News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by tomjen3 on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:34PM (#4061136)
I won't comment on the merits of this article, but before anybody comments, please take a moment to consider if what you to say is new. We had this dicussion recently, and having the same discussion isn't productive.
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:59PM (#4061197)
Maybe you are right and it's an old discussion. But repeating things and repeating discussions is in no way a bad thing. In fact, most of the ideas presented here on Hacker News are repeated ideas, maybe with a twist.

Either way, if you are tired of this discussions don't participate on one, but don't tell other people to not discuss. Maybe someone new here wants to express his/her ideas or maybe someone old really loves discussing this topic.

[deleted]
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by coridactyl on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:51PM (#4061172)
> For every woman who contributed in some way to the founding of the internet, there were hundreds of men. That's just reality, and to use that fact to argue any point about the state of the technology industry today is retarded.

How is it retarded to remind readers that women made critical or at least significant (if not necessarily numerous) contributions to the evolution of the technology we have today? The work of these women has been overlooked, overshadowed, ignored and discouraged throughout history so much that there is a whole month relegated to reminding US school children of that fact. You may have heard of it.

I agree that one blundering sentence does not an endorsement or thesis make, in the case of the New York Times piece. Perhaps the intent was to satirize the "lore" that it's all about men, men, men in tech, which is why women (in this case, Pao) get so much shit for even trying. Xeni took it literally. I can see where you might see that as an overreaction, but frankly the way that opening line is written doesn't instill much hope in me that the average NYT reader will catch the knowing wink, if it is in fact buried in there somewhere.

Finally, no one's saying men shouldn't receive credit for their work because they had the misfortune of being born into a gender fraught with examples of the underqualified being showered with recognition. What is being said is that women should receive credit for their work because they had the misfortune of being born into a gender fraught with examples of the perfectly qualified being mocked, ostracized and all but forgotten. If that frustrates you, I would be curious to know why.

Edit: original comment deleted. I'm a little disappointed because it indicated the writer felt a very potent irritation with the dialog on feminism/sexism in reaction to Xeni's response and I do wish we could engage each other when those difficult feelings rear up.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by angrycoder on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:29PM (#4061129)
Grace Hopper was a complete badass. Here is an interview with her on Letterman circa 1986: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZ0g5_NgRao
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by cantastoria on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:58PM (#4061194)
Women may have been invisible, but the work we did laid the groundwork for more visible advancements now credited to more famous men.

But what aspects of that work specifically led to the invention of the Internet? If "laying the groundwork" is the criteria then Newton, Tesla and Turing had a hand in inventing the Internet as well (an assertion I think few would make...). The fact that Lovelace and Hopper were women and programmers doesn't mean that "women" deserve credit for every invention that came after them.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @01:05PM (#4061210)
Of course they don't deserve credit for every invention after them. I think the basic premise is that if you are going to say that only men's contributions to computers and the Internet are important, you are probably wrong as many women have advanced the field.

If we are talking about a particular invention we can talk about specific inventors. But the Internet is not one but many technologies put together invented and developed by different people, which include men and women (maybe not specifically Lovelace).

Apart from that, saying that women did not contribute enough to the Internet, is like saying black people did not contribute enough to the invention of cars; it's mostly true, but it could be argued that that's because they were an oppressed group.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by coridactyl on Sunday June 03, 2012 @01:30PM (#4061267)
> Apart from that, saying that women did not contribute enough to the Internet, is like saying black people did not contribute enough to the invention of cars; it's mostly true, but it could be argued that that's because they were an oppressed group.

That is indeed an interesting juxtaposition, and I'd particularly note the use of the word "enough." That would suggest that in discussions on the history of technology, it is implied that there is some arbitrary threshold at which mentions of the contributions of a minority group (not necessarily an identity minority; i.e. in a women-dominated field you'd say the minority is the men, etc.) will be disqualified.

For instance, it is indeed "mostly true" that black people did not make many contributions to the automotive industry or its technological development. Richard Spikes' contribution of turn signals (http://www.snopes.com/business/origins/blackinv.asp) is perhaps notable or even significant, but not necessarily critical, so this could serve as an example of that statement. Does that mean that the hypothetical phrase "White men invented the modern automobile" in a hypothetical article about a black man being ostracized from the auto industry in 2012 is racist? Or is it merely an acknowledgment of the fact that white men get the credit because they structured the industry to give it to them, by excluding everyone else? Or is it both?

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by cantastoria on Sunday June 03, 2012 @03:04PM (#4061526)
That would suggest that in discussions on the history of technology, it is implied that there is some arbitrary threshold...

But there's nothing arbitrary here, we know who invented the Internet. None of them where women. The argument that women could have contributed but didn't "because they were an oppressed group" is just an absurd couterfactual. Who knows what would have happened? You can say anything you want...

Richard Spikes' contribution of turn signals...

Richard Spikes invented the turn signal. Full stop. Saying he contributed to the invention of the automobile is as absurd as saying that Edison or Tesla contributed to the invention of the turn signal. No one would say that because the turn signal stands on it's own. Using your line of reasoning, Richard Spikes invented the turn signal with contributions from who knows how many women and other minorities.

Or is it merely an acknowledgment of the fact that white men get the credit because they structured the industry to give it to them, by excluding everyone else?

That doesn't mean women should get a historical "participation trophy" just for being somewhere and doing something in computing while the actual inventors where developing the Internet. It's insulting to them and women (and Al Gore...).

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @02:41PM (#4061474)
No, it's not racist. When you use it to say that black people don't know anything about cars or that they can't influence the future of that, then yes, it is.
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by cantastoria on Sunday June 03, 2012 @01:15PM (#4061234)
If we are talking about a particular invention we can talk about specific inventors.

