Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by robertlagrant on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:34AM
(#40596193)
Doesn't the first point have a probability of 1? It's the subsequent ones that become less and less likely.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by randomtoast on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:51AM
(#40596311)
Maybe my question was not right then. But my question was how likely is it that 7 randomly chosen points fall within a given 50 km band across europe. Because I want to test the hypotheses that the 7 cathedrals fall randomly in line that we see. And that one random point falls in that band is not 1.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by robertlagrant on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:03AM
(#40596406)
Yes, but I suppose even if you have 7 that line up, they may not fall in your band.
To remove that constraint, so it's just any band, I think it should be more like: given a cathedral is in a particular place, how likely is it that six other cathedrals fall in a 50km wide band aross Europe.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by randomtoast on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:27AM
(#40596617)
Okay, GPT4 said there a just 189 non-overlapping 50km bands (horizontal, vertical, and diagnoal) in Europe and then continued to calculate the chance to land those 7 points in any of the 189 bands and gave a result in the order of 10^-12.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by robertlagrant on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:44AM
(#40596731)
But diagonal at what angle? :)
I think if you set the probability of the first one at 1, then the rest works perfectly at any angle of band. I could be wrong, but intuitively that seems correct.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by jimktrains2 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:57AM
(#40596836)
You could have two points in 2 of your non overlapping bands that are less than a band's width apart.
Also, the probability of the first 2 points will always be 100% because they define the line.
Also, it's not 7 random points, it's 7 of thousands of random points.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by randomtoast on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:24AM
(#40597132)
Alright, I suppose it's not as simple to formulate the question accurately and correctly.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by robertlagrant on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:28AM
(#40606874)
> Also, it's not 7 random points, it's 7 of thousands of random points.
Ah - I missed this one.
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by 082349872349872 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:09PM
(#40600530)
search box tells me 600 choose 7 is 5e15, which implies (if google and GPT4 were correct) that there ought to be on the order of thousands of fat lines containing 7 actual cathedrals
Re:St Michael Sword investigation: Are the 7 Cathedrals on a...
by regularfry on Thursday June 06, 2024 @08:01AM
(#40596384)
It's pretty easy to Monte Carlo, even if you can't get there analytically.