News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by pdonis on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:23PM (#40588467)
I don't think it's crazy; it's competition, which is what should be happening. We want multiple private companies to be in this game, because that's the only way access to space will ever become practical at any kind of scale.
[dead]
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:38PM (#40588671)
> It’s just leisure

This describes almost all human activity outside agriculture. (EDIT: slash that—agriculture doesn’t make the cut either.) Shelter, medicine, education, transportation—none of this is biologically necessary by some measure.

It’s difficult to look at history and not see the obvious—practically unchallenged—connection between technological ambition and quality of life. Paradoxically, if you only focus on feeding and clothing your population, you never do.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by buran77 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:51PM (#40588803)
> This describes almost all human activity outside agriculture. Shelter, medicine, education, transportation—none of this is biologically necessary by some measure.

Of all things, why would agriculture be the one exception from "leisure"? On the other hand why would shelter be considered anything but a biological imperative?

Shelter is essential for survival. Agriculture is the kind of advanced organized activity developed much later than foraging or hunting.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:55PM (#40588861)
> why would agriculture be the one exception from "leisure"

You’re right. I was thinking for purposes of survival, but nomadic tribes disprove this assertion.

> On the other hand why would shelter be considered anything but a biological imperative?

Shelter beyond temporary protection from the elements is not necessary for survival, as exemplified by nomadic tribes.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by kaashif on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:17PM (#40589144)
Protection from the elements is only needed in some places. If humans simply lived in the savannah and abandoned useless technologies like shelter and agriculture, we'd all be better off.

Frankly I don't see the point of shelter. What, so we're going to live in the inhospitable environment of Europe? What would be the point? We should focus on preserving and maintaining our current home.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by pdonis on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:25PM (#40590123)
> If humans simply lived in the savannah and abandoned useless technologies like shelter and agriculture, we'd all be better off.

Depends on your definition of "better off". According to my definition, which I suspect is most people's, we're better off with modern technology, modern medicine, the Internet, etc. than we would be if we were all savannah hunter-gatherers like our ancestors 12,000 and more years ago. The very fact that you are posting here, in a conversation that wouldn't even exist if we were all savannah hunter-gatherers because the medium and the technology would never have been invented, indicates that you want at least some aspects of all that modern technology. But you can't just pick and choose.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:57PM (#40591083)
Figured they were being sarcastic, given they’re literally commenting on an internet forum, but perhaps we can be thankful, too, for the prevalence of modern psychiatry.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by pdonis on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:48PM (#40588762)
> Do we want access to space at scale?

Who is "we"? Evidently a sufficient number of people want to to make private ventures have a reasonable expectation of profit. If you personally don't want to, then just don't get involved. But why should that stop people who do want to from doing it?

> It’s just leisure.

No, it's exploration with the expectation that it will lead to profitable ventures. The same thing that led people to spend months in sailing ships traveling around the world a few centuries ago. Plenty of people back then did not want to participate--but enough people did to eventually lead to the very profitable and wealth-generating system of worldwide trade we have now.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by wwtrv on Thursday June 06, 2024 @12:07AM (#40593366)
> The same thing that led people to spend months in sailing ships traveling around the world a few centuries ago

The only real equivalent I can think of was the Arctic/Antarctic exploration. However that was massively cheaper and the environment was much more hospitable and not particularly profitable (and they couldn't send drones etc.). Most prior ventures had very practical goals and motivations and were mostly seeking a direct profit even if it didn't always work out.

> have a reasonable expectation of profit

Mainly through government funding though. The only directly profit generating activity that exists is launching satellites which on itself wouldn't really justify all the investment.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by imiric on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:02AM (#40594002)
> The only directly profit generating activity that exists is launching satellites which on itself wouldn't really justify all the investment.

In the very short-term, yes. In the mid-term, there's a lucrative industry of space tourism yet to be built. In the long-term, there are riches beyond our imagination to be exploited from asteroids and other Solar System objects. All of this should be motivating enough for companies, welwala.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by kolinko on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:38PM (#40588670)
Space has resources we could extract without damaging the environment.

(Aside from the primal human need for exploration, which brought your ancestors the where you live now - unless you live in central Africa)

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by tonynator on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:41PM (#40588694)
Why would we not want to pour resources into ensuring the survival of the human race and learning more about the universe and the possibility of extraterrestrial life?
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by pfdietz on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:56PM (#40589761)
"Ensuring the survival of the human race" is such a remote goal that it cannot be a justification for current space activities. Anything that could be done now would only create a tenuous foothold that could not survive the loss of human life on Earth.
[dead]
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by pfdietz on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:52PM (#40591952)
The argument I'm making is that self sufficient colonies are so far away that building non-self sufficient colonies isn't on the critical path.

The basic problem is the productivity needed is enormously higher than what we have now. Today, a large number of people can support a small number of people in space -- and that's with the high productivity we have with industry optimized for Earth (where, for example, repairing things and dissipating heat are much easier.)

To make a colony self-sufficient, industry has to be so productive that supporting one person in space takes the work of fewer than one person. And, that productivity has to be in space. Not just building spacecraft and stations, but all the necessary materials and interlocking webs of devices and services that an industrial economy uses.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by fullspectrumdev on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:03PM (#40588965)
In your opinion.

In my opinion, I want to fuck about on the surface of the moon.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by kspacewalk2 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:36PM (#40588641)
Yes, we want access to space at scale. Exploring space is no more "leasure" than experimental physics is a "hobby".
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by octonion137 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:46PM (#40588746)
Agree, LLMs cost millions to train and we only have a few, who knows if the next LLM will be an Einstein
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by RecycledEle on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:55PM (#40588875)
Tackling a new frontier pays off over the long term.

I understand that it can be difficult to see that far ahead.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by Wool2662 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:07PM (#40589005)
Yes, the last 5 remaining humans after the most recent climate disaster will thoroughly enjoy waving at the billionaires living on the luxury lunar retreat.

The technological advancements were nice the first time around. But diminishing returns are a thing.

I understand it can be difficult to understand that historic data does not reliably predict the future.

Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission by r7000 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:59PM (#40591101)
Why does anyone think the goal is a place for billionaires to flee to? Where does this come form? All initial efforts in the solar system will be extremely arduous. No one serious thinks otherwise.