Re:Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac
by Hizonner on Monday June 10, 2024 @04:29PM
(#40638577)
> I can't really imagine how it would be implemented.
People do stuff that they claim implements it using trusted, "tamperproof" hardware.
What they're ignoring is that not all of the assurance is "cryptographic". Some of it comes from trusting that hardware. It's particularly annoying for that to get glossed over by a company that proposes to make the hardware.
You can also do it on a small scale using what the crypto types call "secure multiparty computation", but that has enormous performance limitations that would make it useless for any meaningful machine learning.
Re:Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac
by warkdarrior on Monday June 10, 2024 @04:56PM
(#40638983)
There is no known solution to remote software attestation that does not depend on trusted hardware.
Re:Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac
by Hizonner on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:00PM
(#40639033)
That's correct. But Apple is not making that clear, and is therefore misrepresenting what assurance can be offered.
Re:Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac
by ducadveritatem on Tuesday June 11, 2024 @06:12PM
(#40652225)
The details of their approach: https://security.apple.com/blog/private-cloud-compute/
Technically, the sentence could be read that experts inspect the code, and the client uses TLS and CA's to ensure it's only talking to those Apple servers. But that's pretty much the status quo and uninteresting.
It sounds like they're trying to say that somehow iPhone ensures that it's only talking to a server that's running audited code? That would be absolutely incredible (for more things than just running LLMs), but I can't really imagine how it would be implemented.