Re:Perplexity AI is lying about their user agent
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday June 15, 2024 @11:53PM
(#40694564)
"Everything from ad blockers to reader mode to screen readers do exactly the same thing that Perplexity is doing here, with the only difference being that they tend to be exclusively local."
That is quite an important difference. IMHO.
"I don't want to live in a world where website owners can use DRM to force me to display their website in exactly the way that their designers envisioned it. I want to be able to write scripts to manipulate the page and present it in a way that's useful for me."
This is fundamentally different from a statement like, "I want to to able to access a third party server that accesses someone else's website, manipulates the pages and presents them in a way chosen by the third party that I find appealing."
These third party intermediaries, like Perplexity.ai, are not the same as a www user who retrieves a page from a website and reformats it to a suitable presentation, according to her own particular tastes, for her own consumption. The www user is not republishing or otherwise disseminating the reformatted page, and not for the purpose of generating web traffic, collecting data and profiting from the sale of advertising services. The www user may not even have their own website. Most www users do not have a website, let alone a search engine like Perplexity.ai.
There is no relationship between (a) the basic freedom of www users to choose their own www client, whether it is W3C linemode, Google Chrome or something the user wrote themselves, and (b) a third party intermediary that retrieves and redistributes/republishes other peoples' content for profit, without permission. Perplexity.ai is a server, a search engine, a website, not an http client.
That is quite an important difference. IMHO.
"I don't want to live in a world where website owners can use DRM to force me to display their website in exactly the way that their designers envisioned it. I want to be able to write scripts to manipulate the page and present it in a way that's useful for me."
This is fundamentally different from a statement like, "I want to to able to access a third party server that accesses someone else's website, manipulates the pages and presents them in a way chosen by the third party that I find appealing."
These third party intermediaries, like Perplexity.ai, are not the same as a www user who retrieves a page from a website and reformats it to a suitable presentation, according to her own particular tastes, for her own consumption. The www user is not republishing or otherwise disseminating the reformatted page, and not for the purpose of generating web traffic, collecting data and profiting from the sale of advertising services. The www user may not even have their own website. Most www users do not have a website, let alone a search engine like Perplexity.ai.
There is no relationship between (a) the basic freedom of www users to choose their own www client, whether it is W3C linemode, Google Chrome or something the user wrote themselves, and (b) a third party intermediary that retrieves and redistributes/republishes other peoples' content for profit, without permission. Perplexity.ai is a server, a search engine, a website, not an http client.