News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by crazygringo on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:08PM (#40651502)
Why does it scare you? Why do you think it's dangerous and bad?

It's a well-established, economically rational business model to subsidize prices in order to gain market share.

Uber has been very successful at it. Amazon has had great success. It's standard.

Investors know what they're doing and know that some companies won't be able to sustain it and will go out of business. It's a calculated, known risk.

And users don't really need to be concerned. Just enjoy the low prices while they last. If the service you use goes out of business, it's pretty easy to switch to another.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:11PM (#40651545)
> Why does it scare you? Why do you think it's dangerous and bad?

> It's a well-established, economically rational business model to subsidize prices in order to gain market share.

Because once they have the market share, they raise prices and/or make the product worse in order to get their money back.

> And users don't really need to be concerned. Just enjoy the low prices. If the service you use goes out of business, it's pretty easy to switch to another.

Well that's the question, isn't it? If the market stays healthy and they don't take the oxygen out of the room and kill the competition and switching costs stay low, then yes by all means enjoy the free ride but plan for its end. But... do plan for it.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by eitally on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:37PM (#40651855)
I think the bigger risk is that they don't get the market share and then they're tempted to make unethical decisions to keep afloat as their unbalanced inputs & outputs start to drive increasing pressure from their investors.
Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by worldsayshi on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:23PM (#40651678)
>they raise prices and/or make the product worse in order to get their money back

They should only be able to do that if they have a considerable moat though?

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by IanCal on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:12PM (#40651553)
> It's a well-established, economically rational business model to subsidize prices in order to gain market share.

Right but it means you can't depend on that price remaining low. If it's below cost, the price must rise. That may be important for anyone building businesses on top.

> it's pretty easy to switch to another.

Well that assumes the others have true lower prices.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by crazygringo on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:22PM (#40651657)
> the price must rise. That may be important for anyone building businesses on top.

Well yes but every business owner knows that, or should know that. That's a known business risk. We're all adults here.

If your business fails because you naively assumed that prices you rely on will never go up, then that's on you.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by IanCal on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:54PM (#40652045)
> Well yes but every business owner knows that, or should know that.

Know that they are buying services below cost? I don't think so.

It's a reasonable bet that compute costs generally trend downwards, and in a competitive market where the key thing you're paying for is compute that should also trend downwards.

That's different to finding out that everyone's been selling things way under the true cost.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by crazygringo on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @06:07PM (#40652171)
> Know that they are buying services below cost? I don't think so.

To the contrary, of course you should know.

If you know anything about tech businesses, you know that startups being funded by massive amounts of VC keep prices artificially low initially, and that they then rise.

This is tech startup 101 stuff.

It's fine if you're not aware of this as an engineer. But if you're building a business and therefore have a business model where you've identified known risks, there's no excuse for you not to be aware of it.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by IanCal on Wednesday June 12, 2024 @02:08AM (#40655058)
I know that it happens, but that's different from knowing of it's happening here or not, and by how much.

Is openai selling below cost? Is the cost on azure lower than the true cost? ChatGPT free is obviously run subsidized but are the apis?

Can you tell me the actual cost to Microsoft of a gpt4 API call?

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by Eisenstein on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:30PM (#40651756)
Every business owner does not know what prices for other companies actually are -- they assume that they are being charged a price which has been determined by the market and is worthwhile to the seller to cover costs and profit.

By taking outside money and subsidizing certain market players so that they can sell their goods at below market value (because that is what is happening) you are undermining the market and punishing players who are acting rationally.

This would be absolutely no different than taking tax money and subsidizing certain companies over others to destroy competition and then claiming that it was a market decision.

'We are all adults here' is not a magical phrase that makes cheating OK.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by simonw on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:18PM (#40651610)
Because they are platform companies.

If I launch a business that makes sense given the current pricing of LLMs, and the price then goes up by a factor of ten, my own unit economics may not make sense any more.

There's an Uber comparison here: back when Uber was cheap, some people made life decisions about where they lived and worked that were predicated on being able to afford a commute in an Uber (since public transport doesn't serve a lot of places, at least in the US).

This hurt a lot when the prices went up a few years later!

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by 0xcde4c3db on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:39PM (#40651879)
> If the service you use goes out of business, it's pretty easy to switch to another.

I'm not sure how well that works if vendors differentiate themselves through proprietary models and backend integrations. As far as I know, Mistral only releases weights for some of its models, with others being proprietary.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by observationist on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:14PM (#40651570)
Investors don't know what they're doing. This is laughably apparent. They're monkeys throwing bananas at dart boards. There's that whole negative externality thing. There aren't alternatives to FAANG because they've viciously used their VC money to drive out competition, used their lawyers to litigate competition into extinction, and every other tool at their disposal to press an advantage in consumer exposure. This isn't a fair market where the best product wins; it's a game of "who's got the most money."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification

This is how the world gets shittier. It's a whole thing. It's a large part of why things are as bad as they are.

But hey, yeah, don't worry about it, they obviously know what they're doing.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by __loam on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:23PM (#40651676)
Using capital to subsidize costs and sell your product for less than it's worth actually seems like a huge market failure to me, and is the consequence of huge concentrations of capital in the hands of a small and shrinking group of people. The only people who can afford to compete are the already wealthy. It stifles competition.

As a consumer it should definitely concern you if you're using poorly financed or unsustainable products. Maybe it's great now but I would rather have a slightly more expensive product that is more stable than one that suddenly had to make the experience a lot worse because they burned a lot of cash and had a down round.

Re:Mistral AI raises $640M at $6B valuation by LordDragonfang on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:25PM (#40651696)
>It's a well-established, economically rational business model to subsidize prices in order to gain market share.

Economically rational for the business owner, maybe, but it inevitably results in eventual enshittification for the consumer. (And Uber isn't a great example of this; its share price has only recently surpassed what it was at IPO 4 years ago, and many companies don't even do that well)