Re:Kids should be building rockets and robots, not taking st...
by TeMPOraL on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @02:47AM
(#4072705)
> The purpose is to test if you can read a passage and comprehend it. Has nothing to do with microscopes. Has nothing to do with "teaching science", as the writer asserts.
There are lot of comments here referring to the fact that this exercis used in original post was a reading comprehention test, not 'understanding of the microscope' test. It may be so, but it's still a bad test, and the mistake is on the test authors' side. Why?
Because one of the principles of testing is that you should control for any variable that you do not wish to test. Here, they didn't control for the "I know better than test author how this work, because I have (read a whole book about it || been using it since 8 years old || built one)" factor. And that, for many students, converts the test into a choice - should I write what they expect me to, or should I write how the world really is?
If we teach kids to always choose the first option, do we want to live in this world when they grow up and start running it?
So why not, instead, test reading comprehention on fictional topics (like operating a 'fluxklux' device), thus making sure that no-one can have pre-existing knowledge of it to interfere with reading comprehention?
There are lot of comments here referring to the fact that this exercis used in original post was a reading comprehention test, not 'understanding of the microscope' test. It may be so, but it's still a bad test, and the mistake is on the test authors' side. Why?
Because one of the principles of testing is that you should control for any variable that you do not wish to test. Here, they didn't control for the "I know better than test author how this work, because I have (read a whole book about it || been using it since 8 years old || built one)" factor. And that, for many students, converts the test into a choice - should I write what they expect me to, or should I write how the world really is?
If we teach kids to always choose the first option, do we want to live in this world when they grow up and start running it?
So why not, instead, test reading comprehention on fictional topics (like operating a 'fluxklux' device), thus making sure that no-one can have pre-existing knowledge of it to interfere with reading comprehention?