Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by criddell on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:26PM
(#40721871)
If a particle is an excitation of a quantum field, what is a wave?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by itishappy on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:34PM
(#40721948)
The same thing. A wave is just something that obeys the wave equation by wiggling in a certain way.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by oneshtein on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:39AM
(#40726918)
In some mathematical models, a particle is an excitation of a field, e.g. a mountain is an excitation of a height field. It makes calculations much easier. In those models, waves can be represented in many different ways.
In the real world, a particle can be a lot of different things, but usually we use this word to describe small parts of larger objects. There is no much physical difference between a small grain of sand and a planet, but we use different words for them, while we use the same word for small things, which can be different by many orders of magnitude.
In the real world, a wave, is just a form of group behavior of particles, i.e. many particles are doing the same thing at once because of an interaction between them and some energy in a system. For example, merging of black holes makes waves in a galaxy, so we can watch that in super slow motion.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by criddell on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:21PM
(#40731537)
> In the real world, a particle can be a lot of different things
I thought the idea that a particle is an excitation of a quantum field was broadly accepted.
Re:A common misunderstanding about wave-particle duality
by oneshtein on Thursday June 20, 2024 @12:25AM
(#40734899)
It's broadly accepted by "shut up and calculate" guys.