The actual state that is described is determined by the chemical concentrations of various kinds of ions and molecules along and across the body of an animal.
The distribution of electric potential that appears as a consequence of the chemical concentration variations, due to the fact that the atomic ions and also many of the molecules involved are electrically charged, is just a coupling mechanism between those chemical concentrations, so that when one of them is changed that tends to also change the concentrations of other atomic or molecular ions.
The same "bioelectric" state (i.e. electric potential distribution) could appear as a consequence of distinct distributions of the ions and most certainly those seemingly identical "bioelectric" states would behave quite differently.
This is similar with what happens in semiconductors, whose behavior cannot be simulated based on just the distribution of electric charge, but one must account separately the concentrations of all kinds of charge carriers, e.g. electrons, holes, fixed crystal defects etc.
The planaria has evolved a mechanism by which its body plan can be recapitulated from the distribution of electric potential.
When it gets cut in half, the electric potential changes, but this is still enough information for the vivisected halves to redifferentiate. The trade off is, of course, there is only so much information in an electric potential with regard to the patterning of a complex organism, so its hard to imagine a cheetah or a pig pulling off this same kind of trick.
The idea of some subdivision of an animal having its own prerogatives is not some sort of new idea. It goes all the way back to Richard Dawkin's 1970s book "The Selfish Gene" which lays out exactly where the "incentives" are for cells, genes/cistrons, cancer, transposons, etc...
Just because there's some example now of something vaguely reminiscent of semiconductors (which is cool for sure!) does not mean we're gonna start rethinking everything in biology.
None of the linked articles contains any evidence about some direct influence of the electric potential, but only about the influence on differentiation of the variable concentration of ions.
They did not manipulate the planaria with electrodes, but with a drug that has manipulated the concentration of ions, by blocking some of the paths through which some ions are transported through membranes.
All the talk about "bioelectricity" appears superfluous. The variable electric potential is just a side effect of the variable ion concentrations, which complicates their behavior by introducing a coupling between the movements of different kinds of ions.
Yeah, sure... but both are totally relevant?
Given the distribution in space of the electric potential, you cannot compute the entire state, which includes the distributions in space of many kinds of ions, simply because there are many kinds of ions. Only when there had been a single kind of ions, it would have been possible to describe the state using the electric potential.
All the ions move continuously through very complex circuits comprising a network of pores through the cellular membranes. Through some of the pores the movement is "passive" i.e. for each kind of ion that may pass through a given kind of pore the ionic current is determined by both the local gradient of the concentration of that kind of ion and the local gradient of the electric potential. This is the only place where the electric potential matters. Through other kinds of pores, the ion transport is "active", i.e. the so-called ionic pumps move certain kinds of ions regardless of the gradients of the ionic concentrations and of the electric potential (within certain limits, too large gradients can block an ionic pump).
If you want to simulate the ionic current network of an entire organism, you must compute the electric potential inside the simulation. When you observe a living organism, measuring the electric potential is much easier than measuring directly any kind of ion concentration and in many cases one can estimate the ionic concentrations of interest from the measured electric potential and from additional information.
While accounting for the electric interactions inside an organism is essential, talking about a "bioelectric" state of an organism that would determine its development is just meaningless pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo. "Bioelectricity" is an appropriate term when discussing the electric sense organs or the electric weapons of various animals, where the side-effect of the generation of electric potential differences by differences in ion concentrations is exploited in such a way that the effect is cumulative over large ensembles of cells.
I have tried to further this understanding with LLMs but am ofcourse not sure if what they are saying is correct (given the understudied and sparse nature of this research).
If you had a moment to help me understand what exactly these voltage gradients are, how they differ from action potentials, and to tie these to the processes at the cellular level to the larger system, I would be so grateful (for example, is SSH used in limb regeneratio nas well as pattern formation? How? Is it dormant in normal limbs? Which cells, in the limb or in the brain? Which research articles found this? I am fascinated!).
