EDIT: and it takes human children a couple years to reliably identify a cat. My 2.5 y.o. daughter still confuses cats with small dogs, despite living under one roof with a cat.
Hell, many adults would fail it. I'm not sure if I could pass such test - in my experience, you remember the important details only after first experiencing a test and realizing what exactly it is that would be useful in distinguishing the two animals.
Not if they inherit from a previous generation of AI. But even if they did, a different training speed does not imply a different capability
Not to mention the secondary arguments like - no proof that human learns faster from fewer datapoints, that's just your assumption in the sibling comment. Humans inherit information. The equivalent - fine-tuning a foundation model - is very fast to learn novel objects.
Just because someone has a Turing award doesn't mean they know what they're talking about. They are just people, with strengths and weaknesses like everyone else. But often on the extreme end of strengths and weaknesses.
> And if I have to decide whose assessment I trust regarding AI, I take the Turing award winner who worked for almost 40 years on AI over a random guy from the internet.
I'd encourage you to do your own thinking and make up your own mind.