be distinct, as does PlanetMath's definition, as Aethaeryn points out below.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by Aethaeryn on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:21PM (#4085764)

  > A zero-length line segment is a point.
The Wikipedia definition of a line segment says that it is bound by two endpoints.[1] It provides a reference to Planet Math that goes into specifics.[2] In this page, it is made clear that the two endpoints cannot be equal. Planet Math provides an equation for a closed[3] line segment:

  L = {a + tb | t in [0, 1]}
This means that a line segment can be expressed as all of the points a + tb, where t is the range [0, 1] (which contains 0, 1 and all the points between them). It also limits a, b as real or complex numbers with b != 0. In other words, any line segment is just "morphing" the basic 0 to 1 range, with a shifting it and b scaling it.

Now, since b can't be 0, and 0 != 1, you're not going to get the endpoints of the range 0 and 1 to equal each other no matter how you scale them with b or shift them with a.[4] In other words, line segments will always have length.

Because you cannot get the endpoints to equal each other, a point cannot be thought of as a line segment under what appears to be the common definition.

-----

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_segment

[2] http://planetmath.org/encyclopedia/LineSegment.html

[3] Open is the exact same thing, except with (0, 1) instead of [0, 1] and it doesn't include the points 0 and 1.

[4] Of course, if b = 0 was allowed, you could just say that points are where b = 0 for all a.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by lmarinho on Friday June 08, 2012 @05:04PM (#4086151)
I'd also refer to Hilbert's Axioms[1], which are the basis for the modern treatment of Euclidean Geometry.

[1] http://www.gutenberg.org/files/17384/17384-pdf.pdf

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by Sniffnoy on Friday June 08, 2012 @05:32PM (#4086259)
No, the basis for the modern treatment of Euclidean geometry is the explicit construction of the plane as R^2. Axiomatization is reserved for things like set theory and elementary number theory. Although Hilbert's axioms aren't exactly even a proper axiomatization anyway, seeing as it's a second-order axiomatization, and thus requires some ambient set theory. But if you've got set theory, you may as well construct it. You could think of the axioms as just conditions, of course, but then you need an existence proof, which is provided by the explicit construction as R^2, so...
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by lmarinho on Saturday June 09, 2012 @05:13AM (#4087680)
Good point, my statement was poorly formulated. While I agree that analytic geometry and other developments in the field could be more fundamental, Hilbert's formalization can still be useful to express more precisely what one means by "points" and "lines", being, I think, applicable to the current discussion.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by Sniffnoy on Saturday June 09, 2012 @05:11PM (#4089291)
On the contrary, it's an axiomatization, and thus only describes the relation between them. If by "what one means by them" you mean a definition, then you'll need a construction for that. Of course, for the most part, the relation between them is what we mean by them; but Hilbert's formalism doesn't seem to be a good way to address such statements as the one that started this, "a point is a line segment of zero length".
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by colanderman on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:32PM (#4085804)
Ah good I was looking for the restriction b ≠ 0 but couldn't find in on the Wikipedia page. Forgot to check out PlanetMath, thanks.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by Aethaeryn on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:43PM (#4085846)
I'm actually surprised by the lack of rigor in many of the sources I checked. It's obvious that b != 0 is necessary because otherwise you can't get results like line segments having an infinite number of points, and hence equal to the amount of points in a line.[1] The thing is, a lot of common references seem to leave out that the endpoints can't be equal.[2] It's so obvious that it's just implied, but it's dangerous to treat mathematics like that!

-----

[1] http://mathworld.wolfram.com/LineSegment.html

[2] Just saying 'two distinct endpoints' instead of 'two endpoints' would work, so it's literally just one word that makes a big difference!

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by bostonpete on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:25PM (#4085775)
I think there's a difference between what's referred to as a "line" in mathematical terms and in conventional English. I believe the judge and mikek were both using the term in the latter sense.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by cwp on Friday June 08, 2012 @06:14PM (#4086409)
Yes, and a tap is, technically, a zero length swipe. But there is nevertheless a distinction between taps and swipes just as there is between points and lines. Apple's API distinguishes between the two gestures, even if Apple's lawyers don't. Claiming that tap-to-unlock violates a swipe-to-unlock patent is silly. The whole point of swipe-to-unlock is that a tap doesn't unlock the phone.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by vacri on Friday June 08, 2012 @07:44PM (#4086669)
This is what I thought the judge was getting at - yes, you can define a point as a zero-length line in theoretical space, but when you apply it to something like finger movements in the case in front of him, it's a big pile of horseshit. Describing a point as a zero-length line is a mathematical trick used to help understand a concept; it's not a real-world application of mathematics.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by johnpmayer on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:56PM (#4085651)
Depends on your definition.

