News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mungoman2 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:04AM (#40623302)
Hm I don't follow. Could you please define "expected value in money terms" vs "expected value in utility of money terms"
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by graemep on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:27AM (#40623418)
Utility is quite a complex and badly defined concept - its also central to economics. The idea is that the value to you of an extra amount of money goes down as you have more. i.e. getting £10k could be life changing for a poor person, unnoticeable to a rich one.

https://moneyterms.co.uk/utility/

The expected value is the amount multiplied by the chance of getting it. SO if you have a 50% chance of getting £1,000 the expected value is £500.

That GP comment is saying is that in the case of insurance the small risk of being wiped out financially vs the certain cost of premiums the expected value is negative (for insurers to be profitable) BUT because the effect on utility of losing a huge amount of money is so bad, the expected value of the utility is positive.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by pydry on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:09AM (#40623901)
Ive never seen a definition of utility which wasn't self referencing.

It's a highly unscientific concept.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bluecalm on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:24AM (#40623961)
Utility of money is just how much value one (an individual or entity) can derive from having x amount of money. Utility and value might be defined by self referencing each other but that's true for many other concepts or words in a language for that matter. It doesn't make it problematic or unscientific.

The point is that it matters how much certain amount of money or wealth is worth for you not how much wealth you have. It's an important point as it explains why calculations purely in money terms are useless for making financial decisions (as seen in example of insurance)

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by pydry on Sunday June 09, 2024 @10:49AM (#40624816)
>Utility and value might be defined by self referencing each other but that's true for many other concepts or words in a language for that matter

Precisely. Like when a priest says that "love" is "god" and "god" is "love".

Plenty of our language is deeply unscientific.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bluecalm on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:24PM (#40625512)
It's not like that at all. If you want to argue that one can't define value then I am out. If you admit "value" has well understood meaning then utility function of wealth is just how much value one can derive from it. We usually measure wealth in money for convenience. I really don't know why you are so against it. There might be a lot of nonsense associate with it but the concept itself is pretty simple and useful.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:17AM (#40624230)
> never seen a definition of utility which wasn't self referencing

It’s analogous to “holes” in semiconductors or virtual particles. You can’t directly observe it. But it’s an intuitive notion that makes many calculations easier.

Critically, there are several valid definitions of utility, e.g. the von Neumann–Morgenstern (VNM) utility theorem [1] and revealed preference [2]. Each has its own axioms, defined with varying rigour, that can be theoretically extended and practically applied.

> a highly unscientific concept

Sure, it’s unscientific in the way mathematics are unscientific: it starts with a set of axioms and extends from that. Determining whether the chosen axioms fit a particular situation is a separate, more scientific question.

That said, similar criticisms have been raised about e.g. auction theory and quantum physics, both of which (like utility-based models) make testable predictions.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Neumann%E2%80%93Morgenst...

[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revealed_preference

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by pydry on Sunday June 09, 2024 @10:46AM (#40624798)
"Utility" isnt axiomatic or analogous to holes. It's "vibes" dressed up in sciency sounding language.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by kgwgk on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:06AM (#40624923)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_representation_theorem

"In economics, a utility representation theorem asserts that, under certain conditions, a preference ordering can be represented by a real-valued utility function, such that option A is preferred to option B if and only if the utility of A is larger than that of B."

You may challenge the assumptions but otherwise it's mathematics.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:24PM (#40628778)
What’s your opinion of game theory?

> It's "vibes" dressed up in sciency sounding language

This is pop economics. (And again, as mentioned, it’s not science-y. It’s applied mathematics. It’s only when you use the model to make predictions that it becomes science-y.)

Of course, if you’ve refuted von Neumann and Morgenstern, by all means, publish. Otherwise this is the “series of tubes” equivalent for economics.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by graemep on Monday June 10, 2024 @05:16AM (#40631633)
Except that having multiple valid definitions of something that is foundational to a discipline is a bit unsettling.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by JumpCrisscross on Monday June 10, 2024 @06:24AM (#40632013)
> having multiple valid definitions of something that is foundational to a discipline

It’s foundational to one branch. Almost all of finance, for instance, doesn’t bother with utility functions.