In the meantime, here is what Claude told me. I am not sure if it is accurate, I get a sense of "sweeping under the rug":
"Specific ion channels and gradients:
During limb regeneration in amphibians like salamanders, one of the key ion channels involved is the V-gated proton channel (Hv1). The wound epidermis cells at the amputation site become depolarized due to the influx of protons (H+) through the Hv1 channels, creating a localized region of elevated intracellular pH. This pH gradient, or proton gradient, is believed to be a crucial signal that initiates and guides the regenerative process. Other ion gradients, such as calcium (Ca2+) and sodium (Na+), have also been implicated in regulating various stages of limb regeneration, but the proton gradient is particularly well-studied.
Reaching and influencing cells:
The voltage gradients or ion gradients can propagate through tissues and reach distant cells due to a phenomenon called bioelectric signal propagation. Cells are electrically coupled through gap junctions, which allow for the passive spread of ions and small molecules between cells. This electrical coupling enables the voltage or ion gradients to be transmitted from the source cells (e.g., wound epidermis) to the target cells (e.g., blastema) over long distances. The gradients can influence gene expression, cell proliferation, and cell migration in the target cells, guiding the regenerative process.
Pattern effects and limb regeneration processes:
The specific patterns of voltage or ion gradients are crucial for determining the outcomes of regeneration, such as the completeness and proper patterning of the regenerated limb. For example, manipulating the proton gradient can lead to the formation of supernumerary (extra) limbs or alteration of the limb pattern. The voltage gradients are involved in various stages of limb regeneration, including wound healing, blastema formation, patterning, and differentiation of cells into specific tissue types (e.g., bone, muscle, nerves).
Gradient vs. specific voltage measurement:
The term "voltage gradient" or "bioelectric field" refers to a spatial pattern of voltage differences, rather than a singular voltage measurement at a specific point. It's similar to a topographic map, where the voltage (or ion concentration) varies across different regions, creating a gradient or slope. In contrast, an action potential or membrane potential refers to a specific voltage difference across the cell membrane at a given point in time. The voltage gradient is a long-range signal that provides positional information and guides cellular behaviors during regeneration, while action potentials are localized electrical signals involved in neuronal communication and muscle contraction.
The voltage gradient, or bioelectric field, is a spatially distributed pattern of voltage differences that serves as a long-range instructive signal for coordinating cellular activities during regeneration. It is distinct from a singular voltage measurement or an action potential, as it represents a gradient or slope of voltage across different regions, providing positional cues and guiding the regenerative process."
Per what Claude is say, yes, generally true-ish.
Honestly, if you want to dive in more, you'll need to read https://www.amazon.co.uk/Principles-Development-Lewis-Wolper... . Textbooks tend to be gold standards still. You can also look up review articles for the specific thing you want to know more about. Simple googling at google scholar should get you to a good review article in <15 minutes.
I want to caution that in general, DevBio is still an active field. Things are moving and grooving, so you'll need to check back in about every 5 years or so.
In general, DevBio works off of a gradient of some sort (we think). A new daughter cell looks at the gradients that she is in, then uses the genome to figure out what to do next. What to do next and the gradient are both hyper complicated. Think, like, 50+ co-interacting variables for gradient, with functional race conditions then set on the genome. It's rough for us humans to figure it all out, we largely think we haven't a real clue yet.
When we say voltage gradient, think the traditional ions and the like. But also think of the voltage gradient that a protein can have too, with binding pockets and stuff. Think voltage gradients that are held in place by lipid rafts on the membrane too. Think also the osmotic potential that ion concentration will have, not just the raw total voltage of a voltmeter. There are a lot of components, and therefore gradients, that make up the voltage potential.
Also, yes, you're right to think of the action potential. That's a voltage gradient across a membrane. In DevBio though, it's not just the voltage gradient across the membrane, but along the cells and among them too. The pancreas has a lot of this kind of stuff happening, from what I remember of my MolBio classes.
