News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by ryandrake on Thursday June 20, 2024 @10:58AM (#40739474)
> (i) physicsts don't want to give up the beautiful and geometric simplicity of 1/r^2

Not a physicist here, so maybe this is a naive question: but is this really something that they care about? Why does a formula describing some physical principle have to beautiful and simple? Aren't we supposed to observe reality and then come up with the math? Rather than start with a "known true" equation and add factors and parameters it as more and more observations call the equation into question? Who's in charge of the direction physics proceeds? The observing scientists or the mathematicians?

Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by jlokier on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:53AM (#40740139)
It's not about the formula. The formula comes from the geometry.

1/r^2 falls out as the formula, starting from the geometry of "flux" and "field lines", along with "conservation of flux", in 3d space.

That's the idea that the force acts like something that's radiated in all directions, that doesn't fade with distance, instead it just spreads out so it seems weaker at individual points. The amount of spreading out, if it's uniform in 3d, turns out to be exactly 1/r^2.

You get the same 1/r^2 if you measure the flow of water in a 3d volume with a point source of water in the centre, or electric current in a 3d block of metal with a point source of electric current in the centre. (In both cases, presumably through a thin pipe or cable to the centre).

In 2d space, you get a different formula from the geometry, 1/r. If you see a force, or flow, reducing by 1/r^2 in a system you thought was 2d, you might ask "is there a third dimension involved here which I haven't accounted for?"

In 1d, the force or flow doesn't reduce with distance. For example, current in an electrical wire is the same all along the wire.

And if you see 1/r^3 in 3d, you might speculate about a hidden fourth dimension to explain it.

Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by xeonmc on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:01AM (#40739499)
1/r^2 directly comes from how much area an object spans your field of view vs how far away it is. To a paraxial approximation, of course.
Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by empath75 on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:58AM (#40740187)
They will 100% replace 1/r^2 in an instant if they find something else that matches results better.
Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by naasking on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:26PM (#40740476)
I don't think history bears this out. "Science progresses one funeral at a time", as they say.
Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by yetihehe on Friday June 21, 2024 @09:22AM (#40749347)
But that 1/r^2 is very old, with a lot of people standing at the cemetery peeking at their watch and thinking "now how much longer will this take, come on!".
Re:Rotation curves: still flat after a million light-years by wyager on Thursday June 20, 2024 @11:17AM (#40739700)
A general principle of science is that simpler explanations are more likely. Rule-of-thumb described by Occam's razor, formalized by concepts like Solomonoff induction. Rules like 1/r^2, being simple, are assigned a higher prior probability.

This makes sense because otherwise you waste a bunch of time on overfitted theories.