News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:12AM (#40655087)
What if they give 1-2% and good market rate salary (~200k/y) to a founding engineer? Is that still a bad deal?
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by nevir on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:35AM (#40655223)
Having been in this exact position multiple times now (once quite successful, others not), you should probably consider it a wash.

Unless the company hits unicorn AND your shares become liquid (secondaries don't count—you generally won't be able to sell enough shares to make a meaningful dent), you'd make just as much or more at a FAANG firm with way less risk.

Of course, I say this while not at a FAANG firm, because I prefer startup type work.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:46AM (#40655304)
Yeah but I don't think it's fair to compare salaries to FAANG firms, as they are extreme outliers (and not really good companies).

So you would get paid like at another company but get equity on top and it's not a good deal? How comes?

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by jjav on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:54AM (#40655349)
> So you would get paid like at another company but get equity on top and it's not a good deal? How comes?

If it were truly market rate (total comp not just base salary) then sure, it's a good deal. How likely are you to find that in an early startup? It must be pretty close to zero percent chance. But if you find it, sure, it's good.

You'll still work harder and be more stressed but it'll be a different learning experience which is always nice.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by eschneider on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @01:03PM (#40660379)
A lot of it comes down to management/team quality. Do you want to spend an awful lot of time with these folks? Do you think you'll learn from each other? Do these folks seem to know what they're doing and are the building a product that interests you? If you can say yes to most (all?) of those questions, then all-in-all, it's probably a wash. If not, run.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by zaptheimpaler on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @03:26AM (#40655501)
Depends on the options available to the candidate. Typically someone joining a startup very early probably has the skill to get FAANG salaries with less stress and more free time. There are also hundreds or thousands of mid size companies that pay very well nowadays, its not just FAANG.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @04:05AM (#40655698)
Yeah but smaller startups might be more open to non-US applicants, FAANG and other more established companies don't seem to be interested in hiring abroad.

That's what makes the early startup scene the only thing available for some.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by cherryteastain on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @06:50AM (#40656611)
How come? Most large companies have big legal/HR departments that are very efficient at the whole visa application process. A small company won't have that expertise/staff. I mostly see startups being more concerned about the visa status of applicants.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @09:46AM (#40658106)
Remote + non-US is not as welcoming, so the hurdles are way higher as it's not fitting the usual way. While startups have no prior experience anyway, so it's easier to convince 1-2 people instead of changing a whole system (I believe).
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by lumost on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @03:33AM (#40655539)
Most early stage companies turn out to be poor companies for employees. Long hours, toxic leadership, unclear roadmaps etc. Working at a small firm doesn't guarantee high quality.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by extr on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:50AM (#40655329)
I was recently faced with this exact offer at seed stage vs a series B with a similar salary. YMMV but what I found when I ran the numbers is the series B offer had a lottery ticket with a similar risk/reward profile to the seed stage. Of course I got less total equity, but it was way more likely to ever actually materialize. Plus being employee 80 at a Series B is a lot easier.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by halgir on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:30AM (#40655190)
If the salary is market rate for that person, I suppose it's by definition a fair deal. I've seen startups hire "founding xyz" two years after they started. Looks to be a vanity title in many cases.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by dchftcs on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:44AM (#40655283)
Total comp needs to be market rate, not just salary. And non-preferred shares should be valued lower than preferred stock. Lumping non-preferred shares with prefereed shares is one of the bigger lies startups tell employees.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by jonathankoren on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:32AM (#40655203)
Yes. Because you’re literally the same as the founder, but getting waaaay less equity.

First employee is always a sucker

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:55AM (#40655358)
But you're getting paid a good salary for many while they probably might not. Also I'd be sleeping well at night as I can jump ship the second I'm not happy, my reputation won't be tarnished by that.

So I am not sure it's that easy.

Of course, the idea is to keep the same work/life balance one would have at a more established company.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by jonathankoren on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:48AM (#40658804)
It is that easy. Employee 1 is getting paid below market. That’s why they offer 0.9% equity. Meanwhile, the founders are also getting paid. No one is working for free. One of the first things VCs tell you is to make yourself comfortable so you can concentrate on the company. That’s literally one of the reasons why VCs tell founders to sell equity early, to make up for lost income, while Employees 1+ has to ride the rocket into the ground.

It’s Baby’s First Labor Exploitation.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by petesergeant on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:36AM (#40655233)
Market salary with stock upside plus the chance to level up a job title has potential to be a great deal
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:48AM (#40655318)
Yeah, that's my thought too. Many companies give ~$200/y for way less upward mobility, impact and voice, and without any equity.

Maybe you'd lose our on some tiny perk/benefit but that's not always the case.

So I'm not seeing what's wrong with this deal with the only caveat that the engineer has the experience not to overwork/burn out.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by lumost on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @03:37AM (#40655561)
It depends on the role and company, if you want to get paid 200k per year for the opportunity to do X - then sure. In practice, you may end up doing basic work at a lower quality than a large firm. Such experience doesn't translate the up-leveled title to a more standard position.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by geepeeyoudata on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @09:04AM (#40657675)
>> So I'm not seeing what's wrong with this deal with the only caveat that the engineer has the experience not to overwork/burn out.

The startup can go bankrupt any moment, thats a big deal. You get crappy perks, often poor benefits.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by cruffle_duffle on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @03:07PM (#40661751)
And at a large corp you can get laid off just as easily. Any business can toss you out at a moments notice. It's not unique to startups.

At least with a startup you are going into it knowing that you have a higher probability of thing going south financially. With a big company, you might not get any warning at all.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by closeparen on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @01:20PM (#40660610)
Leveling up seems like a good reason for someone who’s stagnating at a bigger company. My experience is startup people want to recruit their most respected former colleagues, who by virtue of being respected are also getting promoted in place.

Titles obviously don’t transfer back to big companies, we had plenty of ex-cofounders and CTOs hired into the same junior roles as anyone else who could LeetCode.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by geepeeyoudata on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @09:02AM (#40657655)
>> What if they give 1-2% and good market rate salary (~200k/y) to a founding engineer? Is that still a bad deal?

OR....you could just become a founding engineer by actually founding and keep 90% of the equity. You can get that salary with an equity raise, its worth not being the low-person on the totem pole.

Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by xandrius on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @09:48AM (#40658125)
That's forgetting what a founder actually has to do and worry about.
Re:Silicon Valley's best kept secret: Founder liquidity by blitzar on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @10:49AM (#40658817)
Advertise for a founding CEO and offer them 1-2%.