Let me know what other question you have and I'll try to get to them today.
It seems that both Claude and you use "voltage gradient" and "ion gradient" interchangeably, which may be not technically correct enough. In electrical engineering voltage = potential = charge difference btw 2 points = the driving force that drives a current to "flow" from a point of bigger potential to a lesser one (typically). Thus it is voltage (or a field) that will drive an ion or any charge gradient.
Yes, ions and charges will flow in Bio too, but that flow is generally restricted and used somehow. Nature is always finding a way to take a toll. Cells will also set up a voltage difference to accomplish things too, all on their own.
Like, cells are quite happy to make massive charge differences (for their size) and then use that to do some little thing. Generally, they use ATP to skit around those pesky little entropy issues to act like Maxwell's Demon.
Like, they are using ion flow/current and deciding how that will benefit them. They gate it, on and off, to induce all kinds of signaling and meiosis and energy transferring.
So, in Bio, a voltage/ion gradient isn't really thought of as the same way in EE. Like, we care about 10 or so K+ ions, that little of a difference can do all sorts of things for a cell. ANd the voltage potentials can be titanic, because the distance are so small. That Van Der Wals force man, you don't think it do, but it do.
One important and subtle thing I learned going from my engineering/physics background and into bio is not assume that cells are little micro machines. They are in fact alive. They study you back, in their own limited ways. They try very hard to stay alive too. So, when bio people talk about cells doing things, we really do mean that they have agency.
But I was curious, what do you think about the ways by which ligands find their receptors inside or outside cells in a dense bioelectrical and biochemical environment (as described here [0]). When I asked on stackexchange, they gave me a link about gradients and concentrations, but my question was about the very beginning of ligand's effect when it needs to find and activate at least one receptor. And no receptors seem to be able to "sense" a piece of space with a ligand's concentration, as they need direct binding of a ligand, but before this how does a ligand find a way to the receptor?
This may differ whether its a small or large molecule ligand, but my ligands of interest are ions (Ca/Mg, Na, K ,Cl; Li), peptides, anticancer drugs with metallocomplexes, ion channel drugs and similar drugs.
Stochasticly. It's all random, as far as we can tell.
The things that make it all work, though, are the large amounts of receptors and binding thingys, the very small spaces, and the temperature. The cell is really kinda jam packed with stuff. But, since we're at ~97F or so, things bounce around a lot. The key here is the mean free path. Depending on the thing you're looking at, the mean free path of that thing is generally sufficient to get the pieces together to party. If not, then you start getting into really complex and hyper specific transport mechanisms. Each of those is going to be it's own little research world and will have little broad applications.
With large molecule drugs, you're likely using some clever transport mechanism with cleavages and digestion steps along the way. These are really some marvels of bioengineering.
With ions, you're just doing simple diffusion modeling, and the body very tightly regulates these ion concentrations
With peptides and these 'medium' sized things, you're looking a combination of diffusion and some hacking of the cell's machinery.
Again, I want to stress something here. We're still on the cusp of really understanding biology as a species. This stuff isn't EE. We're trying to unravel ~4 billion years of random-ass evolution, it's going to take a few thousand years for us to do that. Neither you nor I will see biology as a mature science.
Stochasticity sounds like there has been performed some theoretical modelling to infer this. But does it imply that there would be some tiny % of any ligand molecules - endogenous or exogenous - which would just by chance get "an empty run" and didn't bind to their receptors (though structurally they're fine ligands with high affinity) and would be removed via waste removal systems? Is there any experimental evidence for this, like some study using radiolabelled high affinity ligand molecules to see what % of them gets into "an empty run"?
The mean free path seems sort of sensible in the extracellular space, though it still seems that the variables affecting mean free path (large amounts of receptors and binding thingys, the very small spaces, and the temperature) may be not enough. But wouldn't mean free path be near zero inside cells, where every nanometer should be occupied by some other biochemical pathway/reaction or bioelectric activity?