In my interpretation, to be considered a line in any number of dimensions, it must be specified by no fewer than two points. This puts a lower bound on the amount of information to specify "lines", a bound strictly greater than specifying a "point" in a space of similar dimensions. Otherwise, is point also a polygon consisting entirely of zero-length sides?

But anyway, I think it was only meant to highlight the Judge's opinion of the absurdity of some claims.

edit: so glad this tiny portion was the subject of the most discussion

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by strictfp on Friday June 08, 2012 @04:04PM (#4085939)
That is the point he is trying to make. A point _can be seen_ as a zero-length line, but this is really on the boundary of the definition of a line. Likewise a zero-length swipe is a tap, but that is really stretching the definition of a swipe. Basing a court case on such a stretched definition is what he is opposing.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by hristov on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:58PM (#4085908)
Not exactly. Even if you disregard the definition arguments discussed below, and allow the definition of "line segment" to include "point" I would not say that a point is a zero length line segment.

It seems to me that the "lenght" of a point, if such a concept is to be allowed, is infinitely small but not zero. Thus, a point has length of lim(x->0) x.

To me, a zero length line segment would be nothingness.

But putting the math aside, in the context of patent law, it is important to follow the commonly accepted definitions. A person should not be able to change the meaning of his claims by suggesting new definitions. And it seems obvious that, as others have pointed out, the accepted definition of a line segment is something with finite length, and the accepted definition of a swipe is something that (obviously) results from swiping, i.e. some movement of the finger.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by throwaway___ on Friday June 08, 2012 @04:44PM (#4086080)
Euclid, Book 1, Definition 1. "A point is that which has no part."
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by trowftd on Friday June 08, 2012 @08:46PM (#4086794)
A point has no dimensions whatsoever. No length, width, or area. A point is not a zero length line segment, but not because of the reason you mention.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by twelvechairs on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:39PM (#4085832)
Yeah. This struck me as well. I think what you say is right, but probably the 'silly' part comes from the context of the legal argument.

For instance, You could also say a point is also something with 132 dimensions of data - all but one or two of which are set to 0. Does that mean if we patent ways of working with 132-dimensional data that our patents should apply to anything with fewer dimensions? Of course that would be silly....

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by meson2k on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:45PM (#4085856)
A zero-area polygon. A zero-volume hedron. etc. etc.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by SilasX on Friday June 08, 2012 @06:37PM (#4086468)
Such degeneracy!
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by seanalltogether on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:54PM (#4085641)
Only if you have a jury full of mathmeticians
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by famousactress on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:55PM (#4085644)
Is it? Maybe a zero length line segment. In geometry terms, lines are infinite, aren't they?
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by tankenmate on Friday June 08, 2012 @03:36PM (#4085816)
No. Yes.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by TeMPOraL on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:55PM (#4085647)
A zero-dimmensional equivalent of line, maybe?
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by jsprinkles on Friday June 08, 2012 @05:47PM (#4086323)
I'm beyond disappointed that the article is about the most important ruling regarding patent law in recent memory, and the overwhelming majority of this thread is arguing about the geometry cited in the judge's order. Rational people understood what he meant, even if maybe it's not 100% mathematically sound.

This pedantry really frustrates me, and it extends beyond Hacker News. It's pervasive in conversations I've been having recently as well, as if we're all looking for the slightest thing wrong with what someone has said so that we can achieve some kind of acclaim by pointing it out. I made a point recently about how people need to work together and cited a Star Trek film as a joke, and some jackass in the group decided to go to the mat with me on the fact that I had cited the wrong Star Trek film (my quote was in III, not II).

There is nothing more frustrating than a pedant. It seems like it's tech people that do it most, too, which makes sense, but still.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by ars on Friday June 08, 2012 @06:19PM (#4086420)
> and the overwhelming majority of this thread is arguing about the geometry cited in the judge's order. Rational people understood what he meant, even if maybe it's not 100% mathematically sound.

> This pedantry really frustrates me

People are well aware that they are nit picking, but they enjoy the resulting discussion! Intellectually inclined people enjoy discussing minutia with other like minded people. They are perfectly aware that it makes no difference, and they don't care - it's just something interesting to talk about. It's no longer nit picking about the original (i.e. the practical use is settled), at that point it becomes a discussion for its own sake.

Do you never learn or do anything just for the sake of doing it, rather than in order to accomplish something useful?

