News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study of 49 programmers: static type system had no effect... by quadhome on Friday June 08, 2012 @05:20AM (#4083426)
Please read the paper and not the HN title.

The paper's title is casting doubts on the positive impact of statically typed languages as they had a negative impact on development time. (though not quality)

Re:Study of 49 programmers: static type system had no effect... by cageface on Friday June 08, 2012 @05:40AM (#4083469)
From the very first paragraph:

In the experiments the existence of the static type system has neither a positive nor a negative impact on an application's development time (under the conditions of the experiment).

What's the point of dynamic languages if they don't even make the initial implementation faster? They're certainly harder to maintain afterwards.

Re:Study of 49 programmers: static type system had no effect... by quadhome on Friday June 08, 2012 @05:56AM (#4083506)
From the conclusion:

We measured two different points in the development: first, the development time until a minimal scanner has been implemented, and second the quality of the resulting software measured by the number of successful test cases fulfilled by the parser. In none of these measured points the use of a static type system turned out to have a successful impact. In the first case, the use of a statically typed programming language had a significant negative impact, in the latter one, no significant difference could be measured.

Re:Study of 49 programmers: static type system had no effect... by jfoutz on Friday June 08, 2012 @10:29AM (#4084326)
Here's my pet unprovable theory. Development time is dominated by a programmer's understanding of a problem. Static languages force programmers to say a lot about their understanding of a problem.

Dynamic code can be very fast, but in lisp, after algorithms, that means actually going and finding all of the calls to elt and replacing them by calls to nth. With a static language the compiler has a much better chance of specializing the code for you.