One can similarly complain that mathematicians have different rules for parallel lines depending on geometry. Like, sure. But if you’re in the field it makes perfect sense why parallel lines don’t intersect in a Euclidean space but do in a curved one. Given utility functions are literally ordered sets of preferences, it strikes me as trivial that there would be a multitude of them. (If this bothers you, don’t look up Gödel.)

The economists who deal with utility functions are more or less applied game theoreticians. Some people have a problem with game theory and statistics because they’re unpure. Like, sure. Fine. I also have a small stable of useless opinions, e.g. raisins are trash fruit. That doesn’t mean raisins are themselves useless; it’s just my opinion that’s adding zero value in a world where raisins do.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by graemep on Monday June 10, 2024 @07:29AM (#40632409)
> Almost all of finance, for instance, doesn’t bother with utility functions.

You need the concept of utility and some (reasonable) assumptions about the shape of the utility curve to derive CAPM - at least the way I was taught it and there may be an alternative I do not know of?

I do not think there being a multitude of utility curves is a problem. It seems to be there is a lack of a clear concept.

I do not think that your analogy with maths works. Maths is is more abstract and should change with different sets of axioms. Economics is supposed to be based on observations of the real world.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:08PM (#40627638)
Number of dopamine molecules secreted by a person during his lifetime?
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by greg_V on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:26AM (#40623409)
It's a convoluted way of saying "use value" vs. "exchange value".

A million dollars is a million dollars, or it's a house. I don't need a million dollars but I do need a house or I freeze to death. I can't eat a million dollars worth of food but I need to eat food every day or I die.

Gambling is seen as immoral because it's about extending your exchange value capabilities, although most people who gamble are poor as dirt and a winning bet is often about paying your utility bills and having a day out over being able to do neither (while losing bets contribute to being unable to do either).

Insurance is seen as prudent because it acts as a fail safe over your use values, be it your health, housing, employment, etc. Social security is basically a system of spreading the odds over the population, forcing everyone to do the small bets to contain the catastrophic outlier probabilities - in theory.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bluecalm on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:46AM (#40623527)
It doesn't really matter much if you have a million dollars or a million dollar house (+/- liquidity of assets but this is not really important for the discussion).

>>Gambling is seen as immoral because it's about extending your exchange value capabilities

Why would extending your exchange value capabilities would be seen as immoral? It sounds good to me. I think you are missing the point.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by raincole on Sunday June 09, 2024 @07:06AM (#40623624)
If you have 10% chance to lose -$91 and 90% chance to get +$10, the expected value in money is -$0.1. It sounds bad.

But the relationship between utility and money isn't linear. If for you, $10 is worth 10u and $91 is worth only 89u, this deal has expected value of +0.1u.

Why and how isn't it linear? It's a hard problem that can't be answered easily. However we know it's true for most big institutions in stock and bond markets. A financial product will need to provide extra expected value in term of money to compensate the risk, otherwise no one buys it.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by LorenPechtel on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:07PM (#40626704)
In the real world it always goes the other way--the next dollar is never worth as much as the previous dollar, thus any fair bet costs more (the previous dollar) than it gains (the next dollar.)

That's why you should only engage in negative bets, aka insurance. There you are trading a next dollar (worth less) for a previous dollar (worth more).

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by GeorgeDewar on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:09PM (#40627191)
This has really made insurance click for me because while I understand it intuitively, I wanted a more scientific foundation to understand its value.

I think a great illustration is an extreme case. If I have a house and just enough income to cover all my needs and wants (including retirement savings), then depending on my attitude an extra $1000 per year might have no effect at all - I have nothing I want to spend it on and nothing to save for.

But losing my home would still be devastating. So the utility value of the $1000 per year for the rest of my life is low or none, but the utility value of the previously earned money I would lose from losing my house is high.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by raincole on Monday June 10, 2024 @02:14AM (#40630722)
I don't know why you said "the other way", cause this is the exact thing I decribed in my previous comment.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bluecalm on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:43AM (#40623512)
>>Hm I don't follow. Could you please define "expected value in money terms" vs "expected value in utility of money terms"

Imagine you have $10k to your name and flip a coin for $1k. Your expected value in money terms is $9k * 0.5 + $11k * 0.5. Your expected value in utility terms is: u($9k) * 0.5 + u($11k) * 0.5 where u is a function that tells you how much worth you get from money. See wikipedia link for some explanation (although I think the articles are over-complicated and don't convey the point in clear way):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_utility#Law_of_Dimini...

