In the same way your freedom of movement doesn't allow you to walk over (like literally step on top of) other people.
Rights aren't an absolute literal things. There are always limitations.
Size matters. Organisation matters. Joe saying something is his free speech. Joe buying ads to say something is free speech. 50 people getting a billion USD to advertise how the gay alien lizards are controlling the sheople isn't the same thing because it has an outsized impact. An association of people isn't a human. In many languages there are even specific terms for "physical person" and "juridical person" (like a company, association, grouping, etc.). It doesn't get human rights.
And of course, most importantly of all, it's trivially obvious that to preserve a democratic society there need to be restrictions on campaign funding, advertisments and everything around that. Otherwise you can have extremely rich people simply innundating everyone with their views, skewing people's opinions and getting the results they want instead.
I don't think anyone is arguing that rights are unimpeachable, you just need a VERY good justification. Even for freedom of speech, most would agree that threats, CSAM, or night time noise should be limited, even if they are direct violations of your right to speech.
The problem with this issue is that you need to have a clear and unambiguous rule, that does not cause more harm than good. Let's look at your reasoning.
> 50 people getting a billion USD to advertise how the gay alien lizards are controlling the sheople isn't the same thing because it has an outsized impact.
What about a celebrity? Joe Rogan invites RFK onto his podcast to undermine democrats and spread conspiracies. He has effectively donated his time and platform to a politician. Is that okay under your principle? If it is, why is it different?
> An association of people isn't a human.
This is a pointless distinction because an association is comprised of people. But let's grant that(I would not grant it), would you say the same about other activist organizations? Most Jewish people support Israel, and even without big donors they can pressure politicians in an outsized way through their activist organizations. Should they be silenced?
> And of course, most importantly of all, it's trivially obvious that to preserve a democratic society there need to be restrictions on campaign funding, advertisments and everything around that
This is not trivially obvious. You need to demonstrate that the specific thing you're worried about is actually an issue. If we looked at some studies and they showed that money in politics is a fairly minor issue, would you abandon this pet-issue?
When Boeing or any of the oil giants or a megachurch/any other cult kill or defraud people, the organisation doesn't go to prison. There's a small fine, cost of doing business, nothing more.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC
This is the moment when USA started morphing from a republic to oligarchy.
Free speech can generally be constrained - it is not absolute right (Article 19 of ICCPR), so every case where restriction is considered must take into account the context and the other human rights, rather than granting the free speech right unconditionally. I don’t think SCOTUS understood well the gravity of their decision back then.
When considering free speech for corporations, it must be taken into account that corporations often have more resources at disposal which they can use to amplify the voices of their shareholders or management, distorting the democratic process. Right to choose the government and hold it accountable is also a human right, which is clearly harmed by created imbalance of power. This is exactly what has happened in America, making some researchers calling it oligarchy rather than republic.
No, this is the main objection. You need to justify why, and how, you're going to restrict freedom of speech instead of avoiding the problem.
> Free speech can generally be constrained - it is not absolute right (Article 19 of ICCPR), so every case where restriction is considered must take into account the context and the other human rights, rather than granting the free speech right unconditionally. I don’t think SCOTUS understood well the gravity of their decision back then.
Irrelevant, the U.S does not respect the ICCPR regarding freedom of speech. But either way, no one is arguing that free speech is absolute. This is a straw man.
> When considering free speech for corporations, it must be taken into account that corporations often have more resources at disposal which they can use to amplify the voices of their shareholders or management distorting the democratic process.
So? Lots of things distort the democratic process. Why is this different than a celebrity, an activist group, or demographic behavior distorting the democratic process? Can you quantify and demonstrate the effect?
> Right to choose the government and hold it accountable is also a human right, which is clearly harmed by created imbalance of power. This is exactly what has happened in America, making some researchers calling it oligarchy rather than republic.
Sorry, I didn't realize we slipped into an alternate dimension where poor people could not vote. Just kidding, haha. Sounds more like you're sour that your political project isn't popular.
I do not understand this part. I'm literally explaining why and how in the next sentences.
>Irrelevant, the U.S does not respect the ICCPR regarding freedom of speech.
Proof? As far as I can see, this is incorrect: https://www.aclu.org/documents/faq-covenant-civil-political-...
> Free speech can generally be constrained > But either way, no one is arguing that free speech is absolute. This is a straw man.
No it is not. This argument was not used to address something in the thread, it is used as a foundation for the next paragraph (and I needed to say it because on this forum some people actually argued that free speech is absolute in the past, so I cannot assume that you or anyone else agrees with that).
>So? Lots of things distort the democratic process. Why is this different than...
Every distortion is different and has some unique traits that need to be considered on case by case basis. Example: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/docume...
>...where poor people could not vote
People can vote even in totalitarian dictatorships. It is not the only process that defines democracy. They must have a candidate to vote in the first place. What are the chances that a candidate outside of existing party structures and their fundraising machines will be able to communicate own political views to a sufficient number of voters? How this candidate can secure a party nomination in presence of various special interests groups with money? The list of questions like that is very long. So no, it is not about "poor people who cannot vote". It is a much more complex issue.
>Sounds more like you're sour that your political project isn't popular.
You are too quick to jump to conclusions. I don't have/support any political projects related to USA. That country is not my problem, it's just an object of my curiosity.
Your link actually backs up my point.
> No it is not. This argument was not used to address something in the thread, it is used as a foundation for the next paragraph
Fair.
> Every distortion is different and has some unique traits that need to be considered on case by case basis. Example: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/files/docume...
This document is about funding transparency, and seems unrelated to what I said. Are you trolling me?
> What are the chances that a candidate outside of existing party structures and their fundraising machines will be able to communicate own political views to a sufficient number of voters?
Very good, actually. Donald Trump was a party outsider, and far different from establishment Republicans. Bernie Sanders was second place in the primaries, twice in a row, and does not identify with the party, he simply invites himself in during election season. They both received tons of funding from various sources, with small contributions making up a large chunk of their funding. Turns out if you're popular money will flow your way.
Nothing per se. However if Bob and Joe are "running ads about how bad Issue X is," I'd like to know (or at least be able to find out) that it's Bob and Joe and not Steve and Larry who are financing such ads.
While no one has mentioned it here yet, it seems to me that "dark money"[0] is a significant issue.
[0] https://campaignlegal.org/update/pacs-super-pacs-dark-money-...