News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by candiddevmike on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:05PM (#40682025)
> The European Commission has determined that the iPhone maker is not complying with obligations to allow app developers to “steer” users to offers outside its App Store without imposing fees on them, according to three people with close knowledge of its investigation.

I think that's a fair assessment based on the bizarre fees and hoops Apple has created under the guise of malicious compliance. There was even a brief moment where they blocked PWAs.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by talldayo on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:09PM (#40682053)
The Core Technology Fee was such a mistake, on Apple's part. Presumably it's their attempt at creating a defensible position ("well it's not the App Store but our core technology now"), but it also relocates a relatively volatile discussion from just the App Store to the iPhone itself.

Apple knows what they're doing, they even retroactively added a Free software carveout to the policy in an attempt to offer an olive branch. The longer they spend trying to reinvent the same racket though, the more obvious their market damages become. And if the EU lets them get away with that, they'll let them get away with anything. The US suit ought to bring the hammer down, and threaten Apple with a breakup if they can't find a way to compete with third-parties naturally.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by chucke1992 on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:15PM (#40682097)
Apple's hope is probably EU backepdaling or something but as Microsoft vs USA demonstrated, the government machine can be very slow but if it wants to - it will get the things done.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by Retric on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:54PM (#40682468)
I think Microsoft vs USA demonstrates that stalling until a new administration shows up can be a valid tactic. It’s not guaranteed to work, but even if the odds are say 20% that’s far from nothing when you’re talking 100’s of billions of dollars.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by chucke1992 on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:59PM (#40683177)
It allowed them to avoid breakup but it still immensely affected Microsoft creating the dead decade or whatever it was called. Nobody expects that regulators will force Apple to breakup (Google is in bigger danger there).
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by _aavaa_ on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:35PM (#40682285)
The Core Technology Fee is so absurd. I couldn't help but notice that the Mac is conspicuously missing it. Perhaps the farce would have been too obvious to non-tech people if they had tried to impose it on the Mac.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by aaomidi on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:53PM (#40682464)
Next time someone says lawyers don’t do stupid shit.

This was lawyers doing stupid shit. FAFO.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by MBCook on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:13PM (#40682643)
Apple deserves money for every app on the phone (per Apple). Therefore the CTF makes perfect sense to them.

I think they’re really annoyed by the Facebooks and Spotify’s of the world that make a fortune from the iPhone and pay nothing.

“We have to open up” + “this is our chance to claw some back” = here’s the core technology fee.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by talldayo on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:54PM (#40683110)
> I think they’re really annoyed by the Facebooks and Spotify’s of the world that make a fortune from the iPhone and pay nothing.

And not the Mac?

It seems pretty obvious that it's not even an ideological thing, Apple is fine with some users not being forced through their ecosystem. They know that the iPhone specifically is most lucrative and are trying to arbitrarily distinguish it from their other products. It frankly doesn't matter how Apple feels about it at the end of the day, there's only compliance and noncompliance.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by MBCook on Friday June 14, 2024 @03:36PM (#40684221)
I think they see them as different for historical reasons. The Mac is a computer and the iPhone is an appliance, so the differences makes sense to them.

Also they tried to retrofit the App Store onto the Mac, it’s a joke compared to what they seem to have thought it would become. Yeah there is software, and I use it, but for many reasons it’s far less successful than it should have been if done well.

> It frankly doesn't matter how Apple feels about it at the end of the day, there's only compliance and noncompliance.

I agree. Some people see the CTF and can’t imagine why they’d create it. I’m just trying to explain what I (and others) have suggested was the reason. It makes sense and is just given their seeming point of view.

Problem for them is no one else, even huge fans, seems to agree.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by fennecbutt on Sunday June 16, 2024 @08:08PM (#40701183)
Wait so you really think that Ford should be viciously angry at somebody if they buy a non ford branded air freshener for their car? Because the air freshener company "makes a fortune from the car and pay nothing".
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by ocdtrekkie on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:30PM (#40682248)
The PWA block has more nuance than that. PWAs are locked to Safari's engine and Apple interpreted that as potentially against the law. And part of the problem is that some competing web engines allow extremely dangerous APIs in their web platform which Mozilla has considered harmful.

Which isn't to say that Apple isn't playing malicious compliance hard, the entire CTF thing is ridiculous and demonstrates how desperately they do abuse the claim of security when it is actually all about profit... but the PWA thing isn't really part of that.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by fallingsquirrel on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:51PM (#40682438)
Those so-called "dangerous" APIs are available in a normal browser visiting a normal website too. The APIs don't somehow become more dangerous if you let people put an icon for your site on the home screen.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by ocdtrekkie on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:18PM (#40682701)
This isn't true on iOS. Because allowing arbitrary websites access to system hardware is pretty dangerous and stupid, Safari gates some of the newer APIs they do support behind PWA installation.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by fallingsquirrel on Friday June 14, 2024 @03:40PM (#40684263)
Do you have a source for that?

At any rate, it's not clear to me that granting hardware permissions when you install a PWA is any better than letting the user choose what permissions to grant when you first visit a page. If that really is how it works, maybe alternate browsers will be able to improve over Safari's permission model too.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by ocdtrekkie on Friday June 14, 2024 @03:52PM (#40684395)
That request really kinda falls into "let me google that for you" territory, but, you know, here you go: https://webkit.org/blog/13878/web-push-for-web-apps-on-ios-a...

> it's not clear to me

So, you may not have watched normal users operate a web browser. But... they click on everything in their way. This is why, for example, most "malware" calls I get are just dozens upon dozens of Notifications API permissions being granted in Chrome to random websites. The best way to fix this is... just destroy the Notifications API as a thing, it's a terrible idea. But the next best way is to ensure access to it is limited to contexts where it's obvious a user is interested in persistent communication with a given site or app. Like installing it.

At any point where you thought "just asking the user when they first visit the page for permission" was an adequate concept, you were wrong. And most malicious websites abuse this wrongness ad-nauseum, to the point that browsers now include ways to block websites from making repetitive requests as a attempt to fix it without fixing it.

Firefox has a pretty good record, and I consider their standards positions (https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/) the gold standard. iOS/Safari moves a little more slowly, but generally aligns with good practice.

Google and Microsoft are the two companies everyone else (including Safari) is significantly improving over by actually paying attention to how real users interact with the Internet.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by fallingsquirrel on Friday June 14, 2024 @05:18PM (#40685235)
We're straying a bit from the original topic of direct access to hardware, but I'll humor you. Let's look at one of your users who does click yes to everything. In $YEAR, spam websites will say "enable push notifications to view this funny cat image. In $YEAR+1, spam websites will say "install our PWA to view this funny cat image" or "install our native app to view this funny cat image" and our user will still obey because the popup is in the way.

For the clueless user, nothing has changed other than which button they obediently push. For the savvy user, you've added an arbitrary special case and a hoop to jump through to get the functionality you wanted in the first place. Neither case is improved in the end.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by TheLoafOfBread on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:43PM (#40682966)
So basically Apple screw up writing their iOS kernel and Safari?
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by dangus on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:49PM (#40682406)
So why are PWAs and alternative browser engines okay on macOS but not iOS?

These security excuses are bullshit and that does include PWAs.

Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by ocdtrekkie on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:16PM (#40682680)
I mean, I think those alternative browser engines are dangerous on other OSes too. Both at work at home I enforce policy on computers which disables a lot of harmful web APIs. It is much harder to protect mobile devices with policy.
Re:Apple set to be first Big Tech group to face charges unde... by 1oooqooq on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:11PM (#40682625)
and yet, Microsoft still get purchased without licitation at the comission and all other branches. because of the same reason. lol