But we are talking about a particular invention and it's invention has been well documented (see "Where Wizards Stay Up Late" among I'm sure many others). If there's some alternative history here please point me to it...

part from that, saying that women did not contribute enough to the Internet, is like saying black people did not contribute enough to the invention of cars; it's mostly true, but it could be argued that that's because they were an oppressed group.

So woman *could" have contributed more to the Internet had they not been oppressed? That's a counterfactual argument one and two it doesn't change the fact that women didn't partake.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @02:48PM (#4061486)
I haven't read that book, so I cannot talk about it specifically. But I'm sure that if you try to create an exhaustive list of people involved in creating the Internet, you would wind up with an enormous list, if you are even able to complete it.

Either way, I think the problem is that we have differing views on what a particular invention is. First of all I think it's hard to define the Internet: is it just the networking? Do you count the application layer?

The problem is not that women did not contribute to the Internet, the problem is saying that this means that women cannot make productive contributions to technology or the Internet or computers in general.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by cantastoria on Sunday June 03, 2012 @03:17PM (#4061545)
But I'm sure that if you try to create an exhaustive list of people involved in creating the Internet, you would wind up with an enormous list, if you are even able to complete it.

What makes you so sure?

First of all I think it's hard to define the Internet: is it just the networking? Do you count the application layer?

From Wikipedia: The Internet is a global system of interconnected computer networks that use the standard Internet protocol suite (often called TCP/IP, although not all applications use TCP) to serve billions of users worldwide. It is a network of networks that consists of millions of private, public, academic, business, and government networks, of local to global scope, that are linked by a broad array of electronic, wireless and optical networking technologies.

But even if you wanted to include the "application layer". Who are the women that contributed to developing it?

The problem is not that women did not contribute to the Internet, the problem is saying that this means that women cannot make productive contributions to technology or the Internet or computers in general.

No it doesn't. It means that women did not contribute to the invention of the Internet. Anything else you read into that is purely your imagination.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @03:50PM (#4061605)
> But even if you wanted to include the "application layer". Who are the women that contributed to developing it?

That's not my point in that part. I was questioning the invention of the Internet as an easy to identify fact, while trying to explain that what we understand from the Internet is much much more than TCP/IP, for example HTTP, SSL, SMTP, IMAP, and many many more. And that's not even counting all the programming languages like HTML, CSS or even JavaScript. On the other end, you have all the different routing algorithms and all the hardware created to support the Internet. Where does it start being the Internet and where does it stop? That's why the list would never stop and/or be enormous.

> No it doesn't. It means that women did not contribute to the invention of the Internet. Anything else you read into that is purely your imagination.

I think that's clear because otherwise you wouldn't say it. It's like saying that the car's invention was a white people thing. Just look at the first paragraph: "Without men, we would never know what our friends were doing five minutes ago." We wouldn't have it if we didn't have women and if we didn't have humans and if we didn't have children. That sentence is true, but it does not do any good or adds any information more than implying than men were the only capable of creating the Internet.

But that's part of the interpreting part of the article. Of course we can differ. I think, in this case, either way could be a possibility, but from the tone of the article I believe that it is implied that women could not have created the Internet.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by spindritf on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:24PM (#4061122)
That's nitpicking at its worst imho and can only lead to articles that have longer disclaimers and footnotes than body.

http://www.overcomingbias.com/2008/06/against-disclai.html

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by Tangaroa on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:54PM (#4061180)
NYT: The tech industry is male-dominated and sexist.

BB: The NYT is male-dominated and sexist for pointing it out.

Flagged as bullshit.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by coridactyl on Sunday June 03, 2012 @01:46PM (#4061321)
Revised:

NYT: Ahem. LINKBAIT!!!!!114!234 Okay, now that I have your attention: "News!"

BB: facepalm You're really not helping.

NYT: Oh and PS, Pao's husband is TEH GAY!!!!

BB: Seriously?

NYT: Shut up I'm relevant.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @12:57PM (#4061188)
Really? Maybe BB did say that, but that's not of the point of the article at all. Most of it is just criticizing the NYT views that men's contributions to computers and the Internet were more important than women's contributions.
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by Tangaroa on Sunday June 03, 2012 @01:12PM (#4061227)
The "NYT view" was a crude stereotype of the tech industry and the stereotypical male nerd tech worker, introduced to justify the article's position that the tech industry is male-dominated and sexist. There's plenty wrong with it.

And as a matter of fact, the contributions of men did heavily outweigh the contributions of women because women at the time were NOT ALLOWED to become engineers in most of the United States. In the rare places where it was allowed, high school advisors discouraged women from going to college and college advisors discouraged women from taking advanced math. Society was generally sexist and the potential for women to contribute was suppressed.

In the tech industry, women were allowed to become computer operators because it was seen as a natural progression from being typewriter operators, and because the tech industry was more progressive than the NYT gives it credit for. The heavy math, engineering, and design work was mostly done by men because, with rare exceptions like Hopper, they were the only ones with the skills and training to do it.

Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by lomegor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @02:50PM (#4061489)
You are right. I was just saying what I thought the article was saying not what I believe personally. Saying that the article's argument is saying the NYT is sexist and male-dominated is an over-simplification, and in it's essential part, not true.
Re:NYT: “MEN invented the internet” by GiraffeNecktie on Sunday June 03, 2012 @01:01PM (#4061204)
Where does she say that the NYT is male dominated? Where does she say that the NYT is sexist? As far as I can tell she is only pointing out that the person who wrote the article is ignorant of reality. That has nothing to do with being male-dominated or sexist.