>>Neither you nor I will see biology as a mature science.
I personally wouldn't care a lot about proving anything to anybody in some absolute sense, but first of all to prove instrumentally and make stuff work for myself at least. I think that any biology student with the descent understanding should have some mini lab for personalized medicine (as e.g. Sinclair mentioned that his recent research on using 6 chemical compounds for OSK epigenetic reprogramming (rather than bulky viral vectors) can be done by any biology student).
The mean free path is pretty much 0 all over, so to speak. I was just trying to tie it back into more EE concepts for you. The idea is that things are just randomly moving about, with a 'free' mean free path, until they aren't, and that stoppage costs energy. At body temperatures, it doesn't take much to knock binding ligands out of a cleft. So the stiffer the bind, the harder to disassociate, and the harder to get it to unbind at the end. Nature kinda figures this all out on her own, and the optimal energies are found out via evolution. It's all a 'good enough' system.
So, the trick with bio is that it's a lot like how Clausewitz thinks of war: War is easy, it's just that all the easy stuff is really hard. In that, it's conceptually easy to do bio. It's just that it's really hard to implement anything. Feynman talked a bit about it in one of his lectures. In that, getting a rat to randomly go into a room and then discover that there is cheese in it will take a tremendous amount of prep and careful cleaning and the like. Rats have really really good noses. It's so easy to fool yourself in bio, because the systems are just so complicated. And, for me, that's been true up and down the size scale, from single cells to whole animals. The systems are just so complex, you really only get to ask simple questions and then hope you controlled the experiment correctly.
Evolution also "tries" to save energy anywhere possible, so spending energy on the synthesis of endogenous ligands, which eventually will be discarded, seems a bit redundant. There is also a theorem in evolutionary game theory, that probability that natural selection will allow an organism to see reality as it is (=the truth) is exactly zero, as it's enough to make it just "good enough". I was arguing about that with Gemini, and it agreed with me. My point is that "evolution" is just a tool (like ChatGPT) with it's own instrumentally limited pool of empirical data (80% of which was also obtained from macroscopic enough observations rather than reverse engineering or experimentation) to build upon.
I actually want to apply one EE concept, which has some experimental basis. The reason why I am digging this, is that I am searching for some possible explanations of a couple of dozens of experimental studies in bioelectrics/magnetics I found. (though won't discuss in depth on a public forum)
The stochastic nature of the cell, as far as I know, exists pretty much the same in and out. With more transport mechanims occurring inside to make sure things get to where they need to be.
It's not that the discarded ligands (for example) are really 'discarded'. There are a few instances I know of that use the 'waste' as a product unto themselves. The ToR network comes to mind here. Still, trying to really figure out what the 'intention' was all those billions of years ago is hard, and networks and feedback loops have been built up over the eons. Like, yeah, nothing is really wasted in a cell, per se. But it can seem that way in the chain that you're looking at.
I'd love to know more about the magnetic side of things here. Is it memristors as synapses? Because that is a criminally misunderstood area of neuroscience.
Gemini: ``` Yes, the intracellular space is denser than the extracellular space:
Here's why:
Packing: Cells are packed with molecules like proteins, carbohydrates, and nucleic acids. These molecules take up a significant amount of space within the cell, leaving little room for just water.
Solutes: The intracellular space contains a higher concentration of dissolved molecules (solutes) compared to the extracellular space. This contributes to a higher density.
Extracellular Matrix: The extracellular space, on the other hand, contains a looser network of connective tissues and fluids like interstitial fluid. This allows for more space between molecules, resulting in a lower density.
```>>Still, trying to really figure out what the 'intention' was all those billions of years ago is hard
With this logic you'll need another billion of years to randomly figure it out. I'd rather focus on how/efficiently does such position contribute to a specific current experimental methodology or results.
