News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ken Burns, Faux "Storyteller" by tadfisher on Sunday June 09, 2024 @10:53PM (#40629680)
You're making the same mistake as the article, which is assuming that Ken Burns gives a shit about politics. He will give a "facts-on-the-ground" overview of events at the time, but his films famously have a myopic focus on individuals, their actions and written experiences, sometimes to a fault.

Just like he doesn't really care to put Elliot Ness on an even larger pedestal than the one upon which he currently sits, he doesn't care to delve into the post-war geopolitical situation in SE Asia, because no one wrote about it at the time and it did not matter to front-line soldiers, news reporters, or the American public.

If you want a historiographical survey, read Wikipedia. That's just not the point of a Burns film, and that's okay that you and the author find faults in what he omits.

Re:Ken Burns, Faux "Storyteller" by AlbertCory on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:44PM (#40629939)
several errors in here:

He certainly does care about politics. Just watch his interviews on YouTube, where he describes himself as a "yellow dog Democrat."

> put Elliot Ness on an even larger pedestal than the one upon which he currently sits

That's not at all what I said about Ness. It was that he did play an important role and that was recognized even at the time. The fact that Hollywood made him into a mythic hero after he was dead doesn't mean he was really nothing at all.