> and some jackass in the group decided to go to the mat with me on the fact that I had cited the wrong Star Trek film

He was showing off. If you don't wish to participate in the Star Trek memorization culture just ignore him - his comment was geared to other members of his group who do like doing that. Or simply acknowledge that he was right and move on. Clearly you don't care about that topic, so that acknowledgement shouldn't cost you too much ego.

That's also the point of threads: You can ignore an entire thread that is off topic - but it also gives people who found something interesting a place to talk about it without disturbing the rest of the conversation.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by Produce on Sunday June 10, 2012 @03:07PM (#4091870)
>People are well aware that they are nit picking, but they enjoy the resulting discussion! Intellectually inclined people enjoy discussing minutia with other like minded people. They are perfectly aware that it makes no difference, and they don't care - it's just something interesting to talk about. It's no longer nit picking about the original (i.e. the practical use is settled), at that point it becomes a discussion for its own sake.

Pedantry like that indicates that the person may be suffering from OCD, not that they have a high IQ. There is a correlation between intelligence and anxiety-spectrum disorders but there are, ofcourse, many anxious people who have low IQ's too.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by jsprinkles on Friday June 08, 2012 @06:34PM (#4086455)
Your entire comment would be wise were it not for, both in the case of my anecdote and this original comment, the observation that someone is incorrect. It's one thing to enjoy intellectual pursuits, it's another to put down others, belittle them, or critique their opinions because of a perceived mistake they made (such as the geometry). It's doubly worse if the mistake has no bearing whatsoever on the actual opinion, like the finding and the opinion I was sharing in my anecdote.

Also, I like to think of myself as intellectually inclined, and I simply hate discussing and arguing minutia like this. It just doesn't matter, and my time is limited. I don't want to argue with you on what Dickens meant by a certain character's dialogue in David Copperfield, I'd just like to enjoy it as a great novel. (That is fairly specific, and there are instances where it's fun to think about, but in general it isn't.)

> Clearly you don't care about that topic, so that acknowledgement shouldn't cost you too much ego.

Not about my ego, oddly (most everything else is, but this isn't). It undermines the opinion or discussion at hand from everybody else's perspective, however subtly. It's an annoying opportunity to show off, as you say, like those people that get up at conferences and ask a question that shows off at the expense of everyone listening. Both are distractions from the topic and are a detriment to the conversation, regardless of their original purpose.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by ars on Friday June 08, 2012 @07:26PM (#4086614)
> the observation that someone is incorrect ... to put down others, belittle them, or critique their opinions

I really don't think they are doing that. They understand that for the normal purpose he's right, they are just talking about mathematics, or general cases. At this point it's removed from the original, they are no longer talking about him (the Judge) they are talking about the concept in general.

> I like to think of myself as intellectually inclined

and

> and there are instances where it's fun to think about

There you go. There is no rule that says you have to enjoy talking about the same things as someone else. Each person likes their own stuff.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by larrys on Friday June 08, 2012 @11:47PM (#4087113)
"it's another to put down others, belittle them, or critique their opinions because of a perceived mistake they made (such as the geometry)"

I would guess that people who are in certain professions which require precision would be more likely to act this way. Because lack of precision would cause the plane to crash or the bridge to fail or the code to croak. Medicine (drugs) for example is not really super precise when you think about it. Dosing isn't so critical that if you take a little more or a little less you end up dead or sick. You have latitude. (Of course someone who knows more than I about this would point out that coumadin (Warfarin) dosing is quite critical and correct me.)

Have you found that to be the case in your IRL conversations?

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by jsprinkles on Saturday June 09, 2012 @12:52AM (#4087229)
No. Most of my conversations revolve around my career, and I'm a system administrator. Bike shedding I had already identified to be a problem. Pedantry like this I'm starting to notice as well.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by larrys on Friday June 08, 2012 @11:37PM (#4087090)
"It's pervasive in conversations I've been having recently as well"

It's so much easier to do this as a result of information so readily available at your finger tip. So any statement anyone makes can be quickly verified and corrected with pretty good precision. Wondering if the people who corrected you in conversations looked up the fact on their iphone (or whatever) while you weren't looking.

Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by planetguy on Friday June 08, 2012 @02:51PM (#4085627)
If my high school maths teacher were here he'd say that a point is a zero-length line segment.
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by cglace on Friday June 08, 2012 @04:22PM (#4086002)
Except it isn't. Doesn't a line segment required two distinct endpoints?
Re:Famous judge spikes Apple-Google case, calls patent syste... by ktizo on Friday June 08, 2012 @10:43PM (#4086999)
Sometimes it is useful to think of a really short line becoming a point, like in calculus, but that doesn't mean a point is a really short line any more than its a really tiny triangle or anything else we want to scale to a point.