Yeah, sure cell densities vary (fat vs muscle) but pretty much any cell sample you're going to gather is going to be near the same density as the surrounding water environment. Again, there is a lot of variation though. The end result is that the density of a cell is near enough the density of water, it's not 100x more dense. I mean, iron is only ~8x more dense than water.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Metabolic_Metro_Map.svg
I did a career change from particle physics to bioengineering and neuroscience ( and now AI/ML for EE applications with bioreactors, but that's another story).
There's not a lot of recent texts really. US based academia in the last few years has been really bad, as the replication crisis turned into a dry cough; I.E. make up data all you want, no one will care.
So, I'd go back to the classics like Kandel ( https://www.amazon.com/Principles-Neural-Science-Fifth-Kande...) for the neuro side. Bioengineering really doesn't have any canonical texts yet as the field is do disparate and new still. For the only bio side, really any used text book will do, as the basics are really wide spread at this point. You can dig into good text books here: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/xg3hXCYQPJkwHyik2/the-best-t...
I'd really recommend reading Darwin though. Going way back to the literal foundation really helps set the stage, mentally, and bring you back to what is really going on with relation to the wider human condition.
Just about any review article more than 10 years old is also going to be pretty good. I'd stay way from review articles less than 5 years old though, as things change and retractions come out.
I'll warn you though, the concepts and mental models that you've built up on the Engineering side are not really going to help you with the bio side. Yes, the study habits will help. But bio is really really complicated. You can't abstract the cow into a meter sphere of water. In bio, you really do care about that cell on the medial side of the fourth mesenchymal layer of the second stomach of the cow. You are going to have to get comfortable memorizing pathways and strange names for a few years before all the pieces will even start fitting together. Again, bio is something that's been surviving, ripping, and gouging, for ~4 billion years. She don't have time to stop and let us know what is up.
Eric Davidson did a bunch of pioneering work meticulously "debugging" this spatiotemporal genomic logic in the sea urchin. Pretty amazing. Eukaryotes like us have control elements directly upstream of our genes (trans-acting aka close acting) and also 100,000's of base pairs distant (cis-acting). The region of DNA directly preceding the beginning of an open reading frame at the start of a gene usually has a sequence of DNA motifs that bind proteins that can increase or decrease expression of the gene. Davidson and others showed that the transcription factor proteins that bind to these control motifs actually have additional other proteins that bind to them, in literally a layer on top, and that the sequences of proteins in this second layer recruit a tertiary layer of proteins that conditionally cause more or less gene expression, depending on their identities. You could say the secondary and tertiary layers are a form of "abstraction" in a literal sense, since they encode a hierarchy of logical operations.
Here's an open-access overview of Davidson's work which incidentally illuminates a lot of these concepts in more detail for a lay audience: "ERIC DAVIDSON: STEPS TO A GENE REGULATORY NETWORK FOR DEVELOPMENT" by Ellen Rothenberg, 2016; doi: 10.1016/j.ydbio.2016.01.020 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4828313/
to see the decoded logic in pseudocode and with a diagram, see "cis-Regulatory control circuits in development", Howard and Davidson, 2004, Developmental Biology, vol 271, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ydbio.2004.03.031 (open access)
There's the chemical gradient based on WNT signaling in fruitfly development, the SHH (sonic hedgehog) chemical gradient in limb pattern formation and body planning asymmetry. There's even auxin signaling in plant development.
Heck, one of Alan Turing's (yes, THAT Turing) most famous papers from the 50s described reaction-diffusion mechanisms for pattern formation.
Basically for evolution to invent some kind of reproducible pattern of something, you need to start with a gradient of something and tie that to gene transcription.
In the fruit fly example it's a chemical trigger that reaches the nucleus via wnt signaling. In the flatworm example, it's a membrane polarization gradient that drives the gradient rather than a chemical one.
I'd imagine the patterns you can create from electrical depolarization are simpler than the ones you can get from chemicals interacting as you lose many of the interesting interactions you get from reaction-diffusion