Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg...
by bla3 on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:07PM
(#40713407)
For what it's worth, I used to be certain that I thought in words too. Then I moved to a different country and used a second language often enough that I sometimes think in it. I then realized that there are periods where I think in neither my native language nor in my second language, even when I'm thinking. YMMV of course.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg...
by draculero on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:17AM
(#40714029)
I usually dream in English - but I don't speak English. But I understand everything thanks to my dream's subtitles.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg...
by Zambyte on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:21PM
(#40713476)
Do you find your domain of thought shifts when you do not think with language? For example, do you feel you are able to do complex reasoning without language?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg...
by dotnet00 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:18AM
(#40714032)
This describes my experience nicely too, although I didn't quite realize it until reading this. I was thinking I just thought in words and had a tendency to mix up the bits of various languages I know some words from, but occasionally I have some thought, then for one reason or another become conscious of the thought and get confused which language I was thinking in. Sometimes this even manifests as trying to mix languages (eg at one point I used to struggle to not sprinkle in french and farsi words into normal english, despite speaking english at a native level and only knowing the basics of the other two).
I've always thought of my mental model as an endless conversation with myself, but I think the more fitting description would be a "smooth" series of thoughts which only materialize into language when I explicitly focus on those thoughts as their own thing.
I do also think visually for things that have a visual component though.