https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5391018/
It's not good enough for diagnosis - you want to hit 95+% accuracy for diagnostic. And MRIs are extremely expensive compared to 2-3 outpatient psychology appointments. But it's real.
>It's not good enough for diagnosis - you want to hit 95+% accuracy for diagnostic.
This doesn't quite make sense to me, because you're comparing it to the current diagnostic criteria and assuming it to be 100% accurate.
If we want to be totally scientific, we ought to just do these scans and diagnose people with low gray matter volume, etc and drop the DSM, ADHD etc.
Two major problems with studies like this:
1. The number of brain sub-regions and associated variables they're looking at is huge. Perhaps more than the number of patients in the study, depending on how you look at the data. If you collect enough data points on two groups of about ~30 people each and you run enough regressions, eventually you'll find some model that works on your small data set. This would need to be tested against a much larger cohort.
2. They did not control for stimulant usage at all. In fact, they note that stimulant use was vastly higher in the ADHD group, because obviously you need an ADHD diagnosis to receive ongoing stimulant prescriptions. It's a delicate topic, but we know that stimulant use in some cases is associated with changes in brain structure and blood flow. It's a huge variable that is hard to control for in a study like this.
Overall, I don't find a study with 31 ADHD patients that tested dozens and dozens of different variables to be all that conclusive. Perhaps useful for focusing future research, but a singular study like this isn't very conclusive.
If the direction of causality there was not overtly obvious (as nobody starts out anything even close to a master), one could easily assume those differences caused one to be a master, rather than vice versa. It's the exact same issue here, except the direction of causality is unclear. You're seeing a shared morphometric difference among people of some trait (ADHD) and then just assuming that that difference causes ADHD, rather than that ADHD causes the difference!
To even assume this is the case one would need to perform MRIs on random very young individuals prior to ADHD diagnoses, and then make a prediction, based solely on that MRI, on which ones would be diagnosed with ADHD with no input or information given to the participants before a follow study in a decade or so. That study would then help prove the direction of causality that's seemingly just simply being assumed in this one.
[1] - https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/neuroscience/articles/1...
Would this be useful? I think so: It would then be possible to assess the accuracy of a written test.
I think the risk of conflation with stimulant use that another poster mentioned is very real, though, and that problem is a close cousin of the "direction of causality" problem.
In particular this whole thread of discussion started back with somebody expressing a bit of skepticism about the definitive nature of ADHD (and other psychiatric disorders) and somebody responded with the brain morphometrics as proof of such, yet in reality that's mostly still just begging the question.
That said, all these studies are done way after ADHD was established. That is, ADHD as a concept wasn't established by looking at neurological brain scans or any kind of physical evidence. Makes me wonder what the exact thought process was for establishing the DSM.
I still feel like if I made up a disorder by coming up with 9 semi-normal behaviors as symptoms, enough people would just by chance meet most of the criteria, and imaging scans would find some difference. Wish I was rich so I could conduct that experiment myself.
And how significant are these results? Are we talking about a few percent difference? Are 10% of diagnoses ADHD shown to have statistically significant differences, 20, 50, 90? Depending on the figure, my criticism of the diagnostic criteria remains. Because if it is a low figure like 10%, that means 90% of the diagnoses aren't supported by any scientific evidence.
From what I've been told, including professionals this evidence does not exist.
I've also seen studies which indicate that psychiatric evaluations are entirely inconsistent across physicians.