With physical ailments, symptoms are surface manifestations of an underlying physical cause. For example, fever and fatigue in flu are the result of the influenza virus. Crucially, you can have the physical cause without symptoms (such as in the presymptomatic period), so the two are dissociable. Even where the physical cause is unknown, there's still this symptom-cause distinction.
In the case of mental disorders, they're essentially defined by the symptoms. To have depression is to be depressed. To have anxiety is to be anxious. What would it even mean to have depression without being depressed?
While on some level these are physical in a sense (insofar as they result from brain activity), I don't necessarily think we should think about their cause in the same way as a physical ailment.
More to the point, there's a much more obvious sociocultral element to mental disorders. There's no 'objective' line between being sad and being depressed so while we clearly can and should treat depression, it seems to be very different from other diseases.
None of this is to take away from the real suffering people undergo with these disorders. I just don't think that treating them through a strict biological-pathological lens is as useful as people think it is.
This is what we see historically, in the 19th and early 20th centuries, in "body medicine". We're just at an earlier stage of understanding and treating psychiatric disorders. I assume in a couple hundred years we'll look back at the current state of the art as hopelessly outmoded.
> In the case of mental disorders, they're essentially defined by the symptoms. To have depression is to be depressed. To have anxiety is to be anxious. What would it even mean to have depression without being depressed?
What would it mean to have typhoid without an actual fever? The disease is something else, some causative factor that is not the actual symptom itself, but is no less real for that.
> I just don't think that treating them through a strict biological-pathological lens is as useful as people think it is.
Agreed, but that's with the current state of the art. I would be surprised indeed if by 2080 we didn't have a different lens to view these things through.
Imo we'll come to see that these categorizations of mental disorders are far too simplistic
The mind is much more of a complex system than that.
I like to think of it with an analogy like you have a very intricate 3D maze and have to get a tiny ball into a hole, but you can only ever move the maze in one direction, and it resets between tries. Something like SSRI just pushes everything one way in a big swipe, and sure it might just solve a particular puzzle, but there are endless others where such low-precision method has no way of succeeding. Of course that’s why psychotherapy is a must have for any sort of medication.
There a pretty long list of idiopathic physical ailments, and there are some mental disorders that have specific mechanisms. I get the generalization, but the reality is more jumbled.
I have diagnosed ADHD, and I take mental health very seriously. I have zero such prejudice.
By "definite" things I mean, singular, physical causes which can be pointed to.
I have skin in the game on this one and in my own experience sloppy diagnostics have caused way more suffering than stigma. I was nodding along with gp’s entire point. Your confidently dismissive chastisement is what feels out of line.
Thus the result of these situations is many people cannot afford (or even if they can, sometimes no) proper care necessary to them. Gatekeeping types of arguments like these do not make that better.
Or I guess, if you have skin in the game it does make sense to criticize the people criticizing the game instead of the people perpetuating it
> in this hypercapitalist healthcare system (speaking of the USA specifically here), whether or not it is “worthy” of care
If I was a pharmaceutical company, it would be in my financial best interest to deem as many people eligible as possible. If I was the director of some mental health thing somewhere, it would be in my financial best interest to make sure as many people buy into it as possible
Regarding big pharma, they are certainly to blame, but you don’t really see similar types of discussions regarding purely physical ailments like cancer.
As I said in my comments I am approaching this as a moderator for mental health groups where this type of discussion frequently arises and to point out a line of reasoning I frequently have to deal with.
Cancer is an extreme example here because being 1. Based on hard physical evidence and 2. having a huge liability for misdiagnosis, doctors/hospitals would be in huge trouble if they diagnosed you with cancer and gave you chemo when you did not have it. This serves as a check against pharmaceutical interests.
Mental diagnoses/treatment on the other hand is mostly done in independent offices, private practices, and in prisons/institutions on committed people, and it carries very little risk if misdiagnosed. With adhd its even worse, because its often a diagnosis a patient seeks.
I really don't understand where you're coming from. It seems you don't want people to criticize psychiatry because it makes some people feel bad not having the validation of these disorders being a totally legit, agreed upon science?
I think that's taking the completely wrong angle, like I said I am diagnosed and I don't feel bad about it one bit despite all my opinions here.
The admins there for example have decided that 1. The word "neurotypical" is banned, 2. One cannot say adhd isnt a disorder / adhd might have benefits. 3. Discussing negatives of medication seems to be removed
ADHD in particular is further complicated by the fact that there are many, many drug seekers that game the system and even fool themselves. Even worse these drug seekers have collectively done alot to create scarcity in a limited supply of a class of drugs that many people think they need to survive - (i am making no comment about the efficacy of adhd meds) - so strong violent opinions are evoked (understandably). That is why these rules are in place. People simply cannot discuss the subject rationally. I do not try to involve myself in those communities, but many of the Autism spectrum disorder communities and depression support groups don’t suffer similar issues and people that try to gatekeep are promptly scolded. I do acknowledge adhd forums are a unique place for the reasons I mentioned above.
I agree with almost everything you've written here, and have the same sympathies, except that I don't think it's legitimate to criticise the style of argument you criticise just because it's often used to subtly question whether people are "actually" suffering (and I agree that it is often used that way).
We will never advance our understanding of psychiatry if we can't criticize it, and I for one definitely don't think we already perfected it.
You called this reasoning "completely faulty" in your previous comment, which clearly goes well beyond that.
What you are actually trying to do is stigmatise a valid form of reasoning, by association.
This kind of reasoning is completely faulty and rampant in discussions that usually hold a fair amount of stigma towards people experiencing mental health conditions (it’s also extremely insulting fyi).
I can have a headache, and there may be an unknown biological mechanism, but that doesn’t mean I’m not experiencing a headache.