News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:17AM (#40644151)
Luckily, _most_ people don't buy overpriced and closed Apple devices.
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by majke on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @05:27AM (#40644215)
> In the US, iPhone has a 58.81% market share

There are demographics where Apple has dominance.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by MissTake on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @06:00AM (#40644422)
In the desktop world people tend to buy cheaper, yet equally as closed Windows machines.
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by tsimionescu on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @06:12AM (#40644477)
In what ways are desktop Windows boxes as closed as Apple? I would say there are many many things to fault Microsoft for, but closing down the OS has never been one of them (though that is gradually changing outside the EU, to be fair).
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by esskay on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @06:33AM (#40644609)
Counter point - in what ways is macOS 'closed' and Windows not? And I am specifically talking about macOS, not iOS.
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by Zach_the_Lizard on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @07:57AM (#40645179)
MacOS is only licensed for use in Apple branded hardware, as I understand it. Even running it in a VM could be problematic if that host isn't running MacOS.
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by MissTake on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @08:44AM (#40645572)
True. However I can (and have multiple times) migrate from machine to machine without needing to reinstall everything.

My work MacBook was pulled from an original Air from something like 2015, to a 2017 Pro and currently my 2019 Pro.

So I’ve got apps installed on my Mac that have been installed damn near 10 years ago.

Ditto my home 2015 Pro was later on migrated to a M1 Air. Hell, I’ve still some 32 Bit Steam games that still somehow run on my Air (least Steam tells me they’re 32 bit).

We could play this game ad-infinitum, each finding a level of supposed “openness” but the basic facts are that neither Windows, nor MacOS are truly open.

If you want open, then Linux is always going to be in the answer somewhere. Not MS Windows. And not Apple MacOS.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by esskay on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @09:09AM (#40645799)
So your issue isnt the openness in terms of being limited on what you can do on it, and more that you want it to be bloated with drivers for millions of various pieces of hardware like Windows, got it.
Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by talldayo on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @03:16PM (#40650273)
> and more that you want it to be bloated with drivers for millions of various pieces of hardware like Windows, got it.

MacOS is bloated anyways; they might as well use that bloat for something important like backwards-compatibility and not zombie-code left over from the PowerPC era. That's just an objective failure, on Apple's behalf; they break software support more often than Microsoft and even Linux at this point. A professional OS really has no excuse to break someone's software and leave it broken. Even Microsoft gets that.

So... yeah, you know what? I do want it to be bloated with drivers, because whatever they're stuffing it with right now clearly isn't working. I don't trust Apple to write or maintain a long-lived successor, I demand third-party alternatives I can maintain myself. Give me more options for writing and delivering software, or else I am going to continue ignoring MacOS as a build target for the foreseeable future.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by MissTake on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @07:36AM (#40645032)
When using the terms “open” and “closed” with operating systems, one is traditionally talking open the source code.

As such both Windows and MacOS are closed source.

As for “opening up the OS” both are pretty gosh darned flexible and extensible wrt other features.

However being based upon a BSD core, MacOS has had access to the Unix command line natively since forever. For Windows one used to have to rely on CgyWin before the virtualized WSL platform came to be.

Whilst MacOS has the somewhat opaque ~/Library for storing user settings and data, it pales into comparison to the massively Opaque Windows Registry.

I’ve had had very few issues fixing app install issues with my Mac - with Windows I’ve had more than one occasion where I’ve had to do a complete reinstall of the OS due to the Registry being totally hosed to the point I couldn’t reinstall apps again.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by tim333 on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @08:23AM (#40645388)
You said "equally as closed Windows machines."

In terms of the machine Windows is way more open in that you can use what hardware you want. But yeah the software is closed source.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by MissTake on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @11:06AM (#40647054)
TBH, the parent also stated “but closing down the OS…”

So waters were indeed muddied.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by nicce on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @10:23AM (#40646502)
I think the keynote here is the closed/open hardware.

You can run Windows almost on any hardware. So it is much more open in general.

You can equally run almost any imaginable software on both operating systems (if we ignore the performance), but you have extreme difficulties to run macOS on most hardware.

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by tsimionescu on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @12:43PM (#40648449)
I don't think when someone is talking about a "closed device" they usually mean "closed source". I at least took it to refer to whether you can run whatever software you want on that device+OS, and how easy it is to do so.

I think Windows is up there with the open source OSs (Linux, BSDs, etc) on regular PCs are at the same end of "run anything you want from wherever you want it", iOS devices are at the other extreme of "only run things approved by Apple", Android devices are pretty closer to iOS because they make you jump through hoops and potentially lose access to various functionalities to install certain things or gain root access. Modern macOS, as far as I understand, is somewhere in the middle: you have to jump through quite a few hoops to install certain kinds of software, and a few aren't permitted at all I think (unsigned kernel modules?).

Re:Apple is launching its own password manager app by nicce on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @08:53AM (#40645663)
Many could disagree about the pricing of MacBooks, for example.

M Pro series are probably the best laptops on the market, and if people keep buying them, is the price too much?

MacBook Air is actually quite well priced for what you get.