News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by dehrmann on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:01PM (#40586593)
> We have to deal with them if something weird happens

Check back in three years once you've had to deal with OS upgrades, power outages, running out of disk space, and one of them failing.

Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by abuani on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:04PM (#40586627)
Three years sounds like a reasonably good return on investment. At that point the teams either big enough to justify paying $$ for a hosted solution, or still cheaper to buy dedicated hardware.
Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by delfinom on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:17PM (#40586805)
You can also just rent dedicated servers from hetzner or ovh for far cheaper than AWS instances with more horsepower. More expensive than a dell mini in a closet. But you get datacenter Internet and power backup.
Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by re-thc on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:51PM (#40587309)
> justify paying $$ for a hosted solution, or still cheaper to buy dedicated hardware.

Always cheaper if you have at least some demand. For the lazy fix even just get a few mac mini and it'd work fine.

Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by delfinom on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:12PM (#40586736)
It's a CI runner my dude.

You just obliterate and reinstall the base system in what 10 minutes?

Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by cr125rider on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:27PM (#40586928)
Are any of those problems challenging to deal with? Even if it’s a few expensive man hours the ROI is still quite short.
Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by barkingcat on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:24PM (#40587755)
if the break even was 4-5 months, it means compared to going to cloud vendors, in 36 months, the self hosted solution would have saved 7.2 times the cost!!

Even if within 3 years there needs to be OS upgrades, you can just e-cycle the old machines and buy brand new minipc's (with added benefit of increased performance) every time you need to upgrade, and you'd still be ahead!!

Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by jjice on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:57PM (#40588155)
We're about eight months in at the moment, so here are some current stats:

- No OS upgrades (running Ubuntu 22 LTS), but regular update

- We've had a power outage, but not during the day, so when they rebooted, they went right back to action. Same issue with a network outage in the office.

- We have hit disk space issues due to not clearing all the data we needed to. A quick SSH and an rm or two did the job, plus another 30 minutes to an hour to update a cron to remove that portion of the cache

I see what you mean for sure, and there will undoubtedly be more things that come up at some point, but with the savings, it would take quite a few engineering hours per month to lose the savings at this point.

And I won't lie, when something goes wrong, it's a nice change of pace to deal with a server instead of code once and a while. Can't actually use that for calculations, but I don't hate when it happens so far.

Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by rcleveng on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:28PM (#40591812)
When a better ROI of 4-5 months, you could just buy a new one when any of those things happen, and still be net positive.
Re:GitHub now provides Arm-based runners by bravetraveler on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:55AM (#40596334)
> Check back in three years once you've had to deal with...

This being routine, I can tell you right now how it will go. Let's start!

> OS upgrades

Distinction needed: update/upgrade.

The first is entirely automatable, some may say table stakes. This is CI - take your pick, pull vs push deployment model. Decide to update in this job or another.

Upgrades are a common problem for either hosting world. Can my software work in this new environment? Hence, CI.

> power outages

Set the firmware to return to last power state. Also buy a couple UPS' and a PDU. Fixed. The provider and networks between going away isn't so easy.

> Running out of disk space

How is this unique for them to solve? Hosted workers/cloud servers have finite disks too.

Clean your workspaces in your pipelines.

> and one of them failing.

See deployment model again. Someone else in the thread said it best, these are CI runners man.