http://www.realchat.com/blog/java-vs-flash/
By the way I am not discounting Java as a viable platform. It works in many cases, Runescape proves that being the #2 North American MMO. But it doesn't do that with graphical quality. It does it with gameplay and the progression etc. As of right now the best looking platforms and easiest to develop for are Unity3D and Flash for the web, if we are talking developing games for the browser.
EDIT: btw those numbers are old, these are newer: http://kaioa.com/node/40 But still 1.6 is about 70% penetration.
Flash loses out largely for the lack of good accelerated 3D. I've played with papervision but it's just too slow for a anything decent, that I can guarantee will run on even moderately equipped machines.