News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heroku is down by rdl on Thursday June 07, 2012 @04:50PM (#4081266)
Ultimately this is why it would be nice for the code/configuration to be independent of the operations. I agree it is unreasonable to expect a random developer to build AND MAINTAIN the entire stack for every project. PaaS makes a lot of sense, especially as a starting place.

The solution is either to have a PaaS provider who ruthlessly eliminates single points of failure (there isn't one, currently), or use some standardized software system which can be operated by multiple independent operators with nothing shared. Unfortunately, the only vendor-independent infrastructure is the physical server, various forms of VPS, etc. -- it's all at the IaaS level. As far as I know there's no PaaS type thing with a common interface which arbitrary providers can operate, with some kind of marketplace for users to pick operators independently from the technology.

Re:Heroku is down by T-hawk on Thursday June 07, 2012 @06:23PM (#4081656)
The solution is either to have a PaaS provider who ruthlessly eliminates single points of failure (there isn't one, currently)

This isn't possible by definition, right? The PaaS provider itself becomes the single point of failure.

Rings a bit like a "Who created God?" argument. "What single entity can I use to defend against failures by a single entity?"

Re:Heroku is down by rdl on Friday June 08, 2012 @12:41AM (#4082713)
Theoretically, sure, but it's an engineering and economic thing.

You can mitigate specific risks, and you try to prioritize those based on cost, frequency, and severity. If there were a great redundant provider with good authentication on accounts, a strong balance sheet and business, and sane policies on managing accounts, you would be fairly safe using just that provider. After all, you could always get a court order to cease providing services, yourselves, like if you do something some troll has patented. It kind of depends on your application, too -- if I were doing a wikileaks, a bitcoin exchange or torrent site or some other legally at risk business, I'd want country-level separation across multiple providers, at least as a cold backup. Casual game for facebook or mobile, not really much of a concern.