Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by sho_hn on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:47PM
(#40588030)
If we ever get to heavy industrialization of lunar resources, how are we going to deal with the CO2 footprint of rockets?
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by dotnet00 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:06PM
(#40589882)
You'd be moving other polluting industries off-Earth, thus offsetting the footprint of things that cannot be done without said footprint.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by p1mrx on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:09PM
(#40588311)
In theory it's possible to make a carbon-neutral methane rocket based on atmospheric CO2, though that depends on how completely the methane can be burned.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by throwawaymaths on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:13PM
(#40588352)
A spacex falcon 9 contains ~as much fuel as a 747. Note: fuel, not fuel + oxidizer
Edit: falcon 9, not starship
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by MarkusQ on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:53PM
(#40588833)
Source?
I get Starship 34,000,000 kg + 12,000,000 kg vs 747 ~200,000 liters ≅ 150,000 kg, or about 1/300 th of what Starship holds.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by throwawaymaths on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:15PM
(#40589116)
Oh shit I'm sorry I am so wrong. I had calculated falcon 9. Thank you for the correction
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by SJC_Hacker on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @02:41PM
(#40588695)
Mass drivers.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by somenameforme on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:34PM
(#40590246)
There are a million viable (and often quite fun) answers here, but one is really kind of funny. What do you get when you mix oxygen and hydrogen? Water? No, of course not! You get rocket fuel! Seriously. Liquid oxygen + liquid hydrogen is a common, and highly effective, fuel that's been used for various engines such as on the Space Shuttle Main Engine.
Rockets can also be carbon negative in another way. A rocket that uses less than 50% of its fuel getting to orbit would be carbon negative, because it's spending less than 'x/2' fuel to go burn at least 'x/2' fuel away from Earth. Factor in some of the fuel coming from carbon neutral sources, and it quickly becomes quite easy for a rocket to be carbon negative.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by fnordpiglet on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:05PM
(#40591662)
The flow of mass would be the other way around. Lunar regolith has every element embedded in it and there’s little need to bring anything but bootstrapping -to- the moon. Return to earth from the moon wouldn’t be CO2 producing anywhere but the moon.
Re:Boeing Starliner launches first crewed mission
by imtringued on Thursday June 06, 2024 @02:40AM
(#40594269)
I don't remember exactly but a rocket launch has the carbon footprint of ten American citizens produce annually.
But as long as some subset of humanity believes in this humanity will keep investing in it. Not everyone has to be aligned and we can have many priorities at once, not the least of which is robotic science which I only see as mutually exclusive as long as there’s not plentiful private investment, which there is at the moment. I don’t see robotic exploration as suffering in the build out of extremely low cost launch capability and a general space infrastructure including moon infrastructure. I see it benefiting enormously as the costs and risks drop significantly.