The reason I like Justin's site (we don't know each other) is because you can tell it is:
a) personally curated b) not updated too often (i.e. tried and tested products) and c) supposed to be a definitive resource for someone who doesn't want to shop around & trusts his opinion
It might be an idea to avoid the generic or goofy items that make it look like your own personal Pinterest, and instead make it a site where your network of friends genuinely benefit from your personal experience of the items.
Re:Buy these 9 things
by acoyfellow on Thursday June 07, 2012 @02:00PM
(#4080393)
Awesome.. Great points to take to heart, since his site and my idea are actually so similar. I'm a little ashamed of myself for not knowing about his site before I started working on 9things.
It's ok though.. He's got a job and a rep. I don't have either, so I've got to make it work for me :)
I was really aiming for an outlet to sell items, that are personally endorsed by me. I understand HN's viewers will most likely not buy my items- I was assuming the more than likely purchaser would be someone who I know directly, or indirectly, already. I have a large number of contacts of people I know personally, one time or another, who I have healthy relationships with. I'd estimate that number to be in the low 1,000 range.
I want to try and make those 1,000 people know that I 1) run this service, 2) love the items, and 3) update it regularly with new items. If i can get a small base of fans who enjoy this idea, then I can push to expand that number of happy people..
I was really coming to HN for advice on how to grow this into a sustainable business idea. I've gotten great advice so far, and it's all welcomed warmly.