As we used to say on /.: "Citation needed".
Perhaps some aspects of the above have been challenged or questioned in the interim. But that's my recollection of the precautions he took, or at least said he took, according to those sources.
Having said that I think it’s also a great example of how even he had no meaningful understanding of what he was actually looking at or the context in which it existed.
Or at least that’s the most charitable interpretation of the useful idiot theory that I can think of. It’s also unfortunately a really good example of why credible people think it was an operation from the get go because those steps really only make sense to the general public.
If there were other precautions he could have reasonably taken -- that would also be usable by regular journalists -- then you could just state what they are, rather than alluding to them.
The video sounds interesting, but I won't be able to give it a look for quite some time. Plus I'd like to know what your view specifically is on the matter.
Essentially that his motivations were something entirely different to his version of events.
It’s ultimately an impossible question to answer most likely.
His stated motivations make sense on the surface for sure but I think there are still some big questions around assuming it’s all true, what steps did he take along the way to minimise unnecessary damage and I can’t recall much on that front worth pointing to.
He left that for a proper class of journalists.
Articulate what (even category) of damage you feel he did, that wasn't also about .gov actions that were outright illegal, and/or being hidden from the very citizens paying the bill, and maybe you'll have a discussion here.
I'm still pretty convinced the whole thing was a US operation, to shut up the people who would insist everyone who knew about these things was a crackpot. Could the current push for NIST 800-171/CMMC have really happened without Snowden, or something much worse?
Didn't they lose all biometric info for all federal employees in the OPM hack? Fingerprints and retinal images (for those who had them) too?
Everyone can just keep reading until they find the parts they haven't heard about, now.
But from their point of view, it’s really in no way obvious that this wasn’t an operation from the very start.
The FBIs chief spy catcher was actually working as a liaison officer in Moscow when this happened and he talks about it in some detail here in this interview (will update with timestamps later if I can find it) https://www.youtube.com/live/0NSGOJs150w but in his experience this is actually EXACTLY what he would expect an operation like that to look like and there has never been any clear evidence in the years since that would put a meaningful dent in that theory.
The other point I wanted to make was that because people tend to have no real idea beyond movies as to how intelligence agencies actually function in real life they have no context for where he fit into the bigger picture.
But Snowden was never some super spy or anything like that, he has zero operational experience or context he was just a Microsoft SharePoint administrator who had a security clearance.
He demonstrated numerous times since then that he actually had no meaningful context as to what he was actually leaking for into the wider operational picture or what kinds of controls were in place around its usage. He made a unilateral decision to take as much classified information as he could possibly get his hands on and then leak it with no regards to the consequences that came with it.
There are legitimate reasons to be upset with certain actions of the US intel community I am not here to do some wholesale defence on their behalf but this image he has built for himself as some heroic whistleblower is built on incredibly flimsy evidence. There is a reason why he has essentially zero defenders inside the intelligence community and I would put it to you that it’s not simply because “they are all evil”.