Re:Home-Cooked Software and Barefoot Developers
by eru on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @04:10AM
(#40655729)
> Yes, that's why everyone is writing Lisp, and not C++ or Java or Rust or JS.
> Oh wait, wrong reality.
You are a bit too cynical. The tools (compilers and interpreters and linters etc) that people are actually using have gotten a lot better. Both by moving to better languages, like more Rust and less C; or TypeScript instead of Javascript. But also from compilers for existing languages getting better, see especially the arms race between C compilers kicked off by Clang throwing down the gauntlet in front of GCC. They both got a lot better in the process.
(Common) Lisp was a good language for its time. But I wouldn't hold it up as a pinnacle of language evolution. (I like Lisps, and especially Racket. And I've programmed about half of my career in Haskell and OCaml. So you can rest assured about my obscure and elitist language cred. I even did a year of Erlang professionally.)
---
Btw, just to be clear: I actually agree with most of what you are writing! LLMs are already great for some tasks, and are still rapidly getting better.
You are also right that despite better languages being available, there are many reasons why people still have to use eg C++ here or there, and some people are even stuck on ancient versions of or compilers for C++, with even worse error messages. LLMs can help.
> Oh wait, wrong reality.
You are a bit too cynical. The tools (compilers and interpreters and linters etc) that people are actually using have gotten a lot better. Both by moving to better languages, like more Rust and less C; or TypeScript instead of Javascript. But also from compilers for existing languages getting better, see especially the arms race between C compilers kicked off by Clang throwing down the gauntlet in front of GCC. They both got a lot better in the process.
(Common) Lisp was a good language for its time. But I wouldn't hold it up as a pinnacle of language evolution. (I like Lisps, and especially Racket. And I've programmed about half of my career in Haskell and OCaml. So you can rest assured about my obscure and elitist language cred. I even did a year of Erlang professionally.)
---
Btw, just to be clear: I actually agree with most of what you are writing! LLMs are already great for some tasks, and are still rapidly getting better.
You are also right that despite better languages being available, there are many reasons why people still have to use eg C++ here or there, and some people are even stuck on ancient versions of or compilers for C++, with even worse error messages. LLMs can help.