The key point is that utility is concave (a coin flip for any amount has negative utility) which is obvious when you think about it (better to be a millionaire than flip a coin to be busted or have 2 million net worth) but maybe not something most people think when making everyday decisions.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by CPLX on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:02AM (#40623867)
A simpler way of explaining it is that both activities have a negative expected value but insurance usually reduces variance while gambling increases it.

In the context of money variance is usually synonymous with instability and unpredictability. Those things are bad and it’s worth paying a fairly priced premium to avoid them.

In simple math terms gambling is essentially the opposite dynamic. Of course things that are unpredictable can be entertaining, which is why gambling is correctly viewed as a form of entertainment.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bluecalm on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:30AM (#40623989)
But why is reducing variance desirable? It's exactly because there is utility of money function which is concave. Variance being undesirable comes from the shape of utility of money function.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by CPLX on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:47AM (#40624079)
Yes that’s one factor. But there’s also a “going bust” factor which is kind of a fundamental dynamic as well.

Think of it in terms of life. Once you are dead you’re dead, it’s the end. If the variance in your life outcomes “crosses the zero line” then the game ends, even if it’s just for an hour.

You could bend your argument to cover that by arguing that the utility of that last little fraction tends to infinity. Like what would you exchange for the drink of water that would save your life if you were minutes from death?

But it’s a bit strained, especially as a way to explain it to someone for whom utility is not already intuitive.

I think it’s pretty easy to understand that excessive variance leads to death or very negative outcomes.

All you need to demonstrate it is a houseplant and a supply of water, air, and sunshine. If you increase the variance of any of those three things sufficiently you quickly don’t have a houseplant any more, regardless of the average total supply.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by beaeglebeachedd on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:40AM (#40624041)
And at some point that function bends hard once you hit bankruptcy, for instance many places in US you go to jail if you run out of money, especially if you have children with someone to whom you're not currently married.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by beaeglebeachedd on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:30AM (#40623993)
Variance can be good though. Imagine you want some expensive service like a waterline for your house that's difficult to steal but you live under rules of gangsters or oppressive government so holding anything more than a little money at a time is risky.

You gamble every paycheck knowing eventually you will get a big payout. You quickly pay for the waterline and now you don't have to walk 300 ft to the well everyday.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by jprete on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:56AM (#40624127)
That's a very contrived scenario and your hypothetical response is very unrealistic. For one thing, the gangsters either wait outside the gambling joint or simply take it outright and farm the rake. For another, real communities with such dynamics don't accumulate cash, they might accumulate tangible goods or a little infrastructure but they are not going to have large sums of cash-equivalents lying around. For all kinds of reasons you need either a high-trust society or an army to accumulate liquid wealth.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by beaeglebeachedd on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:11AM (#40624196)
Informal gambling between low tier non gangster class people outside a joint is common amongst the lower class most everywhere and the whole scenario was about minimizing liquid wealth and dealing with cash intensive problems in places where cash is risky.

In the Philippines they even have a pooling system 'paluwagan' like this to make it possible for people to buy big things without a bank account or having to store large sums for large period of time which can be risky there.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by jprete on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:37AM (#40624351)
Thanks for the example.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by CPLX on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:53PM (#40625750)
Maybe but when you see seemingly irrational behavior by "the underclass" it's always worth spending a little more time trying to understand what kinds of issues they may be facing that you're not intuitively aware of.

If you've been in the position where every dollar you make gets somehow taken from you without warning for years you'd act differently. Goes from things like avoiding banks due to various fees or garnishments, up to practices of wearing expensive jewelry because it's a fairly efficient way to carry value on your person, and because you often get to keep it even when you get arrested, unlike the cash in your pocket.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bluecalm on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:53AM (#40624442)
Another example could be needing money for life saving expensive treatment for either yourself or a loved one.

That's why I mentioned that "avoiding variance" in itself is not a good argument. You avoid it for a reason and that reason is that (u(x - a) + (u + a)) / 2 < u(x) for vast majority